Complaining about adulterated food — the FSSAI routeA consumer who has bought adulterated, misbranded or unsafe food in India has three concurrent legal routes — a complaint to the Food Safety Officer under the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (FSSA), which replaced and repealed the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 (PFA); a criminal complaint under Sections 274 to 276 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 [Sections 272 to 275 of the Indian Penal Code]; and a consumer complaint under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 Food Safety Officer, the Section 47 analyst,the Section 68 adjudicator
[ Everyday Law ]

Complaining about adulterated food — the FSSAI route

A consumer who has bought adulterated, misbranded or unsafe food in India has three concurrent legal routes. The principal route is the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (FSSA), which by Section 89 has an overriding effect over every other food law and by Section 93 repealed the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 and seven other earlier statutes. The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) operates through Designated Officers, Food Safety Officers, the Food Analyst and the referee laboratory under Section 47, the Adjudicating Officer under Section 68 and the Food Safety Appellate Tribunal under Sections 70 and 71. The parallel criminal route runs through Sections 274 to 276 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 [Sections 272 to 275 of the Indian Penal Code]. The third route is the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. The Supreme Court in Pepsi Foods Ltd v Special Judicial Magistrate, (1998) 5 SCC 749 settled the magistrate's jurisdiction over Penal Code prosecutions; Swami Achyutanand Tirth v Union of India, (2016) 9 SCC 699 directed enforcement against synthetic milk; Christy Fried Gram Industry v State of Karnataka, (2016) 14 SCC 587 held that the FSSA testing procedure is to be followed even where Section 270 IPC [now Section 271 BNS] is invoked. This guide sets out the architecture and the route the consumer's complaint travels.

Food adulteration in India is regulated by a single principal statute, the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (FSSA), administered by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI). The FSSA came into operational force in 2011 and, by Section 93, repealed the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 (PFA) along with seven other earlier statutes — the Fruit Products Order, 1955, the Meat Food Products Order, 1973, the Vegetable Oil Products (Control) Order, 1947, the Edible Oils Packaging (Regulation) Order, 1998, the Solvent Extracted Oil, De-oiled Meal and Edible Flour (Control) Order, 1967, the Milk and Milk Products Order, 1992, and the Standards of Weights and Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977 in respect of food. Section 89 of the FSSA gives the Act overriding effect over every other food law. The criminal provisions of the Penal Code dealing with food adulteration — Sections 272 to 275, now Sections 274 to 276 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 — survive the repeal and operate concurrently; the Supreme Court in Mahesh Ramchandra Jadhav v State of Maharashtra, 1999 and in Rajiv Kumar Gupta v State of Maharashtra, 2005 confirmed that the PFA (and now the FSSA) does not nullify the Penal Code provisions. A consumer's complaint can therefore travel one or more of three routes — the FSSA enforcement route through the Food Safety Officer, the criminal route under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita read with the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, and the consumer-forum route under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. This guide sets out the architecture.

The 2006 Act and the repeal of the PFA

The Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 was enacted to consolidate the law relating to food, to establish the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India, and to lay down science-based standards for articles of food and to regulate their manufacture, storage, distribution, sale and import to ensure availability of safe and wholesome food for human consumption. The Act came into operational force on 5 August 2011 by notification under Section 1(3). It is administered by the FSSAI, a body corporate established under Section 4 of the Act with its headquarters in New Delhi; the State governments have appointed Commissioners of Food Safety under Section 30, who supervise the enforcement of the Act in the State through Designated Officers (at the district level) and Food Safety Officers (at the sub-district level) appointed under Sections 36 and 37.

The FSSA is the special law, the special procedural code and the principal substantive law on food adulteration. Section 89 provides that the provisions of the Act shall have effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent with them in any other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law other than this Act. Section 93 repeals the PFA Act, 1954 along with the seven Orders and Rules listed above. Section 97 makes transitional provisions — pending prosecutions under the repealed Acts are saved and continue under the old law unless the food business operator opts for the FSSA's adjudication route. The Supreme Court's decision in Christy Fried Gram Industry v State of Karnataka, (2016) 14 SCC 587 held that even where Section 270 IPC [now Section 271 BNS] (malignant act likely to spread infection) is invoked for the supply of sub-standard food, the special procedure under the FSSA for testing and declaring the product as sub-standard must be followed; the FSSA is not bypassed by a Penal Code prosecution. The judgment crystallises the rule that the FSSA's analytical procedure under Section 47 is the gateway to any prosecution that depends on a finding of sub-standard or unsafe food.

Food business operator, licensing and the duties under Sections 26 and 27

The principal duty-holder under the FSSA is the food business operator (FBO) — defined in Section 3(o) as a person by whom the business is carried on or owned and who is responsible for ensuring compliance with the Act. Section 31 requires every FBO in the country (subject to the exemptions for small petty FBOs operating below a turnover threshold, who require only registration) to obtain a licence from the Designated Officer of the area. The Food Safety and Standards (Licensing and Registration of Food Businesses) Regulations, 2011 set out the application procedure, fees, conditions, validity (one to five years, renewable) and the categories of FBOs (manufacturer, processor, packer, importer, exporter, wholesaler, distributor, retailer, transporter, storage, catering, restaurant, club, dhaba). The licence number — the FSSAI number — is a fourteen-digit number that the Regulations require to be displayed on every food package and on the FBO's premises.

Section 26 of the FSSA fixes the principal substantive duty on the FBO: to ensure that the articles of food satisfy the requirements of the Act and the Regulations at all stages of production, processing, import, distribution and sale within the businesses under his control. Section 26 imposes the strict-liability framework — the FBO is responsible for any violation regardless of whether the violation was committed knowingly. Section 27 extends the same liability to manufacturers, packers, wholesalers, distributors and sellers within the FBO's chain. Section 28 imposes a recall obligation — where an FBO considers or has reason to believe that a food which it has processed, manufactured or distributed is not in compliance with the Act, it shall immediately initiate procedures to withdraw the food from the market and the consumers, and notify the Food Safety Authority. The recall obligation is the operational expression of the precautionary principle: it falls on the FBO without a regulator's order being necessary.

The Designated Officer and the Food Safety Officer

The enforcement of the FSSA on the ground is the responsibility of the Designated Officer (DO) appointed at the district level under Section 36, and the Food Safety Officers (FSOs) appointed at the sub-district level under Section 37. The Designated Officer is, in practice, the Chief Medical Officer or an officer of equivalent rank; the Food Safety Officer is a graduate science officer recruited under the State Food Safety Rules. The Food Safety Officer is the officer who visits the FBO's premises, takes samples, issues improvement notices under Section 32, and prosecutes offences under Sections 50 to 56 before the Adjudicating Officer under Section 68 (for non-criminal violations) or before the magistrate (for offences requiring imprisonment under Section 59 read with Section 42).

Section 38 sets out the powers of the Food Safety Officer — to enter and inspect any place where any food article is manufactured, stored or sold, to take samples of any food and to take any extracts, copies or records, and to seize any food which appears to be unsafe or misbranded or sub-standard. The seizure procedure under Section 38 read with the Food Safety and Standards Rules, 2011 requires the FSO to make a panchnama in the presence of the FBO and two independent witnesses, to seal the samples in the prescribed manner, and to forward one part to the Food Analyst for analysis. Section 32 allows the FSO, in lieu of immediate prosecution, to issue an improvement notice to the FBO requiring the violation to be remedied within a stated time — typically fourteen days. Failure to comply with an improvement notice attracts penalty under Section 55. The improvement-notice route is the default for first-time non-grave violations; sampling-and-prosecution is the default for unsafe-food or repeat violations.

Sampling, the Food Analyst and the referee laboratory — Section 47

The analytical procedure under Section 47 is the heart of the FSSA's enforcement architecture and the gateway to any prosecution. A sample taken by the FSO under Section 38 is divided into four parts, sealed and counter-signed by the FBO and the witnesses. One part is sent to the Food Analyst appointed under Section 45 for primary analysis. One part is retained by the Designated Officer for use in a referee analysis if the FBO disputes the Food Analyst's report. One part is given to the FBO. One part is retained by the FSO. The Food Analyst issues a report within fourteen days under Section 46 in the prescribed form — Form B (sample conforms to standards) or Form C (sample is sub-standard / misbranded / unsafe / contains extraneous matter).

Section 46(4) gives the FBO a right of appeal to the referee laboratory — a laboratory notified under Section 43 — within thirty days of receiving the Food Analyst's report. The referee laboratory's report is final and supersedes the Food Analyst's report. The two-tier analytical architecture under Section 47 — Food Analyst and referee laboratory — is the consumer's and the FBO's principal safeguard against bad sampling, contamination of samples in transit, and analytical error. The Supreme Court has, in cases under the PFA Act that continue to inform FSSA practice, emphasised that strict compliance with the sampling and analysis procedure is a condition precedent to a valid prosecution; departures from the procedure vitiate the result. The Bombay High Court in Ganesh Pandurang Jadhao v State of Maharashtra, 2016 held in the gutka and pan-masala context that in order to find out whether the food is unsafe due to an adulterant, the sample must be sent to an analyst under the FSSA procedure; a Food Safety Commissioner's order alone, without an analyst's report, does not establish the offence under Section 272 IPC.

Penalty architecture — Sections 48 to 67

The FSSA penalty architecture is layered. Sections 48 to 67 set out the substantive offences and the corresponding penalties. Section 49 lays down the general principles — proportionality, mens rea where relevant, the relevance of due-diligence defence under Section 81. Section 50 penalises the sale of food not of the nature or substance or quality demanded (up to Rs 5 lakh). Section 51 penalises sub-standard food (up to Rs 5 lakh). Section 52 penalises misbranded food (up to Rs 3 lakh). Section 53 penalises misleading advertisement (up to Rs 10 lakh). Section 54 penalises food containing extraneous matter (up to Rs 1 lakh). Section 55 penalises failure to comply with the Food Safety Officer's directions (up to Rs 2 lakh). Section 56 penalises unhygienic or unsanitary processing or manufacturing (up to Rs 1 lakh).

The grave offences — those involving unsafe food — are dealt with under Section 59 and carry imprisonment in addition to fine. Section 59 prescribes (a) imprisonment up to six months and fine up to Rs 1 lakh where the unsafe food does not result in injury, (b) imprisonment up to one year and fine up to Rs 3 lakh where injury (not grievous) is caused, (c) imprisonment up to six years and fine up to Rs 5 lakh where grievous injury is caused, and (d) imprisonment for a term not less than seven years which may extend to imprisonment for life, with fine not less than Rs 10 lakh, where the unsafe food results in the death of the consumer. Section 63 penalises the carrying on of a food business without a licence (imprisonment up to six months and fine up to Rs 5 lakh). Section 67 provides for compensation in addition to the penalty — in the event of injury or death of a consumer, the Adjudicating Officer or the court may direct payment of compensation to the victim or the victim's family.

The Adjudicating Officer and the Food Safety Appellate Tribunal

The forum for adjudication of FSSA offences depends on whether imprisonment is a possible sentence. For offences punishable only with fine (Sections 50 to 56 and 58), the forum is the Adjudicating Officer appointed under Section 68 — an officer not below the rank of Additional District Magistrate. The Adjudicating Officer holds an inquiry in the prescribed manner, gives the FBO an opportunity of being heard, and passes an order under Section 68(3) imposing penalty. The Adjudicating Officer's procedure under the Food Safety and Standards (Adjudication and Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 2011 is summary — paper-based, with limited oral hearing, on the strength of the Food Analyst / referee-laboratory report and the FBO's reply. The Adjudicating Officer's order is appealable under Section 70 to the Food Safety Appellate Tribunal.

The Food Safety Appellate Tribunal constituted under Section 70 of the FSSA — typically the District Judge designated as Tribunal for the area — hears appeals against the Adjudicating Officer's orders. The Tribunal's procedure and powers are set out in Section 71. The Tribunal is not bound by the procedure laid down in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, but is guided by the principles of natural justice. The Tribunal has the same powers as a civil court in respect of summoning witnesses, requiring production of documents, examining witnesses on oath and reviewing its decisions. An appeal from the Tribunal lies to the High Court under Section 70(6) on a question of law within sixty days. Offences punishable with imprisonment — Section 59 (unsafe food) and Section 63 (carrying on business without licence) — are tried by a magistrate of the first class on a complaint filed under Section 42 by the Designated Officer; the Adjudicating Officer route does not apply. Section 77 fixes the limitation for prosecutions at one year from the date of the offence, extendable to three years by the Commissioner of Food Safety for good reasons recorded in writing.

The Section 42 procedure for launching prosecution

Section 42 of the FSSA prescribes a particular procedure for launching prosecutions before the magistrate. The Food Safety Officer prepares a report and forwards it to the Designated Officer. The Designated Officer, after scrutiny, decides whether to launch prosecution and, if so, sanctions the prosecution and forwards the case to the Commissioner of Food Safety for sanction. The Commissioner, after scrutiny, accords or refuses sanction; sanction is to be accorded or refused within fourteen days of the Designated Officer's reference. The procedure is meant as a screening filter — to ensure that frivolous or weak prosecutions are not initiated and that the FBO's procedural rights under Section 47 (the sampling and referee-laboratory procedure) have been observed. Section 42 has been the subject of a steady line of Supreme Court and High Court decisions; the position is that strict compliance with Section 42 is a condition precedent to a valid prosecution, and a prosecution launched without the Commissioner's sanction is liable to be quashed.

The Voice-of-Consumer portal and the 1800-112-100 helpline

The FSSAI operates a Voice-of-Consumer portal (popularly known as the FSSAI consumer-complaint portal) that allows consumers to register complaints online — about adulterated food, misbranded food, unsafe food, food without an FSSAI licence number, misleading advertisements, or any other violation of the Act or the Regulations. The portal is accessible at the FSSAI website foodsafetyhelpline.gov.in and the linked compliance portal foscos.fssai.gov.in. The consumer can attach photographs of the food article, the packaging, the bill and any other supporting material; the complaint is routed to the Designated Officer of the relevant district for action. The complainant can track the status of the complaint and the action taken. The FSSAI also operates a toll-free consumer helpline at 1800-112-100, on which complaints can be lodged orally; the call is routed to the State Food Safety Commissioner's office for action. The portal and the helpline are first-mile complaint channels — the substantive enforcement action runs through the Food Safety Officer, the Food Analyst and the Adjudicating Officer or the magistrate as set out above. The portal does not, by itself, fix liability; it triggers the enforcement chain.

The Supreme Court's directions in Swami Achyutanand Tirth v Union of India, (2016) 9 SCC 699 — a public-interest petition about widespread adulteration of milk with detergents, urea, caustic soda and synthetic milk — required the Centre and the States to strengthen the FSSAI enforcement infrastructure, to test milk samples randomly, and to fix compliance timelines. The judgment is one of the principal motivations for the Voice-of-Consumer portal and the helpline, and is cited in the FSSAI's annual enforcement reports as a benchmark for compliance.

The parallel criminal route — Sections 274 to 276 BNS [Sections 272 to 275 IPC]

The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 carries forward, with renumbering, the IPC provisions on food and drug adulteration. Section 274 BNS [Section 272 IPC] punishes the adulteration of any article of food or drink so as to make it noxious as food or drink, intending to sell it or knowing it likely to be sold as food or drink — with imprisonment of either description up to six months, or fine up to Rs 1,000, or both. Section 275 BNS [Section 273 IPC] punishes the sale or offer for sale of noxious food or drink, knowing or having reason to believe it to be noxious, with the same punishment. Section 276 BNS [Section 274 IPC] punishes adulteration of drugs that lessens efficacy or changes operation, with the same punishment. The State of Uttar Pradesh by U.P. Act 47 of 1975, the State of West Bengal by W.B. Act 42 of 1973 and the State of Orissa by Orissa Act 3 of 1999 have amended Sections 272 to 276 IPC to make the offences punishable with imprisonment for life and to make them cognizable, non-bailable and triable by the Court of Session in those States; these State amendments survive the IPC's repeal and continue to apply under the BNS by virtue of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 and the saving clauses of the BNS.

The Supreme Court in Joseph Kurian v State of Kerala, AIR 1995 SC 4 — a Section 272 IPC prosecution arising from adulteration of liquor — held that the offence is complete on the introduction of the adulterant into the food or drink, provided it is meant for sale, actual or likely. The Court in Pepsi Foods Ltd v Special Judicial Magistrate, (1998) 5 SCC 749 settled the magistrate's jurisdiction to take cognisance of a Penal Code prosecution for food adulteration on a private complaint, and laid down the framework for quashing such prosecutions where the criminal complaint is an abuse of process. The Supreme Court in Rajiv Kumar Gupta v State of Maharashtra, 2005 held that there is no bar under the PFA Act, 1954 (now the FSSA) to a concurrent prosecution under the IPC; the special statute and the Penal Code operate in parallel. The Supreme Court in Mahesh Ramchandra Jadhav v State of Maharashtra, 1999 confirmed the same point — there is no provision in the PFA Act (and now the FSSA) that nullifies Sections 270 to 273 IPC or makes them dormant.

The criminal route is therefore available to the consumer in addition to the FSSA route. A First Information Report can be filed under Section 173 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 [Section 154 CrPC] at the police station of the area where the food was sold, alleging an offence under Sections 274 to 276 BNS. A private complaint can be filed before the magistrate under Section 223 of the BNSS [Section 200 CrPC]; in the case of Christy Fried Gram Industry and Ganesh Pandurang Jadhao, the courts have emphasised that the prosecution must depend on a Section 47 FSSA analysis of the sample, not a bare allegation of adulteration.

The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 route

The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 provides a third route. Adulterated, misbranded, unsafe or sub-standard food is a "defect" within Section 2(11) of the 2019 Act; the food article is a "product" within Section 2(34); the sale or supply of the food is a "service" within Section 2(46) where applicable. The consumer can file a complaint before the District Commission under Section 35 (pecuniary jurisdiction up to Rs 50 lakh), the State Commission (up to Rs 2 crore) or the National Commission (above Rs 2 crore). The complaint can claim a refund, replacement, compensation for injury or loss caused by consumption of the food, and exemplary damages. The 2019 Act introduced a product-liability framework in Chapter VI (Sections 82 to 87) — under which the manufacturer, the product service provider and the product seller can each be held liable for harm caused by a defective product, subject to the defences in Section 87. The consumer-forum route runs in parallel with the FSSA and BNS routes; the consumer can choose one or pursue more than one concurrently.

The choice between the three routes turns on what the consumer wants. The FSSA route is the route of choice where the consumer's principal interest is in stopping the violation — getting the FBO's licence suspended, getting the product recalled, getting a penalty imposed on the FBO. The consumer-forum route is the route of choice where the consumer's principal interest is in monetary compensation for personal injury or financial loss. The criminal route is the route of choice where the conduct is grave enough to warrant prosecution and where the consumer wants the additional pressure of an FIR and a magistrate's process on the FBO. The three routes are not exclusive and can be combined.

What this architecture produces

The FSSA-and-BNS-and-CPA architecture produces, in working effect, a coordinated regulatory regime in which the principal substantive obligation falls on the food business operator under Section 26, the principal enforcement instrument is the Food Safety Officer's sampling-and-analysis procedure under Sections 38 and 47, the principal forum for non-imprisonment penalties is the Adjudicating Officer under Section 68 with appeal to the Food Safety Appellate Tribunal under Sections 70 and 71, and the principal forum for imprisonment offences is the magistrate's court on a Section 42 prosecution. The Penal Code provisions on adulteration — Sections 274 to 276 BNS — survive as a parallel criminal route that the State governments of UP, West Bengal and Orissa have made more potent by their local amendments. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 provides a parallel civil-compensation route. The Supreme Court's decisions in Pepsi Foods, Swami Achyutanand Tirth and Christy Fried Gram Industry calibrate the relationship between the three routes — the FSSA is the special law that supplies the analytical procedure; the BNS and the CPA run concurrently; the consumer's complaint can travel any one or all three.

The principal practical risk for a consumer's complaint is the sampling-and-analysis procedure. The complaint will succeed or fail on whether the Food Safety Officer's sample is taken in compliance with Section 47, whether the Food Analyst's report is in order, and whether the FBO's right of referee analysis has been observed. The principal practical risk for a Food Business Operator is the strict-liability framework under Section 26 — the FBO is liable for violations within the chain regardless of personal knowledge, subject only to the limited due-diligence defence under Section 81. The architecture works best when consumers understand which route is best for the relief they want and the regulator understands that the Section 47 analytical procedure is the spine on which every successful prosecution sits.