Justice D.B. Chakravarthy Madras HC PETITION ALLOWED A death abroad can still beinvestigated from home
[ Madras High Court ]

Nurse died in Oman, mother got no answers: Madras HC maps the route to India-Oman legal aid

Justice D. Bharatha Chakravarthy held that the hospital records disclose an unnatural death and directed an FIR in Puducherry, a request to the Home Ministry and a mutual legal assistance request to Oman.

A Puducherry woman received her daughter’s body from Oman embalmed and sealed, with no explanation of how a staff nurse had died overnight. Her representation to the Puducherry authorities drew no response.

On 18 November, the Madras High Court allowed her writ petition. Justice D. Bharatha Chakravarthy set out how the death can be investigated: a first information report in Puducherry, a request through the Ministry of Home Affairs, and a mutual legal assistance request to Oman.

A call at 3.30 in the morning

The petitioner, Dhanalakshmi, said her daughter, a qualified nurse, had been working as a staff nurse at a hospital in Muscat since her appointment on 18 July 2022. They spoke for about 30 minutes on 4 April 2025.

At about 3.30 in the morning Indian time the next day, the hospital called to say she had been admitted in critical condition.

About 5 in the morning, it called again to say she had died. No cause was given.

An email from the hospital on 3 August 2025 said it was following up with the police and would obtain the post-mortem report. She heard nothing further.

She submitted a representation on 15 December 2025 to the Puducherry District Collector, who passed it to the Home Department. She received no response and moved the High Court, asking that her daughter’s death be investigated through the Indian Embassy in Oman.

What the Union placed on record

The Ministry of Home Affairs produced a laboratory report and a discharge summary dated 4 April 2025, and a death form from Oman dated 7 April 2025. Counsel K.R. Samratt said the records show she was admitted unwell and that only dehydration was noted at first.

Her condition then worsened. She became unresponsive and began frothing at the mouth, and her pupils were dilated.

She suffered a cardiac arrest at about 12.45 at night and was declared dead at 1.36 in the early hours of 5 April 2025.

The Union said her flatmate had found an empty tube of rat poison, zinc phosphide, in her room, and that she was treated on that footing. The petitioner suspects that the circumstances are being concealed.

The 2019 guidelines and the treaty

Government Advocate Ramasamy Meiyappan, for the Puducherry authorities, said they had forwarded the grievance to the Centre, which must pursue it with Oman. Counsel also produced a flowchart for suspicious deaths and the Home Ministry’s guidelines of 4 December 2019 on investigation abroad and letters rogatory.

Under those guidelines, the family could lodge a complaint with the jurisdictional police. The Ministry would then invoke the India-Oman Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty with a specific request for hospital and forensic records, CCTV footage, witness statements, police records and employer records.

The request would go through diplomatic channels to the Royal Oman Police. The authorities there would investigate and return the evidence, and the Indian agency would take further action, including prosecution if warranted.

The court had been giving the Union time to obtain the post-mortem certificate. Despite repeated emails, the Omani authorities had not sent it.

The court’s finding and its directions

Justice Chakravarthy held that the records, especially the discharge summary, point to an unnatural death. That was enough to start an investigation.

“Disclose an unnatural death” (para 17)

The petitioner may lodge a complaint with the police, who must register an FIR on the unnatural death under Section 194 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. The investigating authority will then forward a request, with a copy of the FIR, to the Ministry through the designated login given to the Puducherry Police.

The Ministry must examine the request and send a mutual legal assistance request under the treaty through the Embassy. The investigation report is to be obtained from the Royal Oman Police and sent to the Indian investigating authority, which will act on it.

Order

The writ petition was allowed on those terms. The Inspector of Police, Odian Salai police station, had been impleaded on the court’s own motion on 12 August 2026.

No costs were awarded.