Justice M.S. Kumar Madras HC PETITION DISMISSED One application, one subject, and arank list that did not move
[ Madras High Court ]

Ranked 571 in Botany, he sought a place among 72 in another subject: Madras HC sees afterthought

Justice Mummineni Sudheer Kumar held that a candidate who applied for Assistant Professor in Botany, ticked direct subject and uploaded no equivalence order could not claim a second post, but spared him costs because he is unemployed.

S Marimuthu cleared the written test for Assistant Professor in Botany with 83 marks, and his name stood at serial number 571 on the Botany list. Only 72 candidates had applied for Plant Biology and Plant Biotechnology.

On his marks he would have sat between 57 and 58 on that list.

That arithmetic, the Madras High Court said on 17 November, explained why he came to court. Justice Mummineni Sudheer Kumar dismissed his writ petition as frivolous and baseless, but imposed no costs.

One notification, 61 subjects

The Teachers’ Recruitment Board issued Notification No. 04/2025 on 16 October 2025. It invited applications for direct recruitment of Assistant Professors in the Tamil Nadu Collegiate Educational Service, for Government arts and science colleges and Government colleges of education.

Marimuthu applied online for Assistant Professor in Botany and sat both papers. The recruitment is not complete, as the oral test is still to be held.

His case: one application, two posts

His petition said his application was common for Botany and for Plant Biology and Plant Biotechnology, and the question paper for the subjects was the same. He said the Board was treating him only as a Botany candidate.

He relied on Government Order (Ms) 243 of 7 November 2022 of the Higher Education Department. It treats an MSc in Botany as equivalent to an MSc in Plant Biology and Plant Biotechnology for public employment in Tamil Nadu, and the reverse.

Senior Counsel Dakshyani Reddy appeared for him. The petition asked for a mandamus to consider him for the Plant Biology post as well and to appoint him if he came within the zone of consideration.

The Board: grouping was for the exam only

Standing Counsel R. Siddharth, for the Board, said the 61 notified subjects were grouped into 48 for the written examination. Botany, Plant Biology and Plant Biotechnology were grouped only for the paper, which gave no right to be considered for each.

The Board added that Marimuthu had marked his subject as direct, not equivalent, in the online column that asks which it is. Had he applied for Plant Biology, it said, he would have marked it as equivalent.

His hall ticket named Botany against the column for the subject applied for. The grouped subjects appeared separately on it, which the Board said showed he knew he was cleared to appear only for Botany.

Clause 8(ix) of the notification, the Board added, lets a candidate apply for one subject only. Even if he claimed to have filed two applications, his candidature could be considered against one subject and no more.

The clause that settled it

The court framed one question:

“The only question that would arise for consideration before this Court is whether the petitioner is right in contending that he has applied for the post of 'Assistant Professor' in both the subjects” (para 5)

The judge turned to Clause 8(ix), which reads: “The candidates should apply for only one subject.” The petitioner, he noted, had declared that he read the instructions, would abide by them and had checked every detail of his application.

Botany and Plant Biology and Plant Biotechnology are admittedly two different subjects. Having joined the process under a notification that allowed one subject, the court said, he could not now claim to have applied for more.

No equivalence order uploaded

The court then assumed, for argument, that he had applied for two subjects. His MSc in Botany is not a notified qualification for the Plant Biology post.

If he sought consideration there, he had to upload the equivalence order with his online application.

Paragraph 9 of the notification lists the documents to be submitted, and evidence of equivalence is at serial number (ix). The petitioner uploaded 15 documents, and Government Order (Ms) 243 was not among them.

The judge concluded that he never meant to apply for both. After the results he found himself at 571 in Botany against a list of 72 in the other subject, and, the judge said, an afterthought followed.

Frivolous, but no costs

Because the notification bars applying for more than one subject, the judge held the claim was frivolous, baseless and “nothing but an abuse of the process of this Court” (para 10).

Costs would have been fit, he said, but he refrained because the petitioner appears to be unemployed.

Order

The writ petition was dismissed with no costs, and connected miscellaneous petitions stand closed. The judgment was reserved on 19 August 2026 and pronounced on 17 November 2026.