LegalRepublic.in
LegalRepublic.in › Student Corner › BNS

MCQs

20 questions 20 minutes +1 correct · −0.25 wrong · 0 blank Read first: the explainer

Before you begin

  1. Answer in any order. Use the numbers on the right to jump between questions.
  2. Mark a question for review if you want to come back to it.
  3. Each correct answer gets 1 mark and each wrong answer loses a quarter mark. A question left blank scores zero, so skip when unsure.
  4. Submit when you are done. You will see your score, then every question with the correct answer and why.
  5. Nothing you do here is saved or sent anywhere.
15:00 0 of 15 answered
Question 1

    0 / 15
    Correct 0 Wrong 0 Blank 0 Time 0:00

    All 20 questions with answers

    Prefer to read? Every question is listed here; open a question to see the answer and why.

    1. Section 250(1) BNSS allows the accused to prefer an application for discharge within what period?

    1. Thirty days from the date of filing of the police report
    2. Sixty days from the date of commitment of the case under section 232
    3. Ninety days from the date of the first appearance before the Court of Session
    4. Sixty days from the date of supply of copies of documents under section 230
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Sixty days from the date of commitment of the case under section 232

    Section 250(1) fixes a window of sixty days from the date of commitment of the case under section 232. The last option is the period in section 262(1), which governs discharge in warrant-cases instituted on a police report and runs from the supply of copies under section 230. The other periods do not appear in section 250.

    Authority: Section 250(1) BNSS; Section 232 BNSS; Section 262(1) BNSS

    2. Section 250 BNSS (discharge in a Sessions case) corresponds to which section of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973?

    1. Section 227
    2. Section 228
    3. Section 239
    4. Section 245
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Section 227

    Section 250 BNSS corresponds to section 227 CrPC. Section 228 CrPC is the old framing of charge provision (now section 251 BNSS), and section 239 CrPC is the old discharge provision in warrant cases on a police report (now section 262 BNSS). The new feature of section 250 is its sub-section (1), the sixty-day limit for the application.

    Authority: Section 250 BNSS; Section 227 CrPC

    3. When a Judge discharges an accused under section 250(2) BNSS, what must he do?

    1. Frame a charge in writing against the accused on a lesser offence
    2. Forward the case to a Chief Judicial Magistrate for trial
    3. Record his reasons for so doing
    4. Issue notice to the complainant to file a fresh complaint
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) Record his reasons for so doing

    Section 250(2) says that if the Judge considers there is not sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused, he shall discharge the accused and record his reasons. The duty exists so that a higher court can examine whether the discharge was correct (State of Karnataka v. Khaja). No charge is framed and no case is sent to a Magistrate on discharge.

    Authority: Section 250(2) BNSS; State of Karnataka v. Khaja

    4. Meena is committed for murder. Two eyewitnesses named her in statements recorded by the police and a recovered weapon is linked to her. On her application for discharge, her advocate argues that the witnesses are unreliable and that she was elsewhere at the time. How should the Sessions Judge deal with the application?

    1. Discharge her, because an alibi raises a doubt about her guilt
    2. Discharge her, because the witnesses are interested persons
    3. Discharge her, since the Judge must weigh the evidence at this stage as at trial
    4. Reject the application, since the Judge cannot weigh witnesses or accept an alibi at this stage and the material gives ground to proceed
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) Reject the application, since the Judge cannot weigh witnesses or accept an alibi at this stage and the material gives ground to proceed

    Under section 250(2) the Judge looks at the record and documents filed with it and asks only whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding. He does not hold a trial, weigh witnesses or accept a defence of alibi, which belongs to the trial. With eyewitness statements and a linked weapon on the record, there is ground to proceed and a charge follows under section 251.

    Authority: Section 250(2) BNSS; Dilawar Balu Kurane v. State of Maharashtra; State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi

    5. Ravi is committed in a Sessions-triable cheating case. The police papers show only that a business deal went wrong between him and the complainant, with no statement or document suggesting he lied at the start. Ravi applies for discharge within sixty days of commitment. What may the Judge do?

    1. Discharge him, recording his reasons, because the material discloses at most a civil dispute
    2. Frame a charge, because the police have filed a report and the Judge must follow it
    3. Send the papers back to the Magistrate to hold a further inquiry
    4. Discharge him without reasons, because the lack of material is obvious
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Discharge him, recording his reasons, because the material discloses at most a civil dispute

    Courts treat discharge as proper where the materials disclose no offence, where ingredients are absent, or where the dispute is purely civil. The Judge is not a post office for the prosecution (Dilawar Balu Kurane). Section 250(2) requires him to record reasons when discharging, so the last option is wrong. He does not return the case to the Magistrate who has already committed it.

    Authority: Section 250(2) BNSS; Dilawar Balu Kurane v. State of Maharashtra; Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal

    6. Sanjay, committed for trial before a Court of Session, files his application for discharge with certified bank statements and an affidavit of a witness, which he says prove that he never received the money. Which statement is correct?

    1. The Judge must read them, as the application is the accused's own case
    2. The Judge may read them, but only if the prosecutor consents
    3. The accused has no right at this stage to produce documents of his own to press for discharge, as he is heard on the prosecution's record
    4. The Judge must call for the prosecution's reply on each document and decide the truth of the allegation
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) The accused has no right at this stage to produce documents of his own to press for discharge, as he is heard on the prosecution's record

    In State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi the Supreme Court held that at the stage of discharge the accused is heard on the record filed by the prosecution and has no right to produce documents or put forward a defence. His material is for the trial. Section 250(2) speaks only of the record of the case and the documents submitted with it.

    Authority: Section 250(2) BNSS; State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi

    7. On the record, the Sessions Judge finds that the material raises strong suspicion against the accused and thinks there is ground for presuming that the accused committed the offence. The accused's advocate says the Judge can still discharge because guilt is not proved. What is the correct position?

    1. The Judge may discharge, as strong suspicion is not proof
    2. The Judge cannot discharge, because strong suspicion giving ground for presuming the offence calls for proceeding to framing of charge under section 251
    3. The Judge must first order further investigation under section 250
    4. The Judge may discharge only if the prosecutor agrees
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) The Judge cannot discharge, because strong suspicion giving ground for presuming the offence calls for proceeding to framing of charge under section 251

    The question under section 250 is not guilt. If the evidence raises only some suspicion and two views are possible, the Judge may discharge (Prafulla Kumar Samal); but if there is strong suspicion leading him to think there is ground for presuming that the accused committed the offence, he cannot discharge and must proceed to section 251.

    Authority: Section 250(2) BNSS; Section 251 BNSS; Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal

    8. A Sessions Judge discharged an accused after looking only at the preliminary charge sheet. Some weeks later, on the prosecution's application, he recalls the discharge order saying that a supplementary report has been filed. What is the legal position?

    1. The recall is valid, because every interlocutory order can be reviewed
    2. The recall is valid, because a discharge order is never an express order
    3. The recall is valid if the Public Prosecutor gives notice to the accused
    4. The recall is not valid, because a discharge order is a final order and cannot be reviewed or recalled by the Judge
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) The recall is not valid, because a discharge order is a final order and cannot be reviewed or recalled by the Judge

    In Deepu v. State of M.P. a Sessions Judge discharged the accused after looking only at the preliminary charge sheet, and could not recall the order later: the Supreme Court held that a discharge order is final and cannot be reviewed. The remedy against a wrong discharge lies in revision before the High Court under section 442, not in a recall by the same Judge.

    Authority: Section 250 BNSS; Section 442 BNSS; Deepu v. State of M.P.

    9. After hearing both sides, a Sessions Judge rejects the accused's application and frames a charge by a brief order that states no reasons. The accused argues that the order is invalid because section 250 requires reasons. How should this be answered?

    1. The order is invalid, since every order under Chapter XIX must give reasons
    2. The order is invalid, since reasons are needed whenever a defence is rejected
    3. The order is valid, since the Act requires reasons only when the Judge discharges, and reasons are not required for framing a charge
    4. The order is valid only if the Public Prosecutor records the reasons for the Judge
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) The order is valid, since the Act requires reasons only when the Judge discharges, and reasons are not required for framing a charge

    Section 250(2) requires reasons for discharge. For framing a charge, section 251 asks only that the Judge is of opinion that there is ground for presuming an offence, and the Supreme Court (Lalu Prasad v. State of Bihar) has explained that reasons are not required, because giving them might prejudice the accused. The exception is a question of jurisdiction decided at that stage.

    Authority: Sections 250(2) and 251 BNSS; Lalu Prasad v. State of Bihar

    10. An accused is committed for an offence of the graver kind. The Sessions Judge, on the discharge application, frames a charge only for a minor offence and says nothing about the graver one. The accused later argues that he stands impliedly discharged of the graver offence. What is the position?

    1. He stands discharged of the graver offence by implication
    2. He stands discharged only if he applied within sixty days
    3. He stands discharged only if the prosecutor does not object
    4. There is no implied discharge: since reasons must be recorded, discharge needs an express order
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) There is no implied discharge: since reasons must be recorded, discharge needs an express order

    Because section 250(2) requires the Judge to record his reasons, discharge needs an express order. Courts have held that the idea of implied discharge, such as framing a charge for a minor offence though the accusation was of a major one, cannot survive. A silent order does not discharge the accused of the graver offence.

    Authority: Section 250(2) BNSS

    11. Consider the following statements about section 250 BNSS. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    1. The accused may apply within sixty days from the date of commitment of the case under section 232.
    2. Both the accused and the prosecution may apply for discharge.
    3. The Judge considers the record of the case and the documents submitted with it, after hearing the accused and the prosecution.
    4. The Judge must record his reasons when he discharges the accused.
    1. 1 and 2 only
    2. 2 and 3 only
    3. 1, 2 and 4 only
    4. 1, 3 and 4 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) 1, 3 and 4 only

    The accused alone applies (statement 2 is wrong: the prosecution has no such right), within sixty days from commitment under section 232 (statement 1). The Judge considers the record and the documents submitted with it, after hearing the accused and the prosecution (statement 3), and must record his reasons for discharging (statement 4).

    Authority: Section 250(1) and (2) BNSS

    12. Consider the following statements comparing section 250 BNSS with section 227 of the old Code of Criminal Procedure. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    1. Under section 227 CrPC there was no time limit and the accused could apply at any stage.
    2. Section 250 BNSS retains the test of not sufficient ground for proceeding and the duty to record reasons.
    3. Section 250 BNSS changed the test to whether the charge is groundless.
    4. Section 250(1) BNSS is new in that it fixes a sixty-day period for the application.
    1. 1, 2 and 4 only
    2. 1 and 3 only
    3. 2, 3 and 4 only
    4. 3 and 4 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) 1, 2 and 4 only

    Section 250 keeps the test (not sufficient ground for proceeding) and the duty to record reasons, which makes statement 2 right and statement 3 wrong. The change is the new sub-section (1) with its sixty-day limit (statement 4). Section 227 had no time limit, and courts held the accused could apply at any stage (Buburao v. State of Maharashtra), so statement 1 is right.

    Authority: Section 250 BNSS; Section 227 CrPC; Buburao v. State of Maharashtra

    13. Consider the following statements about the approach of the Judge at the stage of discharge. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    1. The Judge decides only whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding, not whether the accused is guilty.
    2. If two views are possible and one gives rise only to suspicion, not grave suspicion, the Judge may discharge.
    3. The Judge must scrutinise the evidence in detail as if conducting the trial.
    4. The accused may produce documents of his own to show his defence.
    1. 1, 2 and 3 only
    2. 2 and 3 only
    3. 1 and 2 only
    4. 3 and 4 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) 1 and 2 only

    Following Prafulla Kumar Samal, the Judge decides only whether there are sufficient grounds to proceed (statement 1) and may discharge if two views are possible and one raises only suspicion, not grave suspicion (statement 2). He is not to scrutinise the evidence as at a trial (Dilawar Balu Kurane), so statement 3 is wrong, and the accused cannot put forward defence documents (Debendra Nath Padhi), so statement 4 is wrong.

    Authority: Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal; Dilawar Balu Kurane v. State of Maharashtra; State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi

    14. Read the Assertion (A) and the Reason (R) given below and select the correct answer.

    A: A Judge who discharges an accused under section 250 BNSS must record his reasons.
    R: The duty to record reasons enables a superior court to examine whether the discharge was correct.
    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A

    The assertion is correct: section 250(2) says the Judge shall record his reasons when discharging. The reason is the explanation the Supreme Court gave in State of Karnataka v. Khaja: the duty to record reasons exists so that the superior court can examine whether the discharge was correct. Both statements are true and the reason explains the assertion.

    Authority: Section 250(2) BNSS; State of Karnataka v. Khaja

    15. Read the Assertion (A) and the Reason (R) given below and select the correct answer.

    A: An order framing a charge after rejecting a prayer for discharge cannot be challenged in revision.
    R: A Judge framing a charge under section 251 BNSS is not required to record reasons for doing so.
    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) A is false, but R is true

    The assertion is false: an order discharging the accused, and an order framing a charge after the discharge prayer is rejected, can both be challenged in revision (section 442 BNSS). The reason is a true statement of law, since reasons are not needed for framing a charge, but it does not support the assertion.

    Authority: Sections 250, 251 and 442 BNSS; Lalu Prasad v. State of Bihar

    16. Match List I (sections of the BNSS) with List II (description) and select the correct answer.

    List I
    1. Section 250
    2. Section 251
    3. Section 262
    4. Section 263
    List II
    P. Discharge application within sixty days from commitment under section 232
    Q. Written charge by the Sessions Judge within sixty days from the first hearing on charge in an exclusively Sessions-triable offence
    R. Discharge in a police-report warrant-case where the charge is groundless, application within sixty days from supply of copies under section 230
    S. Written charge by the Magistrate within sixty days from the first hearing on charge
    1. 1-P, 2-Q, 3-S, 4-R
    2. 1-P, 2-Q, 3-R, 4-S
    3. 1-Q, 2-P, 3-R, 4-S
    4. 1-R, 2-S, 3-P, 4-Q
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) 1-P, 2-Q, 3-R, 4-S

    Section 250: discharge in a Sessions case, application within sixty days of commitment under section 232. Section 251: charge in a Sessions case, with sixty days from the first hearing on charge for exclusively Sessions-triable offences. Section 262: discharge in a police-report warrant-case, sixty days from supply of copies under section 230, test of groundless charge. Section 263: Magistrate frames written charge within sixty days from first hearing on charge.

    Authority: Sections 250, 251, 262 and 263 BNSS

    17. Match List I (decisions) with List II (propositions) and select the correct answer.

    List I
    1. Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal
    2. State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi
    3. State of Karnataka v. Khaja
    4. Deepu v. State of M.P.
    List II
    P. Where two views are possible and only suspicion, not grave suspicion, arises, the Judge may discharge
    Q. Accused has no right at this stage to produce documents of his own
    R. Reasons for discharge are recorded so that a superior court can examine them
    S. A discharge order is final and cannot be recalled by review
    1. 1-P, 2-S, 3-Q, 4-R
    2. 1-P, 2-Q, 3-R, 4-S
    3. 1-Q, 2-P, 3-R, 4-S
    4. 1-S, 2-Q, 3-P, 4-R
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) 1-P, 2-Q, 3-R, 4-S

    Prafulla Kumar Samal: two views possible with only suspicion allows discharge. Debendra Nath Padhi: the accused has no right to produce documents at this stage. Khaja: the duty to record reasons exists so a superior court can examine the discharge. Deepu: a Sessions Judge who discharged on the preliminary charge sheet could not recall the order, as a discharge order is final and cannot be reviewed.

    Authority: Prafulla Kumar Samal; Debendra Nath Padhi; State of Karnataka v. Khaja; Deepu v. State of M.P.

    18. A Judge who frames a charge after rejecting an application for discharge gives no reasons. In which of the following circumstances must he nonetheless record reasons for that order?

    1. Where the accused asks for them
    2. Where the offence is punishable with life imprisonment
    3. Where a question of jurisdiction is raised and has to be decided at that stage
    4. Where the prosecution opposed the application
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) Where a question of jurisdiction is raised and has to be decided at that stage

    The Act asks for reasons on discharge, not on framing a charge, and the Supreme Court has explained that reasons for a charge might prejudice the accused (Lalu Prasad v. State of Bihar). The exception is where a question of jurisdiction is raised and must be decided at that stage; the Judge must then record reasons on that question.

    Authority: Sections 250(2) and 251 BNSS; Lalu Prasad v. State of Bihar

    19. Anil is tried by a Magistrate in a warrant-case instituted on a police report. Within how long may he apply for discharge under section 262(1) BNSS, and from when does the period run?

    1. Sixty days from the date of supply of copies of documents under section 230
    2. Sixty days from the date of first hearing on charge
    3. Sixty days from the date of commitment under section 232
    4. Ninety days from the date of filing of the police report
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Sixty days from the date of supply of copies of documents under section 230

    Section 262(1) allows an application within sixty days from the date of supply of copies of documents under section 230. The section 250 period runs from commitment under section 232 and applies only in Sessions cases. Sixty days from first hearing on charge is the limit for framing the charge (sections 251(1)(b) and 263(1)), not for the discharge application.

    Authority: Section 262(1) BNSS; Section 250(1) BNSS; Section 230 BNSS

    20. Which of the following correctly distinguishes discharge under section 250 BNSS from acquittal under section 255 BNSS?

    1. Discharge follows the whole trial, while acquittal comes before charge
    2. Discharge is on the record and documents before charge, while acquittal follows prosecution evidence, the examination of the accused and a finding of no evidence
    3. Both are made on the prosecution's papers, but acquittal needs reasons and discharge does not
    4. Discharge can be ordered only by a Magistrate, while acquittal can be ordered only by a Sessions Judge
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Discharge is on the record and documents before charge, while acquittal follows prosecution evidence, the examination of the accused and a finding of no evidence

    Section 250 operates before charge, on the record of the case and the documents submitted with it. Section 255 applies after the prosecution evidence is taken, the accused is examined and both sides are heard on the point, and the Judge finds there is no evidence that the accused committed the offence. Both orders are made by the Sessions Judge, and discharge needs reasons.

    Authority: Sections 250 and 255 BNSS

    More Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) pages →