In short
Every case opens with one question: who has to prove it? Section 104 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) answers it. A person who asks a court to decide a right or liability in his favour, on the basis of facts he claims are true, must prove those facts. The duty to prove is called the "burden of proof". Whoever comes to court with an allegation has to back it up.
What does Section 104 say?
Section 104 reads:
"Whoever desires any Court to give judgment as to any legal right or liability dependent on the existence of facts which he asserts must prove that those facts exist, and when a person is bound to prove the existence of any fact, it is said that the burden of proof lies on that person."
The section has two illustrations. In the first, A wants a court to punish B for a crime A says B committed; A must prove that B committed it. In the second, A claims land that B possesses, relying on facts that B denies; A must prove those facts.
Reading Section 104 one phrase at a time
- Someone must ask for a judgment. The section is triggered by a person who "desires any Court to give judgment". That is the plaintiff in a civil suit, the petitioner in a petition, or the prosecution in a criminal case.
- The judgment must depend on facts. The right or liability claimed has to turn on the existence of particular facts, such as a sale, a loan, a marriage or an act of the accused.
- The facts must be asserted by that person. The burden follows the assertion. The party who says a fact exists has to prove it; the party who merely denies it does not, at this stage, have to prove the opposite.
- The person must prove that the facts exist. Until the court is persuaded that the facts exist, or considers their existence probable, they are not proved. A party has to prove an allegation before he is entitled to a judgment in his favour.
- The burden then "lies" on him. The Act uses this phrase for the person bound to prove a fact. Put simply, the party who sets the court in motion has to prove the case it brings.
Legal burden or evidential burden?
Judges and writers use the word in two senses, and the difference matters for how the rule works in a trial.
| Point | Legal burden | Evidential burden (onus of proof) |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | The obligation to prove a particular issue in the case | The burden of leading evidence at a given stage |
| Who carries it | The party who comes to court asking for a decision | Moves from one side to the other as each adduces evidence, and when a presumption arises |
| Does it change? | Stays the same throughout the trial | Yes |
Section 104 deals with the legal burden. Section 105 (who loses if no evidence is given) is also about the legal burden, while section 106 (a particular fact) deals with the evidential burden.
Lakshmi, Joseph and the Rs 5 lakh advance
Where it applies. Lakshmi sues her neighbour Joseph in a Kochi court, saying that he agreed in writing to sell her a plot and took Rs 5 lakh as advance. Joseph denies both the agreement and the payment. Lakshmi is the one asking for a court decree, and her claim depends on facts she asserts (the agreement and the payment). Under section 104 she must prove them, for instance through the document, the witnesses to its signing and bank records.
Where it does not apply to the other side. Joseph, who simply denies the claim, does not have to prove that no agreement existed. Even if he leads weak evidence of his own, or none, that does not relieve Lakshmi of her burden. If Joseph raises a separate fact of his own, such as saying that the advance was a loan he has already repaid, he is now asserting a fact and has to prove that one.
Who begins, and what moves the burden?
- Who begins. Because the burden follows the assertion, the plaintiff normally has the right to begin leading evidence. The exception is where the defendant admits the facts alleged by the plaintiff but argues that, in law or on some additional facts, the plaintiff is not entitled to any part of the relief; in that case the defendant begins. In a criminal trial the prosecutor opens by stating the charge and the evidence by which guilt will be proved, because the accused is presumed innocent until guilt is proved.
- Criminal cases. The legal burden of proving everything essential to establish the charge lies on the prosecution and never shifts to the accused. Where an accused pleads a general or special exception, such as insanity, or a plea of alibi, the onus of proving it rests on him. In some offences the law itself lays the burden of a particular fact on the accused (a "reverse burden"), but even then the prosecution must first lead evidence which, if believed, would sustain a conviction.
- Presumptions move the evidential burden. Where a rebuttable presumption of law favours one party, the other party must rebut it. A person suing on a negotiable instrument, for example, need not at first give evidence of consideration because the law presumes it.
- Facts within one party's knowledge. The Act separately puts the burden on a party where a fact is especially within his knowledge (section 109 BSA).
- A weak defence does not help the plaintiff. Failure of a party to prove its defence does not amount to an admission, and it cannot reverse or discharge the plaintiff's burden.
- Wrong placing of the burden. Misplacing the burden of proof vitiates a judgment, but wrong placing of the onus is immaterial if no party is prejudiced by it.
- Who it applies to. The rule applies equally to corporations and individuals.
- Importance fades. Onus matters most in the early stages of a case, or where the party carrying it fails to discharge it. It is of little importance at the end, when both sides have led enough evidence for the court to decide the dispute.
Which cases fix the rule on burden of proof?
- Rangammal v Kuppuswamy, AIR 2011 SC 2344. Cited for the settled rule that if a court misplaces the burden of proof, its judgment is vitiated.
- Parimal v Veena @ Bharti, (2011) 3 SCC 545 (AIR 2011 SC 1150). Cited for the point that the burden of proving facts rests on the party who substantially asserts them, not on the party who denies them, and that a party must prove an allegation before he is entitled to a judgment in his favour.
- Lekhram and Brij Lal v State of Punjab, (1993) Supp 4 SCC 361. Cited for the point that the legal burden stays constant throughout a trial.
- Narchinva V Kamat v Alfredo Antonio Doe Martins, AIR 1985 SC 1281. Cited for the point that the burden of adducing evidence shifts from time to time, depending on the evidence led by each side at a particular stage.
- Maharashtra v Vasudeo Ramchandra Kaidalwar, (1981) 3 SCC 199. Cited for the rule that in a criminal case the legal burden rests on the prosecution and never shifts to the accused.
Section 104 beside Sections 105 and 106
| Section | Evidence Act | What it asks |
|---|---|---|
| 104 BSA | 101 | The person who asserts facts must prove them; it is about the case as a whole |
| 105 BSA | 102 | A test for finding that person: the burden lies on the one who would fail if no evidence at all were given on either side |
| 106 BSA | 103 | A particular fact: the burden lies on the person who wishes the court to believe in its existence, unless a law says that proof of that fact lies on a particular person |
Evidence Act section 101 and older citations
Section 104 BSA corresponds to section 101 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The main rule reads the same as the old section 101, so the case law decided under section 101 continues to explain it. Older books and judgments cite it as section 101.
Three mistakes to avoid
- Treating a denial as an assertion. The burden follows the assertion, not the denial.
- Thinking the burden shifts in a criminal case. The legal burden of proving everything essential to the charge never shifts to the accused.
- Mixing up burden and onus. Burden is fixed; onus can move as the trial goes on.
Common questions
Does the burden of proof ever shift?
The legal burden stays with the person who asserts the facts throughout the trial. What moves between the parties is the evidential burden, for instance when one side leads evidence that raises a presumption.
Who has the burden in a criminal trial?
The prosecution. It must prove everything essential to establish the charge, and that burden never shifts to the accused. The accused carries the onus only for particular matters such as a plea of exception or alibi, or where a statute specifically puts a fact on him.
Is the burden on a person who denies a claim?
No. The burden follows the assertion, not the denial. A defendant who only denies the plaintiff's case does not have to prove anything unless he asserts a fact of his own.
What if the court puts the burden on the wrong party?
A court that misplaces the burden of proof vitiates its judgment. If no party was prejudiced by the error in placing the onus, it is treated as immaterial.
Does section 104 apply to both civil and criminal cases?
Yes. The Act does not distinguish between civil and criminal proceedings for much of its procedure, including burden of proof. How the burden operates in a criminal trial is shaped by the presumption of innocence.
Is "burden of proof" the same as "onus of proof"?
Not exactly. Burden of proof is the legal burden, which is fixed. Onus of proof is the evidential burden, which can move as the trial goes on.
Written to help you understand the law; it is not legal advice for your case. Found a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.