LegalRepublic.in

Constitution of India/Concept explainer

Anti-Defection Law (Tenth Schedule): How Legislators Lose Their Seats for Switching Sides

The Tenth Schedule disqualifies MPs and MLAs who quit their party or defy its whip. Grounds, exceptions, the Speaker's role and leading cases.

Updated 18 November 2026 · 9 min read

In short

An MLA wins on one party's ticket, then walks across to the rival camp, or sits out a crucial vote against his own party's order. Does he keep the seat? Under the Tenth Schedule, he does not. The anti-defection law takes away the seat of an MP or MLA who abandons the party that got them elected, or who votes against the party's instructions in the House. The question whether a member has defected is decided first by the Speaker or Chairman of the House, and that decision can then be tested in the courts on limited grounds.

How did the Tenth Schedule get into the Constitution?

The Constitution (Fifty-second) Amendment Act, 1985 added the Tenth Schedule and inserted Article 102(2). The new clause makes anyone disqualified under the Tenth Schedule disqualified from membership of either House of Parliament. Article 191(2) does the same for State Legislative Assemblies and Legislative Councils. The stated aim of the 1985 amendment was to fight what its Statement of Objects and Reasons called the evil of political defections.

Before 1985, the Constitution did not mention political parties at all. The Tenth Schedule gave them a formal place for the first time.

The paragraphs of the Schedule to know:

  • Paragraph 1(a) defines "House" for the purposes of the Schedule.
  • Paragraph 2 sets out the grounds of disqualification. Its Explanation says an elected member belongs to the party, if any, that set him up as its candidate.
  • Paragraph 6 gives the Chairman or Speaker the power to decide disqualification questions and makes that decision final.
  • Paragraph 7 tried to shut out the courts altogether. The Supreme Court struck it down (see below).
  • Paragraph 8 lets the Chairman or Speaker frame rules to give effect to the Schedule.

Key numbers

  • 15 days: window for a party to condone a vote against its whip.
  • 6 months: window for a party-less nominated member to join one.
  • Two-thirds: the share of a legislature party needed for a protected merger.
  • 2003: the Ninety-first Amendment removes the protection for a one-third split.

Who loses the seat, and on what grounds?

Covered: members of both Houses of Parliament, State Legislative Assemblies and, where a State has one, the Legislative Council.

  1. Ground one: voluntarily giving up party membership. A party member is disqualified if he voluntarily gives up membership of his party. A formal resignation is not needed; the Speaker can infer it from conduct.
  2. Ground two: defying the whip. A party member is disqualified if he votes, or abstains from voting, in the House against a direction issued by his party (or a person it authorises). There are two escape routes: he took the party's permission beforehand, or the party condones his vote within fifteen days.
  3. Independent members. An independent who joins a political party after election is disqualified.
  4. Nominated members. A nominated member is treated as belonging to the party he belonged to on the date of nomination. If he had no party, he may join one within six months of taking his seat. Joining after six months leads to disqualification.

Who decides, and what else does a defector lose?

Any question whether a member has become disqualified goes to the Chairman or Speaker. If the question concerns the Chairman or Speaker himself, the House elects another member to decide it.

Under Article 361B, a member disqualified under paragraph 2 also cannot hold any remunerative political post (broadly, a salaried office under the Union or a State government) until his term would have ended or until he is elected again, whichever comes first.

Once the Speaker decides, he cannot reopen his own order; errors go to judicial review.

A confidence vote in a State: how one whip defiance plays out

A State government faces a confidence vote. The Janata Vikas Party issues a whip directing all its MLAs to vote in favour. One MLA, Harpreet Dhillon, elected on its ticket, votes against without seeking permission, and the party refuses to condone the vote within fifteen days. The party's leader files a petition before the Speaker. The Speaker hears Dhillon and declares him disqualified under paragraph 2. He loses his seat and, by Article 361B, cannot be appointed to a salaried government post for the rest of the term. If he believes the Speaker acted in bad faith or denied him a fair hearing, he can approach the High Court under Article 226 for judicial review of the order.

Who is safe from disqualification?

Situation Position
Presiding officers The Speaker and Deputy Speaker of the Lok Sabha and of State Assemblies, the Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, and the Chairman and Deputy Chairman of a State Legislative Council are protected if, on election to that post, they leave their party and do not rejoin it (or join another) while in office. They may return to their original party after leaving the post.
Mergers If two-thirds of a party's members in the House agree to merge with another party, they are not disqualified. Members who refuse the merger and choose to function as a separate group are also protected.
One-third splits The original Schedule protected a "split" by one-third of a party's members. The Constitution (Ninety-first) Amendment Act, 2003 removed that protection.

Can courts review the Speaker's decision?

Paragraph 7 provided: "Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution, no court shall have any jurisdiction in respect of any matter connected with the disqualification of a member of a House under this Schedule." It no longer operates. The Speaker's decision can be reviewed by the High Courts and the Supreme Court, but only on narrow grounds: breach of a constitutional mandate, mala fides (bad faith), violation of natural justice, or perversity. The courts will not normally step in before the Speaker has decided, except where an interim disqualification or suspension would have grave, immediate and irreversible effects.

Which cases shaped the law, in order?

Kihoto Hollohan v Zachillhu (1992) Supp (2) SCC 651. The Constitution Bench upheld the Tenth Schedule. Justice Venkatachaliah, writing for the majority, rejected the argument that binding legislators to the party line destroys parliamentary democracy, and held that the Schedule does not breach the freedom of speech or immunity of members under Article 105. Paragraph 7, however, changed the effect of Articles 136, 226 and 227, so the amendment needed ratification by half the State legislatures under the proviso to Article 368(2). Since that was not done, paragraph 7 was struck down; the rest of the amendment was saved as severable. The majority also held: "The Speakers/Chairmen while exercising powers and discharging functions under the Tenth Schedule act as Tribunal adjudicating rights and obligations under the Tenth Schedule and their decisions in that capacity are amenable to judicial review."

Dr Kashinath G Jalmi v The Speaker (1993) 2 SCC 703. In Goa, a Speaker disqualified Chief Minister Ravi Naik. After the Speaker was removed, the Deputy Speaker, acting as Speaker, reviewed and reversed that order. The Supreme Court held that the Speaker has no inherent power to review a decision under the Tenth Schedule.

Ravi S Naik v Union of India (1994) Supp (2) SCC 641. Voluntarily giving up party membership is a wider idea than resigning from the party. The Speaker may infer it from a member's conduct, including newspaper photographs and public statements.

G Vishwanathan v Hon'ble Speaker Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly (1996) 2 SCC 353. There is no such thing as an "unattached" member. A member expelled by his party still belongs to it for the Tenth Schedule, and if he joins another party he is disqualified.

Nabam Rebia and Bamang Felix v Deputy Speaker (2016). A five-judge bench dealt with the Arunachal Pradesh crisis. Justice Khehar, with Justices Pinaki Chandra Ghose and N.V. Ramana, held that "it would be constitutionally impermissible for a Speaker to adjudicate upon disqualification petitions under the Tenth Schedule, while a notice of resolution for his own removal from the office of Speaker, is pending." Justice Dipak Misra concurred with Justice Khehar and added his own reasons on Article 179(c). Justice Madan B. Lokur agreed with the conclusions on the Governor's powers, partly for different reasons, but held it unnecessary to decide the Article 179 and Tenth Schedule questions, given his conclusions and an intervening Gauhati High Court decision.

Myth versus law

Myth Law
A member must resign formally to count as having given up his party. Voluntarily giving up membership is wider than resigning; the Speaker may infer it from conduct (Ravi S Naik).
A member expelled by his party becomes independent. Expulsion does not make him independent; he still belongs to the party for the Schedule (G Vishwanathan).

Defection versus other ways of losing a seat

Other disqualifications under Article 102(1). Grounds such as holding an office of profit or being an undischarged insolvent fall under Article 102(1). Questions about those go to the President under Article 103, who must act on the opinion of the Election Commission. Defection questions go to the Speaker or Chairman under paragraph 6. The two procedures are separate and serve different purposes.

Expulsion by the party. A party can expel a member, but that is a matter between the party and the member. Expulsion does not make the member independent, and it does not end his duty to keep away from other parties. Only the Tenth Schedule's own grounds can cost him his seat.

Common questions

Does the law stop MPs from disagreeing with their party?

It allows debate inside the party, but a vote or abstention against the whip in the House can lead to disqualification unless the party gave prior permission or condones it within fifteen days.

Can an independent MLA support a government without losing his seat?

The whip rule applies to members who belong to a political party. For an independent, the ground of disqualification is joining a political party after the election.

Who decides if the Speaker himself is accused of defection?

A member elected by the House for that purpose.

Is the Speaker's decision really final?

Final in the sense that there is no appeal. It remains open to judicial review in the Supreme Court and High Courts on the limited grounds set out in Kihoto Hollohan.

Is a one-third split still a defence?

No. That protection was deleted in 2003. Only a merger supported by two-thirds of the legislature party now saves members.

Can the Governor act on defection disputes?

In Nabam Rebia, Justice Khehar's opinion held that the Governor has no role in disqualification proceedings under the Tenth Schedule; members can seek judicial review instead.

Test yourself20 questions · 20 minutesExam-style questions with marking, a timer and an explanation for every answer.Revise in two minutesMind mapThe whole topic on one zoomable page, with a PDF to download.

Written to help you understand the law; it is not legal advice for your case. Found a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.