LegalRepublic.in

Contract Law/Concept explainer

Acceptance in Contract Law

Acceptance under the Indian Contract Act, 1872: Sections 2(b), 7 and 8, the mirror image rule, silence, acceptance by conduct and leading cases.

Updated 18 November 2026 · 8 min read

In short

You quote a price, and the buyer writes back that he agrees, but at a lower rate. Is there a deal? Not yet. Acceptance is the moment the person who receives an offer agrees to it, fully and on the same terms. Once an offer is accepted it becomes a promise, and if the other requirements of a valid contract are present, both sides are bound. A reply that changes the terms is not acceptance at all. It is a fresh offer.

What do the Contract Act sections say about acceptance?

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 deals with acceptance in a group of connected provisions. The Act uses the word "proposal" for what is commonly called an offer.

  • Section 2(b) defines it: "When the person to whom the proposal is made signifies his assent thereto, the proposal is said to be accepted. A proposal, when accepted, becomes a promise."
  • Section 3 says an acceptance is made by any act or omission through which the acceptor intends to communicate it, or which has that effect.
  • Section 4 fixes when the communication of an acceptance is complete.
  • Section 7 sets two conditions: the acceptance must be absolute and unqualified, and it must be expressed in some usual and reasonable manner, unless the proposal prescribes a manner.
  • Section 8 recognises acceptance without words. Performing the conditions of a proposal, or accepting any consideration offered for a reciprocal promise, is an acceptance.
  • Section 9 calls a promise "express" when the proposal or acceptance is made in words, and "implied" when it is made otherwise than in words.

Eight tests of a valid acceptance

  1. The acceptor must know of the offer. You cannot accept something you have never heard of. This matters mostly in reward cases.
  2. Only the person to whom the offer is made can accept it. An offer to B cannot be taken up by C without the offeror's consent. A general offer to the public, such as a reward notice, can be accepted by anyone who performs its conditions.
  3. The acceptance must be absolute and unqualified (Section 7(1)). It must match the offer on every material point, leaving nothing open for later negotiation. Lawyers call this the mirror image rule: the acceptance simply reflects the offer back. A reply that changes the price, the quantity, the delivery date, the place of payment or any other material term is a counter-offer. The Supreme Court repeated in Padia Timber Company (P) Ltd. v. Board of Trustees of Visakhapatnam Port Trust (AIR 2021 SC 341) that an acceptance with a variation is no acceptance; it is a counter-proposal that the original proposer must accept fully before a contract exists.
  4. A counter-offer destroys the original offer. Once the offeree proposes different terms, he cannot later turn round and accept the offer he has already rejected.
  5. It must be expressed in a usual and reasonable manner, or in the prescribed manner (Section 7(2)). If the offer prescribes a manner and the acceptor uses another, the proposer may, within a reasonable time after the acceptance is communicated to him, insist on the prescribed manner. If he does not object in time, he is treated as having accepted the acceptance.
  6. It may be by words or by conduct (Sections 8 and 9). Signing a document, doing the act a reward notice asks for, or keeping a benefit offered on stated terms can each amount to acceptance. Conduct counts only when it shows an intention to accept.
  7. It must be communicated. A decision kept in one's own mind binds nobody. Under Section 4, communication of an acceptance is complete against the proposer when it is put in a course of transmission to him, out of the acceptor's power, and against the acceptor when it comes to the proposer's knowledge.
  8. It must arrive while the offer is still alive. Under Section 6, an offer ends by notice of revocation; by the lapse of the time it fixes or, if none, a reasonable time; by the acceptor's failure to fulfil a condition precedent to acceptance; or by the proposer's death or insanity, if the acceptor learns of it before accepting.

An example: Jaipur chairs, a counter-offer, then a different route

Narendra Soni, a furniture maker in Jaipur, emails a hotel in Udaipur: "We will supply 40 teak chairs at Rs 6,500 each, delivered by 15 March. Please confirm by signed purchase order." Its manager, Farida Khan, replies: "Agreed, but at Rs 6,000 each." That is not acceptance. It is a counter-offer, and the maker's original offer has now gone. If the maker declines and the hotel then writes, "Fine, Rs 6,500 it is," the hotel is making a new offer, which the maker may accept or refuse.

Now suppose the hotel replies by email, "Agreed on all your terms," instead of sending a signed purchase order. The acceptance is absolute but not in the prescribed manner. If the maker raises no objection within a reasonable time and starts building the chairs, he has accepted that method under Section 7(2), and the contract stands.

When does a reply not amount to acceptance?

Reply Effect
Same terms, unqualified Acceptance; the agreement is complete
Changed price, quantity, date or other material term Counter-offer; the original offer is rejected and the new one may be accepted or refused
A mere inquiry (would you take a different price? what are your best terms?) Seeks information; offer not rejected
Absolute acceptance with an extra offer attached The acceptance stands; the added matter is simply a new offer
  • Silence is ordinarily not acceptance. Silence counts only when combined with conduct, or when the parties' relationship or past dealings justify reading it as assent. A tenant who receives a demand for higher rent and keeps occupying the premises without protest may become liable to pay it; a tenant who protests does not.
  • Provisional or conditional acceptance does not conclude a contract. In Union of India v. M/s. Bhimsen Walaiti Ram (AIR 1971 SC 2295), final bids at a liquor-licence auction were subject to the Chief Commissioner's confirmation. Until that confirmation, the bidder whose bid had been provisionally accepted was free to withdraw.
  • A promise of a formal document does not always delay the contract. If an offer is simply accepted and the parties add that the deal will be put into formal terms, the contract already exists. If the acceptance depends on further terms still to be settled, there is no final agreement.
  • Receiving money is not always acceptance. An insurer that receives a proposal form with the first premium has not accepted the proposal until it underwrites the risk and issues the policy.

Common mistakes

  • Treating a haggling reply as a yes. A varied acceptance is only a counter-proposal.
  • Reviving a rejected offer. After a counter-offer, the original cannot be accepted (Hyde v. Wrench).

When is an acceptance complete?

Agreeing is one thing; telling the offeror is another, and Section 4 fixes the moment separately for each side. A posted acceptance binds the proposer once it is posted, but binds the acceptor only when it reaches the proposer. For telephone contracts, the majority of a three-judge bench in Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v. M/s. Girdharlal Parshottamadas and Co. (AIR 1966 SC 543) held that the contract is complete only when the acceptance is heard by the offeror. Hidayatullah J dissented, reading Section 4 to cover the telephone as well.

Which cases shaped the rule?

  • Hyde v. Wrench (1840) 49 ER 132. Wrench offered his farm for £1,000. Hyde offered £950, was refused, and then tried to accept the £1,000 offer. The court held that the counter-offer had rejected the original offer and Hyde could not revive it.
  • Felthouse v. Bindley (1862) 142 ER 1037. An uncle wrote that if he heard nothing more, he would treat his nephew's horse as his for £30 15s. The nephew never replied. Because the nephew had communicated nothing, no bargain had passed the horse to the uncle.
  • Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913) 11 ALJ 489. A munim sued for a reward of Rs 501 announced in handbills for tracing his employer's missing nephew. The court held that such a claim rests on contract, and that "there can be no acceptance unless there is knowledge of the offer."
  • Haridwar Singh v. Bagun Sumbrui (AIR 1972 SC 1242). A bid for a forest coupe was provisionally accepted, subject to the Government's confirmation. The Supreme Court found no concluded contract: the Minister never confirmed the original bid, acceptance of the bidder's later offer was never communicated to him, and he had in any case revoked that later offer.
  • Bhagwati Prasad Pawan Kumar v. Union of India (AIR 2006 SC 2331). The Railways sent cheques for part of a claim, stating that encashing them would mean full and final settlement. The firm encashed them and protested later. The Supreme Court held that it had accepted the offer by conduct, in the mode the offer prescribed, while noting that conduct is acceptance only "if it is clear that the offeree did the act with the intention (actual or apparent) of accepting the offer."

Common questions

Can silence ever count as acceptance?

Ordinarily no. An offeror cannot announce that he will treat no reply as a yes. Silence may count only when coupled with conduct, or when earlier dealings justify treating it as assent.

Can I accept an offer that was made to someone else?

No. An offer can be accepted only by the person to whom it was made, unless the offeror consents. Offers made to the public at large are the exception.

Is encashing a cheque sent as full and final settlement an acceptance?

It can be. If the offer says encashment means settlement and you encash without first conveying your protest, you are taken to have accepted. A protest sent only after encashment comes too late.

The offer asked for a reply by registered post, and I replied by email. Is there a contract?

Possibly. Under Section 7(2) the offeror may insist on the prescribed manner within a reasonable time after receiving your reply. If he does not, he is treated as having accepted your acceptance.

Does acceptance have to be in writing?

Not necessarily. Acceptance may be spoken, written or shown by conduct, unless the offer itself prescribes a particular manner.

Can I withdraw my acceptance after sending it?

Only until its communication is complete as against you, that is, until it reaches the proposer. Under the illustration to Section 5, a posted acceptance can be revoked at any time before or at the moment the letter reaches the proposer.

Test yourself20 questions · 20 minutesExam-style questions with marking, a timer and an explanation for every answer.Revise in two minutesMind mapThe whole topic on one zoomable page, with a PDF to download.

Written to help you understand the law; it is not legal advice for your case. Found a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.