In short
A customer owes you Rs 6 lakh and you need cash today. Can you sell that right to someone else? Yes, if it is an actionable claim: a right to receive something that you do not yet hold in your hands: usually money someone owes you without having given any security for it, or an interest in movable goods that are not in your possession. You cannot take it physically; you can only realise it by asking for it and, if refused, by going to court. The law treats such a claim as property, so it can be sold, gifted or assigned to someone else.
Where does Section 3 draw the line?
The definition sits in Section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA). It was originally part of Section 130 and was moved to Section 3 when the chapter on actionable claims was remodelled by Act 2 of 1900. The definition covers two kinds of claim.
The first is a claim to an unsecured debt. Section 3 speaks of "a claim to any debt, other than a debt secured by mortgage of immovable property or by hypothecation or pledge of movable property". The second is a claim to any beneficial interest in movable property that is not in the claimant's possession, either actual or constructive. Both kinds must be claims "which the Civil Courts recognise as affording grounds for relief, whether such debt or beneficial interest be existent, accruing, conditional or contingent".
How such claims are transferred is dealt with in Chapter VIII of the TPA, Sections 130 to 137. Section 6(e), which says a mere right to sue cannot be transferred, marks the outer boundary of the idea.
Five tests: is my right an actionable claim?
To decide whether a right is an actionable claim, check these elements:
- A debt or a beneficial interest in movables. A debt here means an obligation to pay a liquidated, or certain, sum of money. The Supreme Court has described it as an ascertained sum due from one person to another, in contrast to unliquidated damages and compensation claims that a court or tribunal must first assess before anything becomes payable.
- The debt must be unsecured. Debts secured by a mortgage of immovable property, or by hypothecation or pledge of movables, are left out. Transferring such a debt is treated as a transfer of the property securing it, not of a bare claim.
- The movables must be out of the claimant's possession. If the claimant already has actual or constructive possession, that possession is ownership, not a claim. In Ramakrishna v Kurukal (1888), a right to recover elephants trapped on the owner's own land was held to be ownership of the elephants, not an actionable claim.
- Civil courts must recognise it. A claim that only a revenue court can hear falls outside the definition. A co-sharer's claim to profits that was cognisable only by a revenue court was held not to be an actionable claim for this reason.
- It may be present or future. The claim can be existent (due now), accruing (existing but payable later), conditional or contingent. So future salary, future book debts and future rents can be assigned, and the price payable by a buyer of land before the conveyance is executed is a contingent debt that still qualifies.
Actionable claim or not?
| Right | Actionable claim? |
|---|---|
| Arrears of rent | Yes |
| Fixed deposit with a bank (Maiyan Dalip Rajeshwari, AIR 1945 All 409) | Yes |
| Right to receive insurance money on death or maturity | Yes |
| A partner's right to an account of a dissolved firm | Yes |
| A right to get back purchase money after a sale is set aside | Yes |
| Dividends on shares (Daya Bai v Ambalal, AIR 1981 SC 156) | Yes |
| A bank's outstanding loans to its borrowers | Yes |
| A mere right to sue for damages, in tort or for breach of contract | No: a claim for defamation damages cannot be handed to another person to pursue |
| A mortgage debt | No: secured on immovable property |
| Stocks, shares, debentures, negotiable instruments and mercantile documents of title to goods | No: Section 137 takes them out of Chapter VIII altogether |
How is an actionable claim transferred, and what does notice do?
Section 130 requires a written instrument signed by the transferor or a duly authorised agent, whether or not consideration is paid. An oral assignment is invalid. The transfer is complete as soon as the instrument is executed, and from then on all the transferor's rights and remedies vest in the transferee, who can sue in his own name without joining the transferor.
Notice to the debtor is not needed for the transfer to be complete, but it protects the transferee. Under the proviso to Section 130, a debtor who pays the original creditor before receiving express written notice (in the form Section 131 prescribes) gets a valid discharge. Section 132 adds that the transferee takes the claim subject to every liability and equity that bound the transferor on the date of transfer, such as the debtor's right of set-off, even if the transferee knew nothing of it.
What if the debtor pays the wrong person? A Tiruppur garment unit
Thangam runs a garment unit in Tiruppur. A Chennai retailer owes her Rs 6 lakh for goods supplied, with no security. Thangam needs cash now, so she signs a deed assigning the debt to a finance company for Rs 5.5 lakh. That debt is an actionable claim, and the assignment is complete the day she signs. If the finance company sends the retailer a written notice and the retailer still pays Thangam, the retailer may have to pay again. If the retailer paid Thangam before any notice reached him, his payment is a good discharge, and the finance company must recover the money from Thangam instead.
Suppose instead the retailer had damaged Thangam's machine in a road accident. Her claim for compensation would be a right to sue for damages, not a debt, and she could not sell it.
When does an assignment fail or fall outside the rules?
- Writing is compulsory. A deposit of an insurance policy with a lender, without a written transfer, creates no charge on the policy.
- Pay orders are different. A pay order is a revocable instruction to a debtor to pay someone; it gives the payee no interest in the fund. An assignment creates such an interest and cannot be revoked.
- Benefit, not burden. The benefit of a contract can be assigned, but not the burden. A contract that depends on personal qualifications, or where the benefit is tied to an obligation the assignor must still perform, cannot be assigned.
- Court officers are barred. Under Section 136, no judge, legal practitioner or officer connected with a court may buy, traffic in or agree to take a share of an actionable claim, and courts will not enforce such a claim at their instance.
- Marine and fire insurance policies are excepted from Section 130.
Which decisions set the boundaries?
- Economic Transport Organization, Delhi v Charan Spinning Mills P Ltd (AIR 2010 SC (Supp) 720): An actionable claim is an ascertained sum due, distinct from unliquidated damages; a letter of subrogation is not an assignment of a mere right to sue and is valid and enforceable.
- ICICI Bank Ltd v Official Liquidator of APS Star Industries Ltd ((2010) 10 SCC 1): A borrower's outstanding is a debt due to the bank and therefore an asset the bank may validly assign; such an assignment is not trading in debts.
- Mulraj Khatau v Vishwanath ((1913) ILR 37 Bom 198): Depositing a life policy as security without a written transfer gave the lender no right to the policy or its proceeds; a later written assignee was entitled to payment.
- Bharat Nidhi Ltd v Takhatmal (AIR 1969 SC 313): The Supreme Court distinguished a revocable pay order from an assignment, and observed that a document can amount to an equitable assignment independently of Section 130.
- UOI v Sri Sarada Mills (AIR 1973 SC 281): Explaining Section 6(e), the Supreme Court said "An assignment of a mere right to litigation is bad", while an assignment of property remains valid even if litigation is needed to recover it.
Telling it apart from a bare right to sue and from a negotiable instrument
A mere right to sue. Before 1900, the definition covered every claim a civil court would grant relief on, so even a right to damages for breach of contract counted. The 1900 amendment narrowed the definition to debts and beneficial interests in movables and, at the same time, widened Section 6(e) so that it now says simply that a mere right to sue cannot be transferred. The test is whether the claimant is owed a fixed sum or holds an interest in property (an actionable claim), or only has a grievance that a court must first turn into money (a bare right to sue, held in Abu Mahomed v SC Chunder (1909) to be personal to the person wronged).
A negotiable instrument. A cheque or bill passes under the Negotiable Instruments Act by endorsement and delivery, or by delivery alone if payable to bearer, and Section 137 keeps it outside Chapter VIII. An assignee of an actionable claim needs a signed written instrument and never gets a better title than the assignor had: Section 132 puts him in the transferor's shoes. See Actionable Claim vs Negotiable Instrument.
Common mistakes
- Assuming an oral assignment will do. It is invalid; Section 130 needs a signed written instrument.
- Depositing an insurance policy with a lender and calling it a transfer. Without a written transfer there is no charge on the policy.
- Waiting for the debtor's consent. The transfer is complete when the instrument is executed.
- Skipping written notice. Until express written notice reaches him, a debtor who pays the old creditor gets a valid discharge.
- Treating a damages claim as a debt. A mere right to sue cannot be transferred.
Common questions
Is a bank deposit an actionable claim?
Yes. A fixed deposit is a debt owed by the bank, and a fixed deposit receipt is not a negotiable instrument, so it is transferred by a written instrument under Section 130.
Can a part of a debt be assigned?
High Courts have differed. Madras and Calcutta held a part of a debt cannot be assigned; Lahore held a part assignment valid if the transferor and other transferees are joined in the suit.
Does the debtor have to agree to the transfer?
No. The transfer is complete when the instrument is executed, whether or not notice is given. Notice matters because, until express written notice reaches him, a debtor who pays the old creditor is protected.
Can an actionable claim be gifted?
Yes. Section 130 was amended in 1929 to apply to transfers made with or without consideration, precisely so that gifts of such claims are covered. The gift must still be made in writing.
Is a right to future rent an actionable claim?
Yes, but an assignment of future rent must be made by a written instrument under Section 130 and must also be registered.
Written to help you understand the law; it is not legal advice for your case. Found a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.