Chief Justice S. Kant Justice J. Bagchi Justice V. Mohana Writ Petition The courts the 1993 Act promisedstill wait for a State to say yes
[ Supreme Court ]

Supreme Court asks NHRC to look at Human Rights Courts missing for 33 years, petitioner says

Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana asked the NHRC to examine Section 30 courts and, if warranted, take the issue up with States and High Courts.

A law passed in 1993 says every district may have a Court of Session designated to try human rights offences. The petitioner told the Supreme Court that in 33 years no State has set one up. On 19 November the court did not order any, but asked the National Human Rights Commission to examine the idea.

A three-judge bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana disposed of a petition by Abhinav Bharat Congress. The organisation’s founding president, Professor Dr Pankaj K Phadnis, argued the case in person after the court allowed his application.

A petition on four laws

The petition was filed under Article 32 of the Constitution and described as a public interest petition. It sought enforcement of what it called long-dormant statutory mandates for the protection of children and youth.

It rested on four sets of laws: the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, the Commissions for Protection of Child Rights Act, 2005, the Right to Education Act, 2009, and the 2016 amendment to the Preamble of the RBI Act, 1934.

During the hearing, the petitioner pressed mainly one issue. It is the failure to establish District Human Rights Courts under Section 30 of the 1993 Act.

What Section 30 provides

The petitioner averred that no such court has been established in 33 years. As a result, it said, victims of human rights violations, especially children and youth, are denied access to justice.

Under Section 30, a State Government may, with the concurrence of the Chief Justice of the High Court, notify a Court of Session in each district as a Human Rights Court. The aim is the speedy trial of offences arising from human rights violations.

Section 31 adds that a Special Public Prosecutor may be appointed for such a court.

Why the bench did not order the courts

The bench pointed to the structure of the Act. The courts can be set up only by a State Government, with the concurrence of the jurisdictional High Court’s Chief Justice.

The effective remedy, it said, is therefore to approach the State Governments and High Courts. They are better placed to judge infrastructure, suitably sensitised judicial officers, finances and other administrative arrangements.

The bench also saw the difficulty. Sending the petitioner to each High Court and State separately, it said, could cause considerable hardship and impede the cause. It then named the Commission as the better forum:

“appropriate authority to examine the issue comprehensively” (para 5)

A request to the NHRC Chairman

The court disposed of the petition with a request to the Chairman of the National Human Rights Commission to examine the matter. If the Commission finds that designating Human Rights Courts would help victims and serve the object of the 1993 Act, it may take the issue up with the State Governments and High Courts.

The order sets no deadline. The bench said it would appreciate the Commission carrying out the exercise within a reasonable period.

The other issues stay open

On the remaining issues in the petition, including those under the child rights, education and RBI Act laws, the bench expressed no opinion.

The petitioner has liberty to submit a comprehensive representation on them to the competent authorities of the Union of India and the State Governments. The order expects those authorities, if they receive such representations, to examine them in accordance with law and with regard to the larger public interest.

Order

The application to appear and argue in person was allowed. The writ petition was disposed of with a request to the NHRC Chairman, and pending applications were closed.