Rs 75 crore settlement ends 14 cases between Kolkata couple as Supreme Court dissolves marriage
Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh recorded a settlement of Rs 30 crore alimony and Rs 45 crore in trust for the child, and used Article 142 to dissolve the 2013 marriage.
A Kolkata couple married in 2013 had spent years in court, in fourteen cases and proceedings spread across Alipore and the Calcutta High Court. On 16 November the Supreme Court recorded a settlement that closes all of them. Rs 30 crore is payable to the wife as permanent alimony and Rs 45 crore for their son.
Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh wrote the order for a bench with Justice Satish Chandra Sharma. The court also dissolved the marriage in exercise of Article 142 of the Constitution.
From maintenance order to dispute over a house
Ankit Saraiya and Pooja Saraiya married on 31 January 2013. They have a son, born in 2017.
The wife began proceedings under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, as Complaint Case No 989 of 2020 before the Judicial Magistrate, 9th Court, Alipore. With it she filed a Section 23 application for interim monetary relief and alternative accommodation.
On 12 February 2025 the Trial Court ordered Rs 90,000 a month for the child’s upbringing, education and maintenance. It added Rs 60,000 a month for alternative accommodation for the wife and son. Together that was Rs 1,50,000 a month, payable from 4 August 2020.
The Hastings Park Road floors
The husband then applied under Section 25(2) of the Act. His main point was the wife’s possession of the second and third floors of 2B, Hastings Park Road, Kolkata, the shared household. On 1 July 2025 the Trial Court appointed an Advocate Commissioner to make a local enquiry into who occupied the premises.
The wife appealed that order to the Additional District and Sessions Judge, 9th Court, Alipore, in Criminal Appeal No 197 of 2025. On 12 December 2025 the appellate court set the order aside and told the Trial Court to hear the question of a Commissioner afresh.
What the Calcutta High Court did
The husband went to the Calcutta High Court in CRR No 553 of 2026. On 17 April 2026 the High Court set aside the appellate order as infructuous, because the wife had filed an affidavit saying she was in possession of the disputed household.
It affirmed the Trial Court’s observation that she could not claim alternative accommodation while also in possession of the matrimonial home. Any amount already paid for alternative accommodation was to be adjusted against the monetary relief for the child. The question of alternative accommodation charges stayed open.
A push towards settlement
The husband appealed to the Supreme Court. His counsel said the High Court order disturbed the arrangement of 12 February 2025 and that the disputes had spread across several fora. The relationship had irretrievably broken down, he said, and the court could bring the disputes to a quietus under Article 142.
The wife’s counsel opposed the appeal. The record, the order notes, showed disputes over the shared household, maintenance, alternative accommodation, custody and visitation of the child, and other connected proceedings.
While the appeal was pending, the court directed the parties to explore settlement. They took part in the process and exchanged proposals. Their counsel then told the bench that an amicable settlement had been reached.
Rs 75 crore in two parts
The terms are recorded in full. A sum of Rs 30 crore is payable to the wife as permanent alimony. A further Rs 45 crore is payable for the minor son, to be held by the wife in trust for him.
The alimony is to be paid by demand draft, simultaneously with the handover of the keys and vacant, peaceful possession of the family home at 2B, Hastings Park Road, Kolkata-700027. That is to happen within a week of the order.
A home held in trust
A residence worth up to Rs 5 crore will be bought out of the funds of the Trust and will belong to the Trust. The wife may live there until she remarries or until the son turns 25, whichever comes first.
If she remarries before he turns 25, she loses all residential rights. If he turns 25 and she has not remarried, her right to stay will be at the sole discretion of the son.
Visitation and the parenting plan
The husband’s visitation rights will follow the parenting plan of the Calcutta High Court, as set out in paragraph 32 of his proposal dated 19 September 2026. The bench considered the parenting plan he submitted and said it shall remain the same.
If the parents disagree over its interpretation or operation, or either wants a change, they must first try in good faith to settle it amicably, keeping the child’s best interests paramount. If that fails, either may go to the competent court for directions or modification.
Fourteen proceedings closed
The settlement ends all pending cases between the parties. The order lists fourteen. They include the wife’s Act VIII case and a group of FIRs and criminal cases at Police Station Alipore.
The list also covers a revision petition and a civil suit in the Calcutta High Court, and the husband’s matrimonial suit and miscellaneous case. The domestic violence complaint, a criminal appeal, an execution case and a civil suit at Alipore complete it.
Order
The bench said that, having regard to the settlement and to give “complete and effective quietus to the disputes between them”, it was exercising its powers under Article 142 (para 15). It dissolved the marriage solemnised on 31 January 2013, and directed that a decree be drawn.
The settlement forms part of the order and both parties must abide by it, including the arrangements for the child and the parenting plan.
The appeal is disposed of in those terms, along with IA No 249387 of 2026 and all other pending applications. The judgment is marked non-reportable.