Justice S.V.N. Bhatti Justice N.V. Anjaria Civil Appeal A plea that failed in 1980 willnot work now
[ Supreme Court ]

Only 9 of 28 States meet waste bylaw target: Supreme Court orders geotagged district photos

Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria reviewed the monitoring committee report on the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2026, found about 400 districts still without Special Cells, and ordered district-wise verifiable data for the next report.

Only 9 of 28 States comply with the urban bylaw target under the Solid Waste Management Rules, 2026, the Supreme Court recorded on 17 November. It then told every District Collector, through the Chief Secretaries, to upload geotagged and timestamped photographs of waste facilities.

A bench of Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice N.V. Anjaria heard the appeals.

The lead case is Bhopal Municipal Corporation v. Dr Subhash C. Pandey, Civil Appeal 6174 of 2023, taken up with Civil Appeal 7728 of 2023.

The Court monitors the Rules through the Supreme Court Monitoring Committee, or SCMC. It listed the matter for 12 January 2027 as part heard.

A report at the halfway mark

Earlier orders fixed a schedule for hearings and for periodic reports from the SCMC. The bench said the monitoring, run to the calendar the Court set, is nearing the halfway mark. The SCMC had filed a 48-page Short-Term Report with annexures running to 387 pages.

Officers from the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, the Ministry of Panchayati Raj, the Department of Drinking Water and Sanitation, the Department of Urban Development, the Ministry of Rural Development and the Central Pollution Control Board attended and helped the Court read the report.

The Court heard Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati and senior counsel Gaurav Agarwal, with Advocates-on-Record Vanshaja Shukla and Surjendu Sankar Das.

The bench said the first two phases, kickstarting the work and building the administrative machinery to monitor the Rules, are in place. The Court’s directions had travelled through the SCMC to Chief Secretaries, District Collectors and heads of local bodies, and the SCMC met every timeline set for it.

What the SCMC has delivered

The order lists the milestones. The SCMC held four meetings with constituents and stakeholders. Its letter of 10 September 2026 went to the Chief Secretaries and to the Railways, Defence, Information and Broadcasting and Education Departments, and was followed by reminders on 6 October, 27 October, 31 October and 2 November.

On the ground, 755 of 784 District Collectors are on the CPCB Portal, and Special Cells exist in 59 per cent of districts. Of 5,049 urban local bodies, 4,958 are onboarded, as are 699 of 701 District Panchayats. Special Gram Sabhas were convened in 89,102 Gram Panchayats.

The report also records 4,592 interception systems installed and 21,324.69 metric tonnes of waste removed from banks and water bodies. Restoration of 778 river stretches is underway or substantially complete. In the Swachhta Hi Seva 2026 programme, about 2.1 crore citizens out of 140 crore, across 4,861 local bodies, are claimed to have taken part.

The bench read this as clear administrative effort. But it added that the milestones, under its own orders and under the 2026 Rules, are still far from being reached.

The gaps the bench counted

About 400 districts have yet to set up Special Cells to assist their Collectors. Sixteen States do not report on rural bylaws. Eighteen do not report on four-way segregation of rural solid waste, which the Court said runs contrary to what the Special Cells are meant to deliver.

The order lists eleven deficiencies for action. The report, it said, is silent on notices served to the unorganised residential, commercial and business sectors, which an order of 18 August 2026 had called a major part of the problem. It is also silent on areas that may warrant temporary disconnection of water or electricity.

Other omissions: no detail on public-private participation, no statutory framework for corporate social responsibility (CSR) funds, nothing on biogas or waste-to-energy plants, and no consolidated figures on the waste generated and how local bodies account for it.

On CSR, the Court said the SCMC should, through a proper framework, require industrial houses to spend on waste infrastructure where the industry is located. Industries, it said, cannot argue that pollution arises in one place and the CSR money is spent in another.

Schools, Railways, Defence and the courts

The Court called educating children and making them volunteers the softest and least coercive way to change citizens’ attitudes. State Governments have not responded adequately, it said, despite SCMC reminders of 6 October and 30 October 2026.

The Railways drew sharper words. They have mapped 630 of 8,809 stations to local bodies, and only 510 premises follow four-way segregation. The Court called the response neither positive nor encouraging, and said the SCMC will issue further directions requiring complete compliance within eight weeks from 17 November.

The report carries no reply from the Ministry of Defence. Nor did the Registrars General of the High Courts send a status report or a reply, despite SCMC letters on compliance with the 2016 Rules. The one exception was the Lucknow Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal.

The bench said the judiciary should be first in carrying out the Fundamental Duty in Article 51A(g) of the Constitution, which concerns protecting and improving the natural environment.

Why a 1980 excuse will not do

The bench went back to Municipal Council, Ratlam v. Shri Vardhichand, (1980) 4 SCC 162. That case held that local bodies cannot shirk their duty on health, hygiene and habitable conditions by pleading financial inability.

India has grown substantially since then, the bench said. A plea that failed in 1980 will not work in the third decade of the 21st century. To make the point, the order refers to comparative data on the country’s standing then and now.

“Bharat is now a rich country but has poor sanitation performance.” (para 12)

The Court said the growth achieved elsewhere is negated by a dereliction it called manageable, by all stakeholders. Resources exist, it said, and what is needed is unwavering enforcement by the statutory authorities and adherence by citizens.

After reviewing all the SCMC reports, the bench observed that each organ of the State has spun on its own wheel. Parliament enacted the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and the Executive framed the Rules, yet performance under the 2016 and 2026 Rules falls short.

The Court described itself as the repository of the constitutional right to a pollution-free environment. Through the SCMC, it said, it has taken on the task of issuing a continuing mandamus to local bodies.

That effort is “not the fifth wheel” trying to drive the other four, the bench said, and it is “now or never”. The SCMC’s role will sunset into self-regulation by the contributors.

A reminder to District Collectors

The Court said it has placed its trust in the SCMC and the District Collectors across the country. It called the present Collectors meritorious, selected through the toughest competitive examination, and drew on its own experience of two or three Collectors in States where such rules were executed through the District Collector.

The order, it said, is not an inspirational quote but a reminder of what the Court expects. Failure in the ongoing work would make the situation worse and remediless. Collectors are to reinvent strategies to suit local needs and help the Chief Secretaries and the SCMC.

Directions for the next report

The Chief Secretaries must instruct all District Collectors to upload a geotagged and timestamped photograph showing the status of facilities in urban and rural local bodies as on 21 November 2026. The order also refers to the progress and state of the facilities as on 1 January 2027.

The SCMC will collate this and place a brief district-wise status report on verifiable parameters before the Court in its next report.

District Collectors are to report category-wise, including private establishments and establishments identified as bulk waste generators. Each report is to state the deficiency found, the steps taken and any notices issued for non-compliance with the 2026 Rules.

The Court said Collectors need not be told of the technology available for virtual inspection. They are to use drone surveys and video-call inspections, and to check performance on the ground through local body staff.

The Education Departments of the States must comply with the earlier orders without further delay. The Court also reproduced paragraph 8 of its order of 5 May 2026, which asked five Secretaries to explore routing industry CSR contributions into compressed biogas plants, and said it is to be implemented in letter and spirit.

Reminders go to the Railways and Defence. The SCMC, drawing on what it has learnt, is to give the Court further inputs on deficiencies in the monitoring mechanism and on remedies.

Order

The directions are to be incorporated in the SCMC’s next report, in terms of the signed order placed on the file. The Court listed the matters on 12 January 2027, to be treated as part heard.