Winning bidder never heard: Supreme Court sets aside NCLAT order scrapping Manjeera plan
Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva set aside an NCLAT judgment that invalidated a resolution plan without hearing the successful applicant, and left every issue open in the appeals pending against the plan approval.
The NCLAT declared a resolution plan invalid, though the company whose plan it was had never been made a party to the appeal. On 16 November the Supreme Court set that judgment aside for breach of natural justice, and sent the dispute over the plan back to appeals that are already pending.
Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva decided two appeals under Section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Justice Kumar wrote the judgment. It concerns the insolvency of Manjeera Constructions Limited.
A 3.3 per cent creditor objects
Corporate insolvency proceedings began against Manjeera Retail Holdings Private Limited, the principal borrower, and its corporate guarantor Manjeera Constructions Limited, on Section 7 applications by Catalyst Trusteeship Limited. The NCLT admitted the guarantor’s petition on 18 July 2023.
S2 Tech.com India Pvt Ltd was a financial creditor of the guarantor with a 3.3 per cent voting share in the committee of creditors. The resolution professional, Birendra Kumar Agrawal, issued an invitation for expressions of interest on 10 January 2024.
Four prospective applicants submitted plans: Vasavi Realty Pvt Ltd, Valentis Laboratories Pvt Ltd (VLPL), Boorugu Infra Projects Pvt Ltd and Gajjala Yoganand. The committee approved VLPL’s plan on 10 June 2024 with 91.64 per cent of the voting share.
The earnest money complaint
On 18 July 2024 S2 Tech.com filed an application, IA(IBC) 1565/2024, asking the NCLT to reject VLPL’s plan. One ground was that VLPL did not remit the earnest money deposit by the due date set in the request for resolution plans.
The NCLT rejected the application on 30 July 2024. It reasoned that S2 Tech.com, holding 3.3 per cent, had taken part in the meeting that approved the plan and had no locus to challenge approval by the majority.
The NCLT added that it still had to examine the plan against the parameters of the Code. Then, on 26 March 2025, it approved VLPL’s plan under Sections 30(6) and 31(1) on an application by the resolution professional.
An appeal without the plan’s owner
S2 Tech.com appealed to the NCLAT at Chennai on 14 September 2024 against the order of 30 July 2024. The Supreme Court recorded that it knew by then that the committee had approved VLPL’s plan, yet it did not implead VLPL.
It did not add VLPL even after the NCLT approved the plan. The Court was told that an impleadment application was in fact filed, but not pursued. It was not even numbered when the appeal was decided on 19 March 2026.
The NCLAT allowed the appeal on that day. It held that the NCLT’s order of 30 July 2024 was passed without application of mind, declared VLPL’s plan liable to be invalid, and gave various directions to the resolution professional.
The resolution professional appealed, as did Surya Treasure Island Pvt Ltd, which represents the consortium of VLPL and itself. On 13 April 2026 this Court stayed the NCLAT judgment.
Beyond the application, against a stranger
The Supreme Court said the NCLAT went far beyond the issues S2 Tech.com raised in its application. It did not decide the validity of the judgment on that basis.
The Court focused on what the NCLAT did to VLPL. The NCLAT invalidated VLPL’s plan though VLPL was not a party before it. S2 Tech.com had also never challenged the NCLT order of 26 March 2025 approving that plan.
Without hearing the party most affected, the Court said, the NCLAT passed a judgment that visited it with dire civil consequences. It found that this alone made the judgment unsustainable in law:
“flagrant violation of the principle of audi alteram partem” (para 10)
Why the Court did not remit
Separate appeals against the NCLT’s approval order of 26 March 2025 are already pending before the NCLAT. Gajjala Yoganand filed Company Appeal 200 of 2025, and the homebuyers of Manjeera Constructions filed Company Appeal 7 of 2026.
A third party, Saasa Villa LLP, filed Company Appeal 348 of 2025. The Court was informed that the timeliness of VLPL’s earnest money deposit has also been raised in these appeals.
The NCLAT had also proceeded in ignorance of the NCLT’s approval of the plan, an intervening factor that bore directly on the appeal before it. Given this, the Court was not prepared to send the matter back to the NCLAT for a fresh hearing with VLPL present.
It held that setting the judgment aside on natural justice grounds alone would suffice at this stage. That serves the interest of justice, it said, and lets every party put its stand in those duly constituted appeals.
Order
The appeals are disposed of. The NCLAT judgment of 19 March 2026 in Company Appeal (AT)(CH)(Ins) 456 of 2024 is set aside.
All issues are left open for the NCLAT in the pending appeals that challenge the NCLT order of 26 March 2025 approving Valentis Laboratories’ plan. Pending applications stand disposed of, and the parties bear their own costs.