Justice P.K. Mishra Justice S. Chandrashekhar Civil Appeal Retirement dues cannot wait onan appeal against acquittal
[ Supreme Court ]

Acquittal holds the field: Supreme Court makes DDA release gratuity of two acquitted retirees

Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed the Delhi Development Authority appeals and upheld release of gratuity, with interest, on an undertaking to refund if the State wins its appeal against acquittal.

Two Delhi Development Authority employees were acquitted in a corruption trial in 2017. Their gratuity of Rs 18,52,224 and Rs 15,43,113 was still being withheld because the State had challenged the acquittal. On 16 November the Supreme Court held that the money must be paid.

Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed the Authority’s two appeals. The retirees must each give an undertaking to refund the amount, with interest, if the pending proceedings end against them. Justice Mishra wrote the judgment.

A slum survey and an FIR

On 18 May 2001 the Anti-Corruption Branch of the Delhi Government registered FIR 29 of 2001 under Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Sections 420, 468, 471 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code. It named officials of the Authority, the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and the Slum and Jhuggi-Jhopri Department.

The allegation was that the officials carried out a joint survey of slum dwellers to decide who was eligible for relocation and alternate plots. In connivance with property dealers, they were said to have added the names of fictitious dwellers for wrongful gain.

The Vice-Chairman of the Authority granted sanction for prosecution on 8 April 2004.

Acquitted in 2017, still waiting in 2026

On 28 February 2017 the Special Judge for Prevention of Corruption Act cases convicted four co-accused. The Special Judge acquitted the two respondents and seven others, and discharged one accused for want of sanction.

The State then filed Criminal Leave Petition 481 of 2017 in the Delhi High Court under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking leave to appeal against the acquittals. On 24 August 2017 the High Court issued notice on it and on an application for condonation of delay.

The Authority promoted both men provisionally to Research Assistant (Group B), subject to the outcome of that challenge. Shri Rajender Kumar Sharma was promoted on 1 March 2019 and retired on 30 September 2021. Shri Satendra Pal was promoted on 5 April 2018 and retired on 31 December 2018.

Rule 69 and the withheld gratuity

The Authority withheld both gratuities under Rule 69(1)(c) of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, because the leave petition was pending. That rule says no gratuity shall be paid until judicial proceedings conclude and final orders are issued.

The two men made representations in 2023 for release of the gratuity. They relied on a precedent where a co-accused’s gratuity was released on an undertaking. The Authority rejected the representations.

Two courts follow Kishan Lal Taneja

Both men went to the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench. On 15 January 2026 it directed release of the gratuity with applicable interest, on an undertaking by each respondent to refund the amount with interest if the proceedings were finally decided against them.

The Tribunal relied on the Delhi High Court’s judgment of 24 May 2022 in Kishan Lal Taneja v. Government of NCT of Delhi. A co-accused, acquitted by the same judgment, had been given relief on the same terms.

The Authority challenged the orders in two writ petitions. On 25 March 2026 a Division Bench of the High Court dismissed them, saying they ought to be disposed of in terms of Kishan Lal Taneja. The Authority then came to the Supreme Court.

The per incuriam argument fails

The Authority did not dispute that relief had been given to another acquitted accused in Kishan Lal Taneja. It argued only that the decision was per incuriam.

The Supreme Court rejected that. Other similarly placed persons had also obtained relief on the strength of the decision, it said.

It named Rajinder Khurana, decided on 23 November 2022, and Laxmi Narain, decided on 24 April 2026, both against the Government of NCT of Delhi.

The reasoning in Kishan Lal Taneja, the Court added, applies equally to these respondents. They were honourably acquitted after the same full-fledged trial.

The High Court was right to hold that pendency of the State’s application under Section 378 could not justify withholding terminal dues after long service. No stay operated on the trial court’s judgment, and the application had been pending since 2017.

Why Bikram Chand Rana did not apply

The Authority also relied on Bikram Chand Rana v. Himachal Pradesh Road Transport Corporation, reported as 2026 INSC 326. The Court called that reliance totally misplaced.

That case concerned an employee whose departmental proceedings had concluded while the criminal trial remained pending. Its observations on downstream recovery were made in that setting, where Rule 69(1)(c) barred payment.

Here, the Court said, the amount became payable once the trial ended in a final acquittal. It put the position this way:

“until then, the acquittal continues to hold the field.” (para 12)

An appellate court, it added, may or may not disturb the acquittal.

What the undertaking is for

The Court said the refund undertaking exists only to balance competing equities: protecting public funds, and the right of a retired employee to receive terminal benefits earned over decades of service.

A retired employee is necessarily of advanced age, it noted. If such a person had to wait for appellate proceedings against an acquittal to end, which could take an uncertain number of years, it said the benefits would likely turn illusory.

“pensionary benefits would itself be rendered illusory” (para 13)

The employees should not suffer for the long pendency of a challenge brought by the State, the Court said, particularly when the delay is not their doing. The condition imposed by the Tribunal and the High Court, it held, adequately safeguards the Authority’s finances.

Order

The Court found no reason to interfere with the common judgment of the Delhi High Court and dismissed the Authority’s appeals, Civil Appeals 14204 and 14205 of 2026, arising from Special Leave Petitions (Civil) 24330 and 24326 of 2026.

The Tribunal’s directions stand. Gratuity is to be released with applicable interest, subject to each respondent giving an undertaking to refund the amount with interest if the pending judicial proceedings finally go against him.