Justice A.G. Masih Justice S. Sachdeva Criminal Appeal An acquittal order that neverreached the jail gate
[ Supreme Court ]

Acquitted in 2018, freed in 2025: Supreme Court lifts compensation from Rs 2 lakh to Rs 30 lakh

Justices Augustine George Masih and Sanjeev Sachdeva ordered Chhattisgarh to pay Rs 30 lakh through a supervised fixed deposit and asked every High Court to consider the jail-release checks adopted in Madhya Pradesh.

A man arrested for murder in 2012 walked out of a Chhattisgarh jail on 19 May 2025, more than seven years after the High Court had acquitted him. On 16 November the Supreme Court raised his compensation from Rs 2 lakh to Rs 30 lakh and told every High Court to look at how convicts are released.

Justices Augustine George Masih and Sanjeev Sachdeva, judges of the Supreme Court, decided Devilal Gond’s appeal in a reportable judgment written by Justice Sachdeva.

The money will not reach him as a lump sum. Most of it will sit in a fixed deposit that a district legal services authority supervises.

Acquitted in January 2018, still in prison

Gond was arrested on 7 December 2012 in a First Information Report for murder under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code. On 14 August 2013 the Sessions Judge at Rajnandgaon convicted him in Sessions Case 14 of 2013 and sentenced him to life imprisonment.

He appealed to the Chhattisgarh High Court in Criminal Appeal 968 of 2013. On 20 January 2018 the High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the conviction and acquitted him. The State did not challenge the order, so the acquittal became final.

That order carried a line about bonds. The High Court noted that Gond was on bail and directed that his surety and personal bonds, furnished when his sentence was suspended, stay operative for six months under Section 437-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

The Supreme Court said it was not brought to the High Court’s notice that Gond was in jail. The High Court, it said, was given the impression that his sentence had already been suspended.

The acquittal was never given effect. Gond stayed in custody until 19 May 2025. The judgment records the period as 7 years, 3 months and 29 days in its findings, although its opening paragraph says 21 days.

After his release he went back to the High Court with a writ petition, WPCR 505 of 2025. He asked for Rs 50 lakh for the detention after his acquittal.

High Court agreed, then awarded Rs 2 lakh

The High Court decided the writ petition on 1 May 2026. It held that the continued detention for more than seven years after acquittal was wholly illegal and arbitrary, and a violation of Article 21 of the Constitution. The explanation offered by the respondents did not justify the delay, it said.

The High Court rejected the plea of procedural formality. Administrative inefficiency or systemic lapses, it said, can never be a defence where fundamental rights are infringed. It called the case one of more than negligence, one that showed “a disturbing degree of apathy and lack of accountability” (para 17 of the High Court order, reproduced at para 7).

The High Court also said the compensation must work as a deterrent and be realistic, and that a higher award was warranted. It then awarded Rs 2 lakh.

Gond appealed to the Supreme Court only on the amount. He did not dispute the finding of illegality. The Supreme Court granted leave.

How the jail lost track of the acquittal

The State’s counter affidavit gave the sequence. On 15 May 2025, during a records-verification exercise on appeals filed by convicts in the Central Jail, officials noticed the discrepancy. They asked the Sessions Judge at Rajnandgaon for a supersession warrant, which was issued on 19 May 2025.

Gond was released the same day. Once the discrepancy was noticed, it took four days to get the paper that freed him.

The affidavit also said the Superintendent of Central Jail, Durg, had written on 3 April 2018 and 18 June 2018 to the panel lawyer of the legal aid system. He asked for the status of Gond’s appeal.

The outcome never reached the jail. The State described an unfortunate gap in communication and coordination between the jail and the other offices concerned.

An inquiry by the office of the Deputy Inspector General (Prisons) found the lapse bona fide, without any mala fide or oblique motive. The affidavit put that finding forward.

The Supreme Court did not accept the explanation as an answer. It found “complete remissness on the part of all Authorities” (para 11). It also spoke of lack of coordination and institutional dysfunction.

The bench said Gond lost his prime youth through the apathy of the authorities. Nothing could restore it, it added, and money was the only solace the court could offer.

Article 21 compensation is a public law remedy

The bench then set out the law at length. It reproduced the 1993 decision in Nilabati Behera v State of Orissa, written by Justice J S Verma.

That judgment held that compensation under Article 32 or Article 226 is a public law remedy, resting on strict liability for breach of a fundamental right.

Sovereign immunity, the Court said in that case, is no defence to such a claim. It belongs to the private law of tort. The earlier ruling in Kasturilal Ralia Ram Jain v State of UP, which upheld immunity, was confined to tort and did not apply.

The reproduced passages also traced Rudul Sah, Bhim Singh and the Privy Council’s decision in Maharaj v Attorney-General of Trinidad and Tobago. In that line, an order to pay compensation is a form of redress and may be the only practicable one.

The bench also noted Article 9(5) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which gives anyone who suffered unlawful arrest or detention an enforceable right to compensation.

Justice A S Anand, concurring in Nilabati Behera, had added a caution. Courts must act with circumspection, he said, so that Article 32 and Article 226 are not misused as a disguised substitute for a civil action.

The judgment then turned to D.K. Basu v State of West Bengal, decided in 1997. Monetary compensation, it recorded, is an appropriate and effective remedy, and sometimes the only adequate one, for a proved breach of the right to life by public officials.

The State is liable and may recover the amount from the official responsible. The citizen’s claim rests on strict liability, and sovereign immunity is not available.

What the amount is meant to do

The bench drew three working principles from these cases. First, compensation is meant to relieve the victim, not to punish the wrongdoer. Punishment is for the criminal courts, and the State must ensure the offender is prosecuted.

Second, public law compensation does not close other doors. The victim can still sue for damages, and the amount paid can be adjusted against any later decree.

Third, no uniform formula exists. The sum depends on the facts of each case.

Sohan Singh and the Madhya Pradesh checks

The judgment next recalled a similar case, Sohan Singh alias Bablu v State of MP, SLP (Crl) 11244 of 2025. The petitioner there had been kept in jail for four years and seven months after completing his sentence. The State said the supersession warrant never reached the jail superintendent’s office.

On 8 September 2025 the Supreme Court directed Madhya Pradesh to pay Rs 25 lakh. It also asked the Madhya Pradesh High Court to assign a responsible officer to check whether any other convicts were still held after completing their sentences.

On 20 November 2025 the Madhya Pradesh High Court issued directions to prevent a repeat. The bench reproduced them in full. The first set deals with the day a judgment arrives.

A copy of the certificate under Section 429 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, read with Rule 315 of the Criminal Courts Rules and Orders, goes by email to the jail, the district establishment and the District Legal Services Authority. It goes on the same day the judgment is pronounced or received, along with the judgment or order itself.

The trial court must then file a compliance report. It must carry a certificate from the jail that its records have been amended, or that the convict has been released in case of acquittal, on the same day. The legal services authority must also report that it informed the jail.

The second set is inspection. Principal District and Sessions Judges must send written jail inspection reports, preferably every month. They must certify the inspection date, whether any convict is still held after completing the sentence, and whether each convict is held under a warrant that is currently in operation.

Secretaries of the District Legal Services Authorities must report weekly through the State Legal Services Authority. They must also visit the jails in person each week. The reports go to the Registrar (J-I) of the High Court by the first week of each month, or by the end of each week for the legal services secretaries.

The judgment also describes an Online Criminal Justice Ecosystem launched by the Madhya Pradesh High Court. It links the police, courts, prisons, prosecution, forensics and hospitals on one platform, and is meant to share case diaries, medical and forensic reports and court orders without delay.

A gap in the statute books

The bench observed that there is at present no legislative mechanism to decide what such victims should receive. It turned to the 2017 judgment of the Delhi High Court in Babloo Chauhan alias Dabloo v State (NCT of Delhi).

That Division Bench had described court-ordered compensation for wrongful incarceration as episodic, and not easily available to everyone in the same position. It asked the Law Commission of India to examine the question.

The Commission’s Report 277, titled Wrongful Prosecution (Miscarriage of Justice): Legal Remedies, came in August 2018. The judgment records that the report looked at schemes in the United Kingdom, Germany, the United States, Canada, New Zealand and Australia.

Where no framework or guidelines exist, the Commission found, ex gratia payments have been arbitrary and generally very modest. They lack transparency, which makes it hard to establish any tariff.

The Commission recommended both money and non-monetary help, such as counselling, mental health services and skills training. It also recommended removing disqualifications that a prosecution or conviction places on a person’s chances of employment or admission to an educational institution.

The factors it listed include the length of incarceration, harm to health, psychological and emotional harm, damage to reputation, lost opportunities in education and livelihood, lost income and damage to property.

The Supreme Court recorded these recommendations but gave no direction to Parliament or the Union government. Its directions are confined to this case and to the High Courts.

Why Rs 30 lakh, and why not symbolic

The bench said compensation for wrongful incarceration reflects restorative justice. It is meant to address, as far as possible, the physical, psychological, social and economic harm of unlawful imprisonment. It is also a formal acknowledgement by the State of the injustice.

It added that compensation has a deterrent function. Financial liability pushes the system to take more care at every stage, from arrest to detention, and to build mechanisms that catch errors early.

The bench then applied the principles to Gond. In his High Court appeal he gave his age as about 22. In the petition before the Supreme Court, filed in June 2026, he gave it as 36.

On that basis the bench worked out that he was 21 when arrested, about 28 when acquitted and about 35 when released.

He was confined, it said, through what should have been the prime years of his youth. It listed the harm: loss of liberty, the harshness and indignity of incarceration, loss of consortium, loss of livelihood and earnings, and lost chances of education, skills and future income.

The award, the bench said, must match the gravity of that injustice. It cannot be symbolic or nominal. It must help him regain financial independence, find a sustainable livelihood and stand on his own feet.

The judgment calls that outcome “not an act of charity or benevolence on the part of the State”, but the bare minimum needed to redress the wrong (para 54).

The inadequacy of money, the bench added, cannot be an excuse for denying a remedy that is practical, effective and proportionate to the harm.

Order

The Supreme Court granted leave and disposed of the appeal. It modified the High Court order of 1 May 2026 and raised the compensation to Rs 30 lakh, covering all heads, pecuniary and non-pecuniary.

Chhattisgarh must pay within four weeks, after adjusting anything already paid under the High Court order. Payment goes by RTGS, NEFT or IMPS straight to the bank where Gond holds a savings account.

The bank must credit Rs 5 lakh to his savings account. It must place the balance in an interest-bearing fixed deposit with auto-renewal, in his sole name. No joint holder may be added.

The bank keeps the original receipt. It must give Gond and the Secretary of the District Legal Services Authority, Mohla Manpur, Ambarbagh Chowki, a statement with the deposit number, amount, maturity date and maturity value. The monthly interest is credited to his savings account.

No loan, advance, withdrawal or premature closure is allowed without the Secretary’s prior permission. The Secretary may allow withdrawal for a medical emergency or for creating a long-term income-generating asset, and must supervise compliance.

The Court also directed all High Courts to consider issuing directions in line with those of the Madhya Pradesh High Court after Sohan Singh. It asked them to consider setting up a criminal justice ecosystem like Madhya Pradesh’s online platform.

A copy of the judgment goes to the Registrars General of all High Courts, for placing before their Chief Justices. A copy also goes to the Secretary of the District Legal Services Authority at Mohla Manpur for compliance.