Accounts she signed recorded the land sale: Supreme Court reverses NCLT cancellation of deed
Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva applied the doctrine of indoor management and dismissed an oppression petition by a company director against her son and an outside buyer of company land.
A company with two directors, a mother and her son, sold 9 acres and 28 guntas of land on 4 September 2015 on the strength of a board resolution. Three years later the mother told the NCLT she had never heard of any board meeting. The tribunal cancelled the sale deed.
On 16 November the Supreme Court set that order aside. It held that the buyer, an outsider, could not be expected to prove what happened inside the company, and that the mother had signed audited accounts which recorded the sale. Her petition under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013 was dismissed.
Two directors, one resolution
According to the mother’s petition, M/s J and A Avenues India Private Limited had bought 18 acres and 18 guntas by a sale deed of 26 March 2013. Its shares were split 50:50 between Mrs Vishnumolaka Govardhanmma and her son. They were the only two directors.
On 4 September 2015 the son executed a registered sale deed of 9 acres and 28 guntas in favour of Elaine Info Solutions. The deed recited a Board resolution of 1 August 2015 authorising him to sell.
The company’s accounts recorded receipt of Rs 4,36,50,000 as the sale consideration.
The mother’s case at the NCLT
The mother filed a petition under Section 241. She said that although she was a director, her son looked after the company’s day-to-day affairs, and that she learnt later that he had colluded with Elaine to transfer part of the land.
On 1 August 2015, she said, only two directors existed. She was never told of a meeting and received no notice of one.
A son’s money dispute with the buyer
The son filed a counter-affidavit. He said Mr Naga Satish was a family friend who, with his mother, lent money, and had paid Rs 1,65,00,000 in all. The company, he said, agreed to sell the land for Rs 12,27,50,000 and treat that sum as an advance.
On that account the balance was Rs 10,62,50,000. Of that, Rs 7,91,00,000 went to him and Rs 4,36,50,000 to the company. He said the money he took was used for the company and its shareholders.
He alleged the deed was written for Rs 4,36,50,000 instead of Rs 12,27,50,000. A deed for 34 guntas bought from two other sellers, he said, showed Rs 38,25,000 against a real price of Rs 1,07,10,000.
He also said Mr Naga Satish had sued him on an agreement to sell dated 16 February 2015 for 29 acres and 30.08 guntas of his own land, with a balance consideration of Rs 7,91,00,000.
What Elaine told the tribunal
Elaine said the resolution of 1 August 2015 was recorded in the sale deed, and that its director, Mr Naga Satish, paid Rs 4,36,50,000 towards the consideration. The company’s balance sheet at 31 March 2016, it said, showed advance money of Rs 12,73,50,000 against the land sale.
It argued that if the company failed to minute a board meeting, that was an internal matter and could not be blamed on a bona fide purchaser. It relied on Section 41 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
It also said that on 11 June 2018 it had signed an agreement of sale with two other firms and taken substantial advance money.
On the son’s version, Elaine said the consideration was only Rs 4,36,50,000. It said the son had agreed to sell his own land at Kollur to Mr Naga Satish, taking Rs 1,65,00,000 before that deal was cancelled. A fresh agreement of 16 February 2015 for about 30 acres at Rs 12 crore followed, of which Rs 7,91,00,000 was paid.
Elaine called the Section 241 petition a collusive attempt to settle the dispute in the specific performance suit.
The NCLT and NCLAT held against the buyer
By its order of 2 August 2019 the NCLT reasoned that with only two shareholders and two directors, no valid board meeting could be held without the participation of either. Neither the son nor Elaine produced a notice of the meeting. The sale deed was void from the start.
The NCLT rejected the doctrine of indoor management. Only a colour photocopy of the resolution had been produced, so Elaine had not done due diligence. It also noted that one deed covered three properties, two belonging to individuals, and that a dispute already existed between the son and Mr Naga Satish.
It found oppression and mismanagement. It cancelled the registered deed, ordered the property restored to the company, and directed the company to return Rs 4,36,50,000 with 8 per cent interest.
The son and the company were told to return Rs 7,91,00,000 to Mr Naga Satish with 8 per cent interest within 60 days. The son was barred from directorship for five years, and the company was told to hold an extraordinary general meeting.
The NCLAT upheld that order on 18 March 2020. It said Elaine had led no evidence that the mother was present at the meeting. The audit report and financial statements did not reflect the sale, and the 2015-16 annual return showed no board meeting on 1 August 2015.
The original resolution had not been shown to Elaine, which bought on a certified copy. The NCLAT also noted that no profit or loss on the land sale appeared in the 2015-16 profit and loss account, and that the property was in the mother’s control. The son appealed separately, and the two appeals were heard together.
Why the buyer need not prove the meeting
Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva, writing for the Bench, began from the position of a stranger to the company. A meeting and a resolution fall within the personal knowledge of the directors and shareholders, and Elaine could not be taken to know of them.
The only two shareholders were the mother and the son. The NCLT was wrong to find that Elaine had failed to prove the mother had notice of the meeting. It was for the shareholders and directors of the company to prove or disprove the meeting, the Court held.
A third-party purchaser can act in good faith when one of two directors, who holds half the shares, produces a board resolution.
“The Doctrine of Indoor Management would clearly come to apply in the present case.” (para 20)
The mother had signed the books
The Court then turned to the company’s own records. The sale consideration had been received in the company’s accounts, shown in audited books and used for the company’s business. The audited accounts were signed by both the mother and the son.
The notes to those accounts mention the sale. Note 14 says the company executed a sale deed for 9 acres and 28 guntas of agricultural land.
It records that the purchaser disputed the consideration and filed Original Suit 15 of 2016 before the First Additional District Judge, Sangareddy. The sale, it says, would be completed or cancelled depending on the outcome of the suit.
The Court said the note acknowledges execution of the sale deed even though it records a dispute over price. The accounts were certified by the statutory auditors, and the mother never challenged the books or Note 14.
She signed the accounts for the year of the sale on 2 September 2016, and she did not deny that.
“She cannot, therefore, be permitted to deny the said transaction” (para 25)
Her denied signature and the missing complaint
The certified copy of the Board resolution referred to in the sale deed carries the mother’s signature, attesting it as a true copy. She denied the signature as hers. The Court noted that she filed no complaint against her son for forging it, and began no criminal proceedings against him.
Filed after three years
The mother filed her NCLT petition on 8 October 2018, saying she was unaware of the transaction and that the petition was within limitation. The Court rejected that. She had signed a balance sheet and notes disclosing the sale on 2 September 2016.
The petition challenging a registered sale deed of 4 September 2015 therefore came after more than three years. The Court concluded that the challenge to the resolution and the deed had been made to counter Mr Naga Satish’s claim in the suit for specific performance.
Income tax returns the Court never saw
The Court also noted that the company’s income tax returns were not placed before any forum, though they would have shown how the capital gains on the land were treated. The son denied only the sale price, not the execution of the deed.
The company, the Court said, had an obligation to reflect the transaction in its returns.
“an adverse inference needs to be drawn against the Company” (para 28)
Order
The Court held that the NCLT erred in declaring the resolution of 1 August 2015 and the sale deed of 4 September 2015 void. It also erred in directing the Sub-Registrar to cancel the deed, restoring title to the company and ordering return of Rs 4,36,50,000 with interest.
The NCLAT order of 18 March 2020, the Court said, compounded the error.
Civil Appeal 2821 of 2020, by Elaine, was allowed. Civil Appeal 6250 of 2021, by the son, was dismissed as infructuous. Both orders were set aside and the mother’s Section 241 petition was dismissed.
The five-year directorship bar on the son had already run its course. The Court clarified that it had neither examined nor commented on the merits of either side’s allegations in the specific performance suit, and that the suit must be decided on its own merits.