Justice S. Kumar Justice S. Sachdeva Civil Appeal A scheme sanctioned in 2015 stillcapped a claim made in 2018
[ Supreme Court ]

STC claimed Rs 24 crore and got Rs 2.19 crore: Supreme Court ends its insolvency petition

Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva held that a sanctioned rehabilitation scheme binds a creditor listed as a contingent liability to 25 percent of its principal, and set aside the NCLAT order.

In March 2018 the State Trading Corporation of India served a notice on Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd claiming ₹24.26 crore. On 16 November 2026 the Supreme Court held that the most STC could ever have recovered was 25 percent of its principal dues, which it had already been paid. The NCLAT, it said, was wrong to revive the insolvency petition.

Justice Sanjay Kumar wrote the judgment for a bench that also included Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva. The court allowed the company’s appeal, set aside the NCLAT judgment of 21 January 2026 and restored the order of the NCLT, Mumbai, of 13 February 2020. Each side bears its own costs.

A sick company and a sanctioned scheme

Ganesh Benzoplast, incorporated in Maharashtra in 1986, makes and stores chemicals and runs port storage tank terminals. It did business with STC in 2003, supplying toluene and allied products, and exported its industrial lubricants through STC between 2004 and 2006.

After its net worth eroded, the company made a reference under Section 15(1) of the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act, 1985. On 6 May 2010 the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction declared it a sick industrial unit.

A Draft Rehabilitation Scheme was circulated on 18 April 2013 with a cut-off date of 31 March 2011. The BIFR then stopped functioning for want of a member, so the company went to the Delhi High Court. A Division Bench approved the scheme on 4 December 2015.

Clause 11.11 and where STC stood

The scheme scaled down unsecured liabilities. Clause 11.11 gave unsecured creditors 25 percent of principal in five equal annual instalments, with an option to refuse the scaled-down value and wait until the scheme worked itself out or seven years had passed.

STC was not among the 191 unsecured creditors in Annexure V. It appeared at serial 6 of ten entries in Annexure VI(a), titled List of Contingent Liabilities, with a claimed amount of ₹11.35 crore.

Until its liability crystallised, STC could not be an unsecured creditor under Clause 11.11. It never challenged that listing. The scheme was published in newspapers on 9 May 2013, and STC did not object then or after the Delhi High Court approved it.

A third party, Avron Chemicals, an unsecured creditor, challenged the approval in the Supreme Court. The petition was dismissed on 10 April 2018.

Demand notice, petition and a 25 percent order

STC issued a demand notice under Section 8 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code on 20 March 2018, claiming ₹24,26,44,490. That sum was made up of about ₹17 crore for export transactions, ₹3.69 crore for domestic transactions, and ₹3.58 crore for the company’s failure to submit ‘C’ Forms under the Central Sales Tax Act.

The company denied liability on 31 March 2018, and STC filed a Section 9 petition before the NCLT on 5 June 2018. On 30 January 2020, during the case, the company handed over the ‘C’ Forms.

The NCLT noted that STC’s own rejoinder said that under the scheme it would get 25 percent in five instalments as an unsecured creditor. It also noted a letter of 4 October 2019 in which the company offered ₹1.75 crore in full and final settlement.

The tribunal called the offer reasonable, since STC could be treated only as an unsecured creditor under the scheme. It quantified 25 percent of dues at ₹2,18,88,421, directed payment within 30 days and disposed of the petition on 13 February 2020.

The detour through limitation

STC appealed to the NCLAT, which first dismissed the appeal as time-barred on 20 April 2023. On 2 April 2025, the Supreme Court held that the appeal was within time and sent it back to be decided on merits.

On 21 January 2026 the NCLAT allowed the appeal and sent the company petition back to the NCLT for a fresh decision. The company appealed, and on 17 March 2026 the Supreme Court stayed that judgment.

Why the NCLAT restored the petition

The NCLAT said the dispute was about how STC’s dues were treated. An unsecured creditor had two options under the scheme: accept 25 percent in instalments or wait out the scheme and then claim in full. STC argued the NCLT could not force it into the first option.

STC also pointed out that the company paid ₹2,18,88,421 as a lump sum only after the NCLT order, not in annual instalments from 2015. The money had been accepted without prejudice. The NCLAT agreed and asked why STC’s dues were shown as a contingent liability, and why the NCLT ordered 25 percent when the company denied liability altogether.

What the Supreme Court said was missed

The Supreme Court found that the NCLAT overlooked several points. STC issued its demand notice on 20 March 2018, within the seven-year period under the so-called second option in Clause 11.11. The options were open only to an unsecured creditor and not to a claimant listed as a contingent liability.

A contingent liability becomes an unsecured debt only when it crystallises, and STC’s claim never did. At the time of its demand notice and petition, the bench held, STC did not act as Clause 11.11 required.

The NCLAT had also wondered why STC’s claim was classed as contingent. The bench said STC itself accepted that listing and never challenged it. It was, the court said, “too late in the day” to claim otherwise.

Modi Rubber and the unworkable second option

The bench said the NCLAT strangely refused to apply Modi Rubber Limited v. Continental Carbon India Limited. That decision noted that after the 1994 amendment to SICA the BIFR could scale down the dues of creditors, including decree-holders and arbitration award holders.

It held that once the BIFR approves a rehabilitation scheme, the scheme binds unsecured creditors as well. They have no option to refuse the scaled-down value, because the scheme would become unworkable and defeat the SICA’s objective. Unless all concerned make a sacrifice, a sick company cannot be revived.

The bench also relied on Fertilizer Corporation of India Limited v. Coromandel Sacks Private Limited, which applied that rule to a decree-holder that was not even part of the scheme. Had it been part of it, that creditor would have had to take the scaled-down value like the others.

Why the wait-seven-years option was invalid

In light of those decisions, the bench held that the option in Clause 11.11 to wait for seven years and then claim full dues was not valid. Once the scheme was sanctioned, the position was plain.

“Once the DRS was sanctioned, the approved RS was binding on all concerned” (para 14)

There was no possibility of reopening the issue after the scheme worked itself out or after seven years, the court added. That would put the company, which stood rehabilitated, at risk of becoming sick again.

STC was not even an unsecured creditor on 4 December 2015. It was a contingent liability, so it could not claim a higher status than an unsecured creditor and demand full dues.

STC’s instalment argument fails

The bench called the NCLAT’s distinction between an unsecured creditor and a contingent liability illogical. STC could at best become an unsecured creditor when its dues crystallised. Clause 11.11 then put it on par with the listed creditors, entitled to 25 percent of principal and no more.

STC’s argument that it was not paid 25 percent in five annual instalments from 2015 was also rejected. It could claim instalments only after its dues crystallised, and it took no step to crystallise them. It went straight to a Section 8 notice for its entire dues.

The bench added that the IBC regime does not provide for determining or quantifying liability, so STC could not have sought crystallisation there. Even so, the company offered 25 percent by its letter of 4 October 2019, and the NCLT acted on that fair offer.

Nothing left to decide

The ‘C’ Forms claim, the bench said, stood extinguished once the company submitted them on 30 January 2020. That left the export and domestic claims, and the NCLT quantified them at ₹2,18,88,421.

No one disputed that figure before the Supreme Court, and STC accepted the payment on 20 March 2020 without prejudice. The maximum STC could have recovered under the approved scheme had thus been paid.

Nothing remained to be adjudicated in the Section 9 petition. The NCLAT, the bench said, erred in overlooking this and restoring the petition for a fresh decision.

Order

The appeal is allowed. The NCLAT judgment of 21 January 2026 is set aside, and the NCLT order of 13 February 2020 disposing of STC’s petition is restored.

The parties shall bear their own costs.