Justice U. Bhuyan Justice A.S. Chandurkar Criminal Appeal The cheques were posted fivedays before the alleged demand
[ Supreme Court ]

Marked notes, a pink hand wash, no proof of demand: Supreme Court acquits Delhi tehsildar

Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar overturned the bribery conviction of a Delhi tehsildar after the complainant and shadow witness died and the trap officer could only repeat what he was told.

Two Rs 500 notes treated with phenolphthalein powder were taken from the coat pocket of Har Parsad Gaur, then Tehsildar of Kotwali in Delhi. His left hand and the pocket turned pink in the wash test, and both courts below took that as enough. On 17 November the Supreme Court did not.

The complainant and the only independent witness to the trap had both died before they could testify. The Court held that nobody who gave evidence had seen or heard a demand for a bribe, and that the statutory presumption of corruption therefore never arose. It acquitted Gaur of all charges under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.

A Rs 1,000 trap outside an SBI branch

The complainant, Puran Chand, had won a wage award of Rs 41,425 from the Labour Court against his former employer, M/s Pooja Printers. The Labour Commissioner wrote to the District Collector on 19 July 2002 for recovery. The file was marked to Gaur at his Kotwali office.

Puran Chand said Gaur demanded Rs 3,000 to speed up the recovery, and that he paid it. A further Rs 1,000 was demanded on 7 December 2002, he said. On the morning of 6 January 2003 Gaur phoned and asked for it at the State Bank of India building in the Tis Hazari court complex.

That day he complained to the Anti-Corruption Bureau. Inspector Sandhu (PW-10) recorded the complaint before a panch witness, Ramesh Chand, a peon in the Delhi Government animal husbandry department. Two Rs 500 notes were treated with phenolphthalein powder and handed to the complainant.

What the raid party said it saw

According to PW-10, a man in a blue coat approached the complainant outside the SBI branch at about 1.05 pm and put a hand on his back. The two shook hands and spoke. At about 1.10 pm the panch witness gave the pre-arranged signal.

The raid party closed in. PW-10 said the panch witness told him Gaur had demanded and accepted Rs 1,000 and put it in the inner right pocket of his coat. Gaur refused the search PW-10 offered, and the panch witness took the two notes from the pocket on PW-10’s instructions.

PW-10 then took the wash of Gaur’s left hand and of the pocket. Both turned pink. The water was sealed in four small bottles.

Two witnesses died before the trial

A Special Judge in Delhi tried Gaur under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d), punishable under Section 13(2). The prosecution examined ten witnesses. Puran Chand and Ramesh Chand died before their evidence could be recorded.

On 28 August 2008 the Special Judge convicted Gaur. The trial court relied on the documents, PW-10’s evidence and the pink wash to draw the presumption under Section 20, and found no reliable rebuttal. The next day it sentenced him to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 10,000 on each count, to run concurrently.

The Delhi High Court dismissed his appeal on 19 December 2014, again relying on Section 20. It cut the sentence to one year on each count and left the fines alone. This Court granted leave on 6 April 2015 and suspended the sentence.

What each side argued

Mr Parthiv K Goswami, senior counsel for Gaur, said the foundational facts of demand and voluntary acceptance had not been proved. With both key witnesses dead, he argued, there was no primary evidence of any demand. The Section 20 presumption could arise only after those facts were established.

He called PW-10’s account of what the panch witness had told him inadmissible hearsay, since the inspector reached the spot only after the exchange. He also relied on the depositions of PW-4 and PW-7, which showed the two cheques had already reached the Deputy Labour Commissioner’s office on 1 January 2003.

Dr Nachiketa Joshi, senior counsel for the State, defended the High Court. He said the complaint set out the demand in detail and recovery from the coat pocket was undisputed. Both washes, he said, tested positive for phenolphthalein and sodium carbonate, showing conscious handling of the money.

Once recovery was proved, he said, Section 20 operated automatically and the burden shifted to Gaur. His authorities included Hazari Lal, Narsinga Rao, Uma Maheshwari Rao, Jeevaratnam, Sarangapani and Chandrasha.

Demand is the foundation of the offence

The Court, in a judgment written by Justice Bhuyan, set out Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) as they stood in 2003. It also set out the old Section 20, substituted from 26 July 2018, which presumes a corrupt motive once it is proved that a public servant accepted a gratification.

The Court turned first to Satyanarayana Murthy (2015) 10 SCC 152. That decision held that proof of demand is the gravamen of the offence under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii). Recovery of money without proof of demand does not lead to a conviction.

The Court next went through the Constitution Bench decision in Neeraj Dutta (2023) 4 SCC 731. Its conclusions, which the Court reproduced, treat demand and acceptance as a fact in issue that must be proved.

What Neeraj Dutta allows, and limits

The Constitution Bench said demand and acceptance can be proved by direct evidence or, where that is missing, by circumstantial evidence. If the complainant turns hostile, dies or is unavailable, other witnesses can prove demand, and the trial does not abate or end in acquittal.

A presumption of fact about demand and acceptance can be drawn only once the foundational facts are proved by oral and documentary evidence.

The Section 20 presumption of motive or reward follows proof of demand and acceptance. It does not extend to Section 13(1)(d)(i) and (ii). The Court’s own summary of the Constitution Bench holding includes four words that carry the point:

“Demand must precede acceptance.” (para 33.4)

The presumption is rebuttable, and an accused need only meet the standard of preponderance of probability. The Court drew that from the later two-judge ruling in Neeraj Dutta (2023) 18 SCC 251. Aman Bhatia and Gaba, it added, hold that recovery of tainted money alone does not establish the charge.

The State’s precedents did not help it

The Court observed that four of the State’s authorities pre-dated Neeraj Dutta. Even those, it said, treated the Section 20 presumption as contingent on proof at trial that the accused accepted or agreed to accept the gratification, though not necessarily through direct evidence.

It examined the two cited after the Constitution Bench. In Sarangapani, the pre-trap and post-trap proceedings were proved and both courts found conscious acceptance of the tainted money. The burden had shifted to the accused, whose explanation fell short.

In Chandrasha, a three-judge Bench found that demand and acceptance stood proved, so the presumption could be invoked. In both cases, the basic facts were found proved before the presumption was applied.

A trap officer who heard nothing

The Court listed what was missing from the record. There was no direct or primary oral evidence of any demand on 23 September 2002 or 7 December 2002. None existed for the telephone call on 6 January 2003, or for the words exchanged outside the SBI building that afternoon.

The trap case therefore rested entirely on PW-10. His account had a discrepancy: in examination-in-chief he said the panch witness told him Gaur took the money with his right hand, and in cross-examination he said the left. The Court looked past it.

What mattered was that PW-10 himself had neither seen nor heard any demand or acceptance. It had all been relayed to him by a man who never testified.

“such hearsay statement of PW-10 would be inadmissible in evidence” (para 42)

That left the recovery of the notes from the right inner pocket and the pink washes. The Court restated that recovery, without proof of demand, cannot sustain a conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d). With no primary evidence of demand, the prosecution had to prove circumstances leading to an irresistible inference of guilt.

The cheques had already gone

The Court found that the official record undercut the prosecution account of motive. The complaint said Gaur was holding back two recovery cheques from M/s Pooja Printers until he was paid. The original order sheet and the forwarding letter showed that his office had sent both cheques to the Deputy Labour Commissioner on 28 December 2002.

PW-4 Sudhir Kumar and PW-7 Suresh Kumar Verma, both clerks, said the cheques left on 28 December and reached the Deputy Labour Commissioner’s office on 1 January 2003. Proceedings before the Assistant Labour Commissioner on 7 January 2003 recorded that Puran Chand appeared and collected both cheques, which had been lying there since 1 January.

No official work concerning the complainant, the Court concluded, was pending before Gaur on 6 January 2003. The allegation that he telephoned that morning to threaten to withhold the cheques unless paid Rs 1,000 was contrary to the official record.

An explanation the Court would not brush aside

In his statement under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, Gaur said the complainant met him near the SBI branch to thank him for forwarding the cheques. While shaking hands, he said, the complainant tried to thrust the currency notes into his coat pocket.

The Court said this version could not be discarded altogether. The prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt, it noted, while the accused need only establish a defence on a preponderance of probabilities to rebut Section 20. Given the records showing the work was already done, the defence version was plausible and met that test.

The Court then stated its conclusion in one sentence:

“drawing of presumption under Section 20 of the PC Act was impermissible” (para 48)

It reached that point because neither the demand for the bribe nor Gaur’s conscious acceptance of it had been proved.

Order

The appeal was allowed. The High Court judgment of 19 December 2014 in Criminal Appeal 782 of 2008, and the Special Judge judgment of 28 August 2008 in CC 40 of 2003, were set aside.

Har Parsad Gaur was acquitted of the charges under Section 7 and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. As he was on bail, his bail bonds were discharged. All pending applications were disposed of.