Same pen, no patient number: Supreme Court reinstates CRPF constable sacked for 99-day overstay
Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh held that a shared pen and a missing patient number did not prove forgery, and that removal for the 99-day absence was grossly disproportionate.
A Central Reserve Police Force constable was sacked in 2001 after an inquiry decided that his medical papers were forged. The reason: the prescriptions and medicine bills looked as if they were written with the same pen. On 16 November the Supreme Court ordered him back to work with half his back wages.
Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, judges of the Supreme Court, allowed Mithilesh Kumar Pathak’s appeal in a reportable judgment written by Justice Sharma. They restored a High Court Single Judge’s order and set aside the Division Bench ruling that had upheld his removal.
Casual leave, then 99 days away
Pathak was a constable with the 54th Battalion of the CRPF, posted at Anantnag in Jammu and Kashmir. He was granted casual leave from 21 September to 12 October 2000 because his wife was ill. He was due back on 13 October.
He did not return. The Company Commander sent two registered letters, dated 26 October and 8 November 2000, directing him to report. He did not reply.
He reported for duty on 19 January 2001, having overstayed his leave by 99 days.
On 22 January 2001 he explained himself in an application to the Commandant. He said he had fallen ill on 9 October 2000 at his village in Munger district, Bihar, and had been treated for infective hepatitis under Dr S N Singh, a Medical Officer attached to Sadar Hospital, Banka.
He relied on prescriptions, pathology reports, receipts for medicines and a certificate declaring him fit for duty on 13 January 2001. His illness, the lack of postal facilities in his village and his wife’s inability to read or write had stopped him from answering the letters, he said.
The inquiry that disbelieved his papers
A memorandum of charges followed on 25 January 2001. It alleged unauthorised absence for 99 days and disobedience of orders, for not responding to the two letters. Pathak pleaded not guilty and produced twelve documents, including medical certificates and pathology reports.
The Enquiry Officer held both charges proved in a report dated 17 March 2001. He disbelieved the medical papers mainly on three grounds. They carried no indoor or outdoor patient number, the treatment appeared to have been obtained privately, and the prescriptions and bills appeared to have been written with the same pen.
From that he inferred that the documents had been prepared on a single day and were fabricated. On 29 March 2001 the Commandant ordered his removal from service, effective from the afternoon of 31 March 2001.
His departmental appeal was rejected on 11 January 2002 and his revision on 26 March 2004. In between, he had approached the Patna High Court twice, in CWJC 8712 of 2001 and CWJC 3333 of 2002.
Single Judge reinstates him; Division Bench reverses
Pathak then filed CWJC 5308 of 2004. On 13 April 2007 the Single Judge allowed it. The overstay was admitted, the Single Judge said, so the only question was whether Pathak had given a sufficient explanation.
The reasons for rejecting the medical papers rested on conjecture and surmise, the Single Judge found. He quashed the orders of the disciplinary, appellate and revisional authorities and directed that Pathak’s joining be accepted.
The Union appealed in Letters Patent Appeal 921 of 2007. On 5 May 2010 a Division Bench allowed it, holding that the Single Judge had exceeded the limits of judicial review by reappreciating evidence like an appellate authority.
The Division Bench upheld the rejection of the medical evidence. Once the absence was held unauthorised, it reasoned, the plea of illness failed and the charge of insubordination followed.
It also held that past conduct was relevant to the penalty. A uniformed force deployed in a sensitive area needed discipline, it said, and it restored the removal order.
Pathak appealed to the Supreme Court. The appeal carries a 2011 number.
What each side argued
For Pathak, it was argued that the Single Judge had rightly interfered with findings founded on conjecture. The documents could not be called fabricated merely because of the pen or ink, or because no hospital registration number appeared, without examining the treating doctor or verifying them in some other way.
His counsel added that the earlier overstays had already been dealt with and could not defeat his explanation this time. The penalty of removal was disproportionate, he said, and the inquiry had not followed Rule 27(c)(4) of the CRPF Rules, 1955 on the chance to give a written statement and lead defence evidence.
The Union’s counsel said Pathak belonged to a disciplined force posted in a sensitive area, yet stayed away 99 days without permission and ignored two directions to report. The medical papers, he said, were procured to justify the overstay.
He relied on two earlier absences, 71 days in 1994 and 175 days in 1999, as proof of repeated disregard of discipline. Adequate opportunity had been given in the inquiry, he added, and the Single Judge had substituted his own view of the evidence for that of the departmental authorities.
How far judicial review can go
The bench started from settled law. It cited State of Andhra Pradesh v S Sree Rama Rao, decided in 1963. A High Court may interfere where the inquiry breached natural justice or the statutory rules, or where the conclusion is so wholly arbitrary that no reasonable person could reach it.
Otherwise, that decision says, the departmental authorities are the sole judges of fact. The adequacy or reliability of evidence cannot be argued before the High Court in a writ proceeding under Article 226.
The bench also quoted B C Chaturvedi v Union of India, reported at (1995) 6 SCC 749. The disciplinary authority and the appellate authority are the fact-finders, and a High Court or tribunal cannot normally substitute its own penalty.
If a punishment shocks the conscience of the court, Chaturvedi adds, the court may mould the relief. It can send the matter back for reconsideration of the penalty or, in exceptional and rare cases, impose a punishment itself with cogent reasons.
Unauthorised absence is not always wilful
On those principles, the bench held that the Division Bench had wrongly set aside the Single Judge’s order. Absence without prior permission may be unauthorised absence, it said, but “unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous” (para 10).
The circumstances of the absence, the explanation given and the material backing it must all be weighed before the nature and gravity of the misconduct is decided. Illness or other circumstances beyond an employee’s control may matter, though they do not automatically excuse the whole period.
A shared pen proves nothing by itself
The bench then looked at what the Enquiry Officer relied on. Pathak had produced prescriptions, pathology reports, receipts and a fitness certificate. The officer disregarded them because certain entries appeared to be in the same pen and there was no outpatient department number.
No verification from the treating doctor, the medical establishment or the pharmacy supported the inference, the bench noted. Similarity in writing or ink, without material connecting it to fabrication, could not reasonably sustain the conclusion drawn.
The bench did not treat the other features as irrelevant. The missing indoor or outdoor patient number, and the doctor’s use of his official seal on a fitness certificate after treating Pathak privately, could call for clarification.
But those features did not by themselves show that no treatment was received or that the papers were forged. The Single Judge, it held, was right to find that the rejection rested on “conjectures and surmises” (para 12).
Removal was grossly disproportionate
The bench turned last to the penalty, which it said must be proportionate to the magnitude and gravity of the misconduct. It recognised that Pathak served in a disciplined force in a sensitive area, where obeying orders and reporting on time are essential obligations.
Even so, removal for overstaying 99 days was unduly harsh in the circumstances. That held even after counting his earlier overstays and his failure to keep in touch. The judgment calls the penalty “grossly disproportionate in the facts of this case” (para 13).
The judgment does not rule on Pathak’s complaint about Rule 27(c)(4). It also does not hold that the medical papers were genuine. Its finding is that the inquiry’s reasons for rejecting them could not stand.
Order
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal in Civil Appeal 4411 of 2011. It set aside the Patna High Court judgment of 5 May 2010 in Letters Patent Appeal 921 of 2007 and restored the Single Judge’s order of 13 April 2007 in CWJC 5308 of 2004.
The respondents must reinstate Pathak with immediate effect. They must pay him 50 per cent of the back wages for the period from his removal until reinstatement. He is entitled to all other consequential benefits, and pending applications stand disposed of.