Rs 33.2 lakh never offered in six months: Supreme Court holds the sale decree inexecutable
Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva set aside a Madhya Pradesh High Court order that let a buyer proceed to execution, saying the High Court rewrote the decree by holding he had no duty to pay first.
A civil court ordered a seller to execute a sale deed within six months of receiving the balance price. The buyer, who still owed Rs 33.2 lakh, did not offer a rupee of it in that time. In the seventh month he filed for execution anyway.
On 16 November the Supreme Court held that he could not. Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva allowed the seller’s appeal and set aside a Madhya Pradesh High Court order that had cleared the way for execution.
A Rs 34.21 lakh deal, a 2022 decree
The dispute began with an agreement to sell dated 21 September 2020. The buyer, Pradeep Jadhav, paid Rs 1,01,000 out of a total sale consideration of Rs 34,21,000.
His suit for specific performance was decreed on 21 November 2022. The decree directed the appellant, Raj Goyal, to execute the sale deed within six months after the buyer paid the remaining Rs 33,20,000 along with registration expenses.
It also said that if the seller still did not execute the deed in six months, the buyer could get it executed through the court.
Seventh month, straight to execution
It was an admitted fact, the bench recorded, that the buyer made no offer within the six months to pay the balance consideration or the registration expenses. In the seventh month he filed an execution petition.
The seller had filed an appeal against the decree. The buyer’s answer in the Supreme Court was that, because of that appeal, he had taken no steps.
The appeal he learnt of too late
The bench answered that with another admitted fact. The seller’s appeal came to the buyer’s notice only after the execution petition was filed, which was after the six months had expired.
So the appeal, on the bench’s account, was not something the buyer knew of while the six months were running.
What the High Court held
The Madhya Pradesh High Court at Gwalior ruled on 23 March 2026 in a miscellaneous petition. It observed that the decree required the seller to execute the sale deed within six months after receiving the consideration.
It then held that, under Section 28 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, the executing court could not add conditions that were not part of the decree. The Supreme Court called it strange that the High Court went on to say no obligation lay on the buyer to pay within a specified time.
On that reading the High Court directed the executing court to proceed with the execution petition for the sale deed. This Court stayed that order on 15 May 2026.
Who had to move first
The bench read the decree as it was written. The seller was bound to execute the deed on receiving the balance price and registration expenses within six months, so the first duty fell on the buyer.
Only after payment would the seller’s duty arise, and the buyer never took a step even to offer it. The High Court, the bench said, had erroneously held that no obligation lay on him.
The bench went further. It said it was in fact the High Court that rewrote the decree, a course not open to it:
“the High Court which rewrote the terms of the decree” (para 7)
Order
Leave was granted and the appeal allowed. The Madhya Pradesh High Court order of 23 March 2026 is set aside. In light of the bench’s findings, the decree would be inexecutable, in terms of Section 28 of the 1963 Act.
Pending applications stand disposed of. The parties will bear their own costs.