Justice P.K. Mishra Justice S. Chandrashekhar Civil Appeal A sagging wire, a lost suit anda restored decree
[ Supreme Court ]

Suspicion is no proof: Supreme Court restores Rs 8.7 lakh award for a live-wire injury

Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar held that the Rajasthan High Court could not wipe out a proved electrocution claim by doubting it, and restored the trial court decree against JVVNL.

A trial court gave a woman Rs 8.7 lakh after a live electric wire injured her when she was a minor. The Rajasthan High Court threw the award out because the incident looked suspicious and “unless there is miracle it does not happen”. On 16 November the Supreme Court restored the decree.

Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar, judges of the Supreme Court, decided Rekha’s appeal against Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited, or JVVNL. Justice Chandrashekhar wrote the reportable judgment.

The bench held that a civil suit is decided on evidence, not on a judge’s doubt. It called the High Court’s approach a serious error of law.

What Rekha said happened

Rekha sued in Civil Case 2 of 2015. She said that at around 7 am on 15 July 2011, when she was a minor, she was passing through a village and tried to ward off electric wires in her path.

The lines running between Phunthpura and Harivansh ka Pura-Pathaur ka Pura had loosened over several days, she said, and hung three or four feet above the ground.

The wire was live, and a large part of her body was badly burnt. She was taken to the Primary Health Centre at Basedi and then to a doctor at Badi, but did not improve.

After four days she was taken to Agra, where her right hand was amputated. She said she was left permanently disabled. A Daily Diary Report was recorded at Basedi police station on 18 August 2011, she said, but the police took no action on it.

The utility called the story imaginary

JVVNL said her account was imagined and invented to claim compensation. Anyone touching an 11 KV line, it argued, would die on the spot, so she could not have survived.

The utility also denied that any 11 KV line was hanging low near the place. It denied any negligence in maintaining its lines. It pleaded that no low-tension line passed through that village from which she could have suffered burns.

Trial court awards Rs 8.7 lakh

At the trial Rekha gave evidence herself and described the incident in detail and with clarity. JVVNL suggested to her that she had been shocked at home while removing a jumper wire. She denied it and stood by her version.

Her witnesses said they had complained about the lines sagging dangerously towards the ground. JVVNL examined one employee, who repeated the utility’s version that she was shocked at home.

In cross-examination he admitted he had not seen the incident and was not even on duty that day. He also admitted that maintaining the transmission lines was the utility’s responsibility.

The trial court decreed the suit and directed JVVNL to pay Rs 8,70,000 as compensation, with interest at 6 per cent until payment.

High Court finds the incident suspicious

JVVNL appealed to the Rajasthan High Court in S B Civil First Appeal 319 of 2016. A Single Judge allowed it and dismissed the suit. The High Court said Rekha’s witnesses were not on the same page and contradicted each other about the wires hanging low.

It also pointed to delay. Nobody reported the incident to the police or to JVVNL soon after it happened, and the victim gave no explanation for the delay. The High Court said medical expert evidence did not establish treatment for an electric shock.

It found it unbelievable that a person who passed under a hanging high-voltage wire, with her head touching it, suffered no shock at all. Her shock came when she removed the wire from her head by hand, the High Court noted, and unless there was a miracle that does not happen.

The High Court added that a civil case needs more than tendering documents. A witness had exhibited papers, but exhibiting them did not prove them. Strict liability, it said, applies when an incident is established, not when the incident itself is suspicious.

It called the claim frivolous and held that the trial court had committed a serious error in allowing it.

Doubt cannot replace evidence

The Supreme Court granted leave after condoning the delay in filing. It said the High Court had interfered with a well-considered judgment “on mere ipse dixit” (para 8).

A civil suit, the bench said, must be decided on the evidence the parties produce and not by raising a doubt about the plaintiff’s claim. Whether Rekha was injured by a live wire was a question of fact, and the trial court decided it on the evidence led.

In an appeal, findings of fact recorded by the trial judge should normally prevail. The exception is where the trial judge missed vital defects in a witness’s testimony.

The cross-examination that did not land

JVVNL had a full trial in which to find the truth, the bench said. That is the point of cross-examination under Sections 146 and 155 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It lets a party test a witness’s veracity and, in the ways the Act allows, attack the witness’s credit.

The utility could also have led positive evidence that its lines were in good shape and the wires hung at the proper height. Instead its only witness turned out to be hearsay, and it led nothing else to show it was not responsible.

The utility’s attempts to impeach Rekha’s witnesses, the bench said, were confined to insignificant issues. The suggestion put to her that she was hurt by a jumper wire did not come from any proven fact or document.

Her evidence, by contrast, remained unshaken and intact. Her witnesses stood by her claim on every material aspect.

Preponderance of probability, not possibility

The test in a civil case, the bench said, is preponderance of probability. It asks how likely the plaintiff’s case is to be true. That means more than a mere possibility, and the plaintiff need not prove the case beyond reasonable doubt.

The evidence must show a fair degree of certainty. The trial judge applied that test correctly, the bench held.

The High Court, in contrast, overlooked a basic rule: not every inconsistency or omission in a witness’s evidence is material in a civil trial. It disbelieved the whole case because it found the incident suspicious.

That was a grave error, the bench said. Section 4 of the Evidence Act allows a court to treat a fact as proved where the Act provides a presumption, or to call for proof until it is disproved. Nothing authorises a court to disbelieve an incident without finding the witnesses unreliable or lying.

Whether Rekha suffered permanent disability was also a question of fact, it added. Her witnesses made positive statements on it, and the bench said it was proved that she received injuries from electrocution.

Documents were only supporting material

The High Court had held the incident unproved because documents were tendered but not proved. The bench disagreed. Rekha’s case rested mainly on witness testimony, and the medical records were produced as supporting material.

Section 3 of the Evidence Act, the bench noted, says a fact is proved when the court believes it exists, or considers its existence so probable that a prudent person would act on it. Beyond a statutory presumption, no court may assume a fact that no witness or document supports.

An appellate court can step in where the first court’s judgment suffers from material irregularity, rests on inadmissible evidence or misreads the evidence. It cannot do so merely on suspicion, without weighing whether the witnesses are truthful.

If a witness is found truthful, the court must still separate chaff from grain and apply the correct principles. Delay in lodging a claim or complaint, or some inconsistency in the plaintiff’s evidence, does not by itself justify spurning a trial court’s judgment.

An appellate court, it said, should not embark upon “a fault-finding expedition” (para 12) and interfere on a mere showing of some mistake.

Order

The Supreme Court condoned the delay, granted leave and allowed the appeal. It set aside the High Court order of 10 May 2024 in S B Civil First Appeal 319 of 2016.

It restored the trial court judgment and decree in Civil Case 2 of 2015, directing JVVNL to pay Rs 8,70,000 with interest at 6 per cent until payment. The bench said the case attracts strict liability of the respondents. Pending applications stand disposed of.