Justice S.C. Sharma Justice N.K. Singh Criminal Appeal Bail cancelled by a magistrate, undoneby the High Court, restored here
[ Supreme Court ]

Supreme Court restores bail cancellation in law student murder: Madras HC skipped his record

Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh set aside a Madras High Court order that had freed the accused, saying it ignored his antecedents, threats to witnesses and fresh cases filed while on bail.

A 22-year-old law student was found dead on a public road in Tamil Nadu. The man the police named as the prime accused left jail on default bail, was arrested again two days later with five pistols in his cars, and then threatened a man who came to collect the vehicle used in the crime.

On 16 November the Supreme Court restored a magistrate’s order cancelling his bail. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed an appeal by the student’s mother against the Madras High Court, which had set that cancellation aside.

A body on the road, then default bail

The FIR, Crime No. 278 of 2024, was registered on the complaint of the Village Administrative Officer after the body was found. The investigation, as the order records it, showed that Rohith Kumar alias Revanna and other co-accused abducted the student over earlier enmity and attacked him with lethal weapons.

He was arrested on 8 October 2024. On 7 January 2025, after about three months in custody, he was released on default bail under Section 167(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

Arrested again two days after release

On 9 January 2025 a second case was registered against him and others. They were intercepted in two cars, driven rashly and negligently, and five pistols were found. He stayed in custody until the Krishnagiri sessions court granted bail on 12 March 2025.

While the murder investigation continued, the order says, he also threatened with death a person who had come to collect the vehicle involved in the crime. That led to an application to cancel his bail.

Magistrate cancels, High Court reverses

The Hosur magistrate cancelled his bail on 1 April 2025. He went to the Madras High Court, which allowed his petition on 30 April 2025 and enlarged him on bail.

What the two sides told the bench

For the mother, Mr Ishaan George, Advocate-on-Record, described the accused as a hardcore criminal with more than 10 cases, three of them for murder. He said fresh cases were registered even after bail, and pointed to a 26 May 2026 order of the Bengaluru Rural sessions court rejecting his anticipatory bail in a later case.

The State of Tamil Nadu supported the appeal. Its counsel referred to the long list of antecedents and said he had threatened prosecution witnesses.

Senior Advocate S. Nagamuthu, for the accused, argued that the appeal had become infructuous. After the investigation was transferred, he said, a court in Karnataka cancelled the bail and the Karnataka High Court affirmed it, and the accused proposed to file a Special Leave Petition.

He added that his client had been acquitted in three murder cases, though the other antecedents were not disputed. He also objected that Karnataka’s Standing Counsel, not the State of Tamil Nadu, should have argued the matter.

Why the appeal survived

The bench rejected the infructuousness argument. It said it had to examine the legality and propriety of the High Court order.

“the present appeal has certainly not become infructuous” (para 10)

The order does not separately rule on the objection about which State’s counsel should appear. It moved straight to the High Court order and the record before it.

What the High Court left out

The bench counted the custody he had actually served: 8 October 2024 to 7 January 2025, then 9 January to 12 March 2025, and 1 to 30 April 2025. It found it unfortunate that the High Court had not referred to his history of criminal cases, his conduct in threatening witnesses, or his involvement in fresh offences while on bail.

In the bench’s words, the High Court had “mechanically set aside the well-reasoned cancellation order” passed by the magistrate (para 12).

The bench weighed the short period in custody, the gravity and heinous nature of the offence, the extensive antecedents and the High Court’s complete non-consideration of them. On that footing the impugned order, it held,

“cannot be sustained and deserves to be set aside” (para 13)

Order

Leave was granted and the appeal allowed. The Madras High Court order of 30 April 2025 is set aside. The magistrate’s order of 1 April 2025, cancelling the bail of Rohith Kumar alias Revanna, stands restored.

Pending applications stand disposed of.