Same charge, same footing: Supreme Court extends stay of conviction to Azam Khan son and wife
Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu dismissed Uttar Pradesh appeals against the stay given to Mohammad Azam Khan and held that his son and wife, convicted of the same conspiracy, must get it too.
The Allahabad High Court had paused the conviction of Mohammad Azam Khan in a forged birth certificate case, but refused the same relief to his son and his wife. On 17 November the Supreme Court called that an arbitrary split. It left Azam Khan’s stay in place and extended it to Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr Tazeen Fatma.
Justice Dipankar Datta wrote the judgment for a bench that also included Justice Sheel Nagu. The court dismissed the State of Uttar Pradesh’s appeals and allowed the two convicts’ appeals. The criminal revisions now return to the High Court for a decision on their own merits.
Two birth certificates and a conspiracy charge
The case began with a written complaint of 17 December 2018 and an FIR registered on 3 January 2019 at Police Station Ganj, Rampur. It named Mohammad Azam Khan, his son Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan and his wife Dr Tazeen Fatma.
The charges were criminal conspiracy, cheating and forgery under Sections 120-B, 420, 467, 468 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code.
The prosecution said the three conspired to procure and use two conflicting birth certificates in the name of Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan. The documentary evidence was the same for all three: one certificate issued at Rampur and the other at Lucknow.
The three were convicted on 18 October 2023, and an appellate court affirmed the conviction on 23 December 2023. All three then went to the High Court in revision under Sections 397 and 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
What the High Court gave, and withheld
By its judgment of 24 May 2024, the High Court suspended the sentences of all three under Section 389(1) CrPC and released them on bail. It listed its reasons: the offence was not heinous, they had stayed on bail during trial without misusing it, and there was no chance of absconding.
It noted Azam Khan was about 74 and Dr Tazeen Fatma about 72, both with age-related ailments. Against a maximum sentence of seven years, Azam Khan had served over two years and five months with remission, and the other two over one year and four months each.
The High Court then drew a line. It held that Azam Khan’s case was distinguishable and stayed his conviction, but rejected the same prayer from his son and wife.
Three appeals, two sides of the same order
Uttar Pradesh challenged the stay of Azam Khan’s conviction. The son and the wife challenged the refusal of a matching stay. A bench had issued notice on the State’s petition on 24 July 2025, accepting the State’s point that the revision prayer sought only suspension of sentence.
Mr K.M. Nataraj, Additional Solicitor General, appeared for the State. Mr Kapil Sibal, senior counsel, appeared for all three family members.
The State’s two objections fail
The State’s first objection was procedural. In his revision petition Azam Khan had expressly prayed only for suspension of sentence, yet the High Court stayed the conviction on its own motion. The Supreme Court examined paragraph 5 of the High Court’s judgment and found it recorded that all three had separately applied for a stay of conviction.
The High Court therefore did not travel beyond the prayers. The bench overruled the objection.
The second objection was that the High Court gave reasons for suspending the sentence but not separately for staying the conviction. The bench accepted that the reasons were not extensive. It held that the reasons for suspending the sentence were valid grounds for the stay as well.
Those reasons, spread across paragraphs 21 to 25 of the High Court’s judgment, were the long custody already served, Azam Khan’s advanced age and the absence of direct evidence that he personally signed the forged entries in the municipal registers. The exercise of discretion showed no manifest perversity, and there was no ground to interfere under Article 136.
The split that could not stand
The bench framed the real concern as the selective grant of relief, calling it a starkly selective grant of interim relief to one of three co-convicts. It put the question this way:
“whether the High Court was justified in applying a different and seemingly contradictory standard while exercising discretionary powers under Section 389(1), read with Sections 397/401, Cr. PC” (para 8)
It first separated two remedies. Suspension of sentence only defers the penalty while a challenge is pending. A stay of conviction keeps in abeyance the legal disability that follows a finding of guilt, and by settled law it is an exceptional remedy needing compelling justification.
Where several convicts stand on identical evidentiary footing, the court must keep its approach consistent. Parity, the bench said, is a facet of Article 14.
Differential treatment is not forbidden, but the court must name the feature that justifies it. An order silent on that point is arbitrary.
“an unreasoned differential treatment cannot be sustained” (para 19)
Why a conviction itself is a harm
The bench described a conviction as inflicting an immediate and profound blow to the right to live with dignity under Article 21. It brings social stigma and moral opprobrium. If a revisional court later sets it aside on merits, the bench said, years under that shadow cannot be restituted in money or repaired.
It drew on the Afjal Ansari decision, which read Section 389(1) broadly where irreversible consequences follow. The bench recalled that the Ravikant Patil ruling makes a stay the exception, to be used in rare cases, but that where the damage would be irreparable and cannot be compensated if the convict is acquitted, an exceptional situation arises.
In Afjal Ansari, the court had noted, refusing a stay would have left a constituency without its representative and, with the sentence and an additional six-year disqualification, could have kept the appellant out of elections for ten years even if he were later acquitted. It also stressed that societal interest is equally important.
The bench then added a limit of its own. It said it unequivocally disavowed any plea for a stay of conviction anchored purely on political expediency, electoral ambitions or election campaigns. Statutory powers, it said, cannot be “leveraged to suit political calendars or electoral ambitions”.
One conspiracy, one set of papers
The court held the High Court’s refusal to the son and wife a violation of parity and a patent error of jurisdiction. The entire prosecution rested on a single charge of conspiracy under Section 120B IPC and on the same two certificates.
No separate overt act of manual forgery was attributed to Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan or Dr Tazeen Fatma beyond their status as co-conspirators and alleged beneficiaries. The evidence, offences and conspiracy bound all three to the same legal fate.
Giving favourable treatment to the father and denying it to a son and a wife who is herself a septuagenarian was, the bench said, arbitrary differentiation. Both faced the same irreversible prejudice during the pendency of their revisions.
The High Court had said Azam Khan’s case was distinguishable, but the bench found that it never identified a coherent legal reason why the others were treated differently.
Order
The State’s criminal appeals, arising out of SLP (Crl.) Nos. 11030-11032 of 2025, are dismissed. The stay of Mohammad Azam Khan’s conviction stands.
The appeals of Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan and Dr Tazeen Fatma are allowed. The High Court’s judgment is set aside to the extent it denied them a stay, and the trial court’s judgment of 18 October 2023, as affirmed on 23 December 2023, remains stayed for them while their revisions are pending.
The High Court is to decide the revisions on their individual merits, uninfluenced by the Supreme Court’s observations, as expeditiously as possible. The parties agreed to cooperate with the roster bench for early disposal. Pending applications stand disposed of.