Justice S. Kumar Justice S. Sachdeva Civil Appeal Bolted to a base is not buriedin the earth
[ Supreme Court ]

Supreme Court quashes Rs 53.36 crore solar GST demand: the 70:30 split was only an option

Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva held that the 70:30 split was optional for the earlier years and that solar systems fixed to foundations are movable, so no works contract arises.

The tax department wanted Rs 53.36 crore from Sterling and Wilson for supplying and installing solar power generating systems between July 2017 and December 2018. On 16 November the Supreme Court set the demand aside, holding that a 70:30 goods-and-services split offered as a choice in 2021 could not be forced on a company that never took it.

Justice Sanjay Kumar wrote the judgment for a bench with Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva. The court also held that a solar power generating system fixed to a civil foundation is not immovable property, so its supply and installation is not a works contract, and that extended limitation for fraud or suppression had no footing.

A Rs 53 crore demand, a cursory dismissal

On 17 January 2025 the Joint Commissioner of Central GST and Central Excise, Thane Commissionerate, Mumbai, called on the company to pay CGST of Rs 13,33,95,241 along with an equal penalty. That came to Rs 26,67,90,482.

A Summary Order of 24 January 2025 from the Superintendent of Central Tax, Range V, Santacruz, followed. With the matching State GST and penalty, the company was required to pay Rs 53,35,80,964. It skipped the statutory appeal and went straight to the Bombay High Court.

The Division Bench dismissed Writ Petition 4616 of 2025 on 28 July 2025, citing an efficacious alternate remedy. It said no contentions had been advanced for bypassing the rule of exhaustion, and no grounds were made out to call the pre-deposit harsh or to waive it.

The Supreme Court noted that the High Court had lost sight of the fact that two orders were under challenge and mentioned only the Summary Order. On 25 August 2025 it stayed the Joint Commissioner’s order.

Why the court decided it itself

After hearing senior counsel and counsel for both sides, the bench found the dismissal unjustified on the facts. The company had raised arguable points that deserved consideration instead of being sent to the appellate remedy.

“not a straitjacketed formula to be applied without exception” (para 5)

That was the court’s description of the rule on alternate remedy, and each case turns on its own facts. It would ordinarily have remitted the writ petition. But the matter was argued at length, and the Andhra Pradesh High Court had already adjudicated the issue, so the bench decided it on merits.

From 2.5 per cent to the 70:30 split

The dispute concerns CGST and SGST on the supply and installation of solar power generating systems, called SPG systems in the judgment, from 1 July 2017 to 31 December 2018. The company installs them on a turnkey basis under EPC (engineering-procurement-construction) contracts in various States.

Notification 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate) of 28 June 2017 listed renewable energy devices at serial 234 of Schedule I, taxed at 2.5 per cent CGST and a matching 2.5 per cent SGST. A solar power generating system, as a whole, was named in that entry, the court noted.

It traced the rate to the GST Council. At its ninth meeting on 16 January 2017 the Power Secretary warned that a 10 paise rise in power cost per unit would burden consumers by Rs 11,000 crore.

The Secretary for New and Renewable Energy said inputs taxed at 18 per cent would add 40 to 50 paise per unit for solar plants.

The Council put renewable energy devices at 5 per cent at its 14th meeting. On 3 June 2017 it added photo voltaic cells, whether assembled in modules or made into panels.

Separately, Notification 11/2017 taxed construction services at 9 per cent central tax, and that rate covered a composite supply of a works contract as defined in Section 2(119) of the CGST Act.

On 22 December 2018 the Council’s 31st meeting took up the many disputes over EPC contracts, where a solar system might be supplied under two or three contracts. It deemed 70 per cent of the total amount to be the value of goods at serial 234 and the remaining 30 per cent the value of services.

Notification 24/2018 inserted an Explanation to that effect, and Notification 27/2018 added serial 38 for the services. Both came into force on 1 January 2019. The court noted that the 70:30 Explanation had no retrospective operation.

The judgment works through an example. On a hypothetical Rs 10,000, tax at 5 per cent was Rs 500 before 1 January 2019. Afterwards, 5 per cent on Rs 7,000 and 18 per cent on Rs 3,000 comes to Rs 890, or 8.9 per cent.

What the 2021 circular actually said

At its 45th meeting on 17 September 2021 the Council noted that the 70:30 scheme was prospective. The Fitment Committee recommended a clarification that taxpayers can pay in that ratio for solar projects completed before 1 January 2019, with no refund where tax had been paid on the entire contract value at 18 per cent.

Circular 163/19/2021-GST of 6 October 2021 said GST on such projects could be paid in the 70:30 ratio for the period 1 July 2017 to 31 December 2018. It was issued under Section 168 of the CGST Act, and the court said it need not be gazetted.

The word that mattered, the bench said, was can. The circular gave assessees a choice. The authorities appeared to have misread it as binding every assessee for the earlier period.

On that footing the company received a show cause-cum-demand notice on 29 March 2023. It asked why the company should not be taxed at 5 per cent on 70 per cent of the value and 18 per cent on the other 30 per cent.

The Joint Commissioner’s case against the company

The Joint Commissioner noted that the company had paid 5 per cent, treating its supply as goods under serial 234. He held it to be a composite supply of works contract services and applied the 70:30 ratio.

He said the circular did not discuss movable or immovable property, so that question was immaterial. Even so, he found a solar power plant to be immovable property. It has a permanent location, cannot be shifted without dismantling, and includes civil work such as site development, foundations, cable trenches and control buildings.

He concluded that the company wilfully misstated and suppressed facts and misclassified its supply to cut its tax. That, he held, attracted penalty under Section 122(2)(b) and the extended limitation period under Section 74.

The Andhra Pradesh ruling the Revenue never challenged

In its writ petition the company relied on a Division Bench ruling of 10 January 2025 from the Andhra Pradesh High Court in its own case against the Joint Commissioner, State Tax, Vijayawada. That case began with a demand of Rs 63,00,19,512 for 30 November 2017 to 30 September 2018, with a penalty of the same sum.

On appeal the tax stood, but the penalty was cut to Rs 6,30,01,952. The Revenue argued that supply and installation of solar systems was a composite supply and therefore a works contract.

The Division Bench read Note 6 of Schedule II with Sections 8 and 9. Every works contract is a composite supply, it held, but not every composite supply is a works contract.

The difference lies in the end product. Section 2(119) covers contracts for building, erection or installation of immovable property where property in goods is transferred. So the question was whether the solar system is movable or immovable.

The High Court found that the system was not embedded in the earth but attached to a civil foundation that was. That attachment was not for the foundation’s permanent beneficial enjoyment, since the foundation was there for the system’s benefit.

The transaction was therefore not a works contract. The Revenue did not challenge that decision, and it attained finality.

In Siemens Gamesa, the same High Court held wind turbine generators on foundations to be movable goods, so their supply and installation was no works contract. The Supreme Court dismissed the State’s challenge, finding no ground to interfere.

In Arka Green Power, decided on 24 December 2025, the High Court dealt with solar pumping systems supplied between July 2017 and December 2018 and taxed on the 70:30 basis. It held that mere attachment of a pumping system to a base does not make it immovable, and followed its 2025 ruling.

The Revenue also leaned on a Madhya Pradesh High Court ruling in Rudraksha Allied Chemicals. The bench called that reliance wholly misplaced, because it concerned a tender and whether work was a works contract for a policy. Whether a contract is a composite supply or a works contract turns on the facts of each case.

Six tests for what counts as immovable

The Andhra Pradesh court drew on this court’s cases, and so did the bench. TTG Industries held that machinery erected at a purchaser’s site was immovable because it could not be shifted without dismantling and re-erecting it.

Solid and Correct Engineering Works later examined a hot mix plant bolted to a foundation of not more than 1½ feet. Fixing for stable, wobble-free working, without intent to attach permanently, does not make a machine part of the earth.

That court used Section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act. Attached to the earth means rooted in it, embedded in it, or attached to what is embedded for the permanent beneficial enjoyment of that to which it is attached.

Sirpur Paper Mills made the point with a water pump fixed on a cement base, which does not become immovable. Duncans Industries, a stamp duty case, treated plant permanently embedded for running a factory as immovable, and said the answer depends on the facts and the parties’ intention.

In Bharti Airtel the court distinguished TTG Industries for a mobile tower bought knocked down, erected on site and capable of being dismantled and re-erected without damage. It then summarised six tests: nature of annexation, object of annexation, intendment of the parties, functionality, permanency and marketability.

Fixing an article to the ground only to make it stable and wobble free points to movable property. So does an article that can be dismantled and relocated without damage, or removed and sold in the market.

Option, not mandate

Before the 70:30 regime, the company paid 5 per cent, in keeping with the Council’s recommendations and the policy of promoting renewable energy through tax incentives. The new regime began on 1 January 2019 and was not retrospective.

The 2021 circular, the court said, shows that some assessees asked to use the new ratio for earlier supplies, and the Council accepted. Only an option was given to those who chose it. Neither the notification nor the circular made the ratio compulsory for past transactions.

The authorities’ notion that the option applies across the board, even to assessees who did not choose it, was held to be:

“patently erroneous and wholly unsustainable” (para 33)

No fraud, no extended limitation

Because the 70:30 ratio came only on 1 January 2019, no fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression could be imputed to the company for treating the earlier period under a different regime. Section 74 could not have been used against it.

The court held that invoking extended limitation was completely unsustainable on facts and in law. It cited Tata Steel: extended limitation is no lip service, and the foundational facts behind an inference of fraud should be evident from the notice itself.

Using the words fraud or suppression, the bench recalled, does not show application of mind. It said nothing more on the point.

A solar system that can be moved

The EPC contract included some civil work, but that did not make the transaction a works contract. It was not disputed that the solar photo voltaic panels and modules can be detached from the civil foundation and used elsewhere. The foundation only keeps the system firm and stable.

Not every composite supply under Section 2(30) is a works contract under Section 2(119), the court said, agreeing with the Andhra Pradesh High Court. The contract must relate to activity on immovable property as its end product.

“easily detached from the foundation and used elsewhere” (para 36)

A system of that description cannot be treated as immovable property, said the bench, so the contract for its supply and installation falls outside a works contract. The view consistently taken by the Andhra Pradesh High Court was the correct view.

The bench also looked at Notification 8/2021 of 30 September 2021, which omitted serial 234 and inserted serial 201A in Schedule II. The old entry named a solar power generating system. The new one names only a solar power generator.

The change showed that earlier the entire system was treated as one unit taxed at 2.5 per cent, and now only the generator is. The substitution, the court held, cannot be applied retrospectively to earlier supplies.

Viewed from any angle, the bench said, the CGST authorities’ action was unsustainable on facts and in law. They had applied the 70:30 ratio to contract value for a period governed by a different regime.

Order

Leave was granted and the appeal allowed on 16 November. The Supreme Court set aside the order of 17 January 2025 of the Joint Commissioner, Thane Commissionerate, and the consequential Summary Order of 24 January 2025.

The parties will bear their own costs.