Justice S.C. Sharma Justice N.K. Singh Civil Appeal Eight years of service, a leave applicationand a penalty out of all proportion
[ Supreme Court ]

Supreme Court reinstates CISF constable removed over a leave row, calls penalty shocking

Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh found the three charges unproved, the inquiry unfair to a Hindi speaker, and ordered reinstatement with half back wages.

A Central Industrial Security Force constable asked for twelve days of leave in December 2017 to care for his wife, who had by his account suffered a miscarriage and surgeries. Five months later he was removed from service. On 16 November the Supreme Court quashed the removal and ordered reinstatement with 50 per cent back wages.

Justice Satish Chandra Sharma wrote the judgment for a bench with Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh. The court found none of the three charges established, criticised an inquiry run in English against a Hindi speaker, and called the penalty shockingly disproportionate.

A leave request during a wife’s illness

Sumit Kumar joined the CISF as a Constable (General Duty) in 2012. He was posted at the CISF unit at the Uranium Corporation of India Limited, Jaduguda. He was on casual leave from 18 October to 7 November 2017 because of complications in his wife’s pregnancy.

She was hospitalised on 31 October, suffered a miscarriage, and had surgery on 1 November. His leave was extended to 3 December with a warning that no further extension would follow. On 27 November she was admitted again and underwent another major procedure.

He rejoined on 3 December and applied for twelve more days from 5 December. On 4 December he met the Assistant Commandant with her hospital admission slip and other papers. By his account the documents were found insufficient and the request was declined.

On 5 December, it is alleged, he telephoned the Commandant and was told to report on 6 December with all documents. On 6 December he tendered a resignation through the grievance portal, saying he was under acute mental stress. The resignation was closed, and he was told the same day that twelve days of leave were granted.

On 8 December the Senior Commandant, NAPS Narora, visited his home in Meerut, recorded his statement and examined his wife’s medical records. She was discharged from hospital that day.

A charge memorandum on his first day

He resumed duty on 17 December and was transferred to the CISF unit at the Heavy Water Plant, Manuguru, Telangana. He joined on 18 January 2018 and was served the same day with a Memorandum of Charge under Rule 36 of the CISF Rules, 2001.

Charge I said he failed to appear before the Commandant on 6 December, refused to come, and submitted a conditional resignation to pressure the unit.

Charge II said he threatened and intimidated officials through relatives in the Ministry of Home Affairs. It also said he made a video of his wife viral, in which she accused the administration of torturing him by refusing leave.

Charge III cited five earlier minor penalties for indiscipline and said he had not mended his ways. The first was a deduction of three days’ salary over varying certificates of his wife’s date of birth.

The second was a pay cut by one stage for two years for not disclosing a property transaction. The third was a fine of five days’ pay for carrying a smartphone on duty.

The fourth was withholding of one increment for two years, again for a smartphone on duty. The fifth was a censure for opening a storeroom door at the plant shift house while on duty.

An inquiry conducted in English

The constable was not conversant with English. On 24 January 2018 he asked for Hindi translations of the documents relied on in the charge memorandum and two more he said were essential. The Commandant refused on 25 January, and his representations to the Deputy Inspector General and the Inspector General met the same fate.

An Inquiry Officer was appointed on 15 February. The constable acknowledged the notice for the preliminary hearing under protest, noting his pending request. The respondents treated that as non-cooperation and, on 17 February, suspended him and fined him seven days’ pay.

His requests for a defence assistant were rejected on 23 February, 1 March and 14 March because the assistant had to be from the place of the inquiry. His plea for a change of Inquiry Officer on the ground of bias was also refused.

Eight prosecution witnesses were examined between 28 February and 16 March, and he was examined on 24 March. The Inspector General ordered translation on 28 March, and Hindi copies reached him on 29 March.

On 16 April the Inquiry Officer put the mandatory questions. The constable named three defence witnesses but was told to produce them within ten minutes, with no notice issued to them.

The report of 18 April held all three charges proved. The disciplinary authority ordered removal on 1 May 2018. His appeal failed on 13 June 2018 and his revision on 4 January 2019.

The High Court: a blot is a blot

The Delhi High Court Division Bench dismissed his writ petition on 14 February 2024. It said his chequered service history, and the fact that he did not dispute the five earlier penalties, were enough to treat him as a habitual offender.

A blot on the record was a blot, the High Court said, and its size mattered little. It also held that he had shown no remorse, that the inquiry followed the CISF Rules, and that removal was commensurate. A review petition was dismissed on 12 July 2024 as an attempt to re-argue.

What each side argued

For the constable, the penalty was grossly disproportionate and the charges disclosed no grave or deliberate misconduct. He had no written direction to appear on 6 December and had no printed medical papers then. He never asked relatives to call the department and did not know of the video.

The five earlier penalties, it was argued, were for unrelated lapses already punished, and using them again amounted to double jeopardy. The inquiry also breached natural justice and Rule 36, because the Hindi translations came after the evidence closed and he could not cross-examine afterwards.

Under Rule 36(10)(b), he said, he was asked about a defence assistant, documents and witnesses only on 16 April. The High Court, he added, passed a non-speaking order.

His counsel relied on Bhagat Ram, J. Ahmed, Tirlok Nath, Ranjit Thakur and B.C. Chaturvedi.

Counsel for the Union said the inquiry followed the Rules and gave him enough opportunity, which he did not use in time. He had filed repeated applications for translations and a new Inquiry Officer to derail and delay the proceedings, it was said.

The respondents also said he had been non-cooperative, allegedly misbehaved with witnesses and failed to identify his wife in the video or the relatives who called. His five penalties showed he had not changed despite repeated chances.

The limits of review in disciplinary cases

The court framed the principal question as:

“whether the Division Bench was justified in dismissing the petition filed by the Appellant” (para 10)

It added the second limb, upholding the penalty of removal from service with immediate effect. The bench began with S. Sree Rama Rao, under which a High Court may interfere where the inquiry breaches natural justice or the statutory rules, or where the conclusion is arbitrary and capricious.

If the inquiry is otherwise properly held, the departmental authorities are the sole judges of facts. Where there is some legal evidence, its adequacy is not for a writ court.

Quantum is a distinct question. A constitutional court would not ordinarily substitute its own view of the penalty. But where the punishment is so disproportionate that it shocks the conscience, it is arbitrary and offends Article 14.

The bench cited Bhagat Ram, Ranjit Thakur, Giriraj Sharma and Chaturvedi for this.

It quoted Chaturvedi for the point that a court should mould relief, either by sending the penalty back or, in exceptional and rare cases, by imposing one itself with cogent reasons.

Charge I: no proof of any direction

The bench asked whether the department had shown that the constable was specifically directed to appear on 6 December and deliberately disobeyed. The charge memorandum disclosed no specific written direction, and the inquiry record placed before the court showed no contemporaneous material of the alleged communication.

The absence of a written direction or telephone record may not be conclusive, it said. But without other reliable evidence that the direction reached him, deliberate disobedience could not be sustained on the allegation alone.

His wife’s serious condition and his request for more leave were relevant to the resignation. They needed examination before he was said to have meant to pressure the administration.

Charge II: a video he did not circulate

PW-1 had said the video, though of the constable’s wife, was not sent by him and came from a different mobile number. The record also showed that he was at the unit when it was recorded at the hospital.

The inquiry, the bench held, disclosed no satisfactory evidence that he circulated the video, caused it to be circulated, or instigated relatives to threaten the authorities.

That the video concerned his wife, or that people claiming to be his relatives called, was not enough without evidence linking their conduct to him. Disciplinary liability, the court said, must rest on misconduct attributable to the employee and established in the inquiry.

Charge III: old penalties cannot be recycled

Past misconduct for which an employee has already been punished cannot by itself be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct. A service record may be considered when fixing the penalty for a later misconduct that has independently been established, where the rules allow.

It cannot make up for a deficiency of proof in the present proceedings. The reference to five minor penalties established no independent misconduct and could not strengthen charges that had otherwise not been proved.

Hindi papers came late; no defence assistant

The bench noticed procedural irregularities too. The charge documents were in English, which the constable did not follow, and the Hindi translations he sought on 24 January 2018 arrived on 29 March, after the prosecution evidence closed.

That delay, the court said, deprived him of an effective opportunity to understand the material and prepare a defence.

It also noted that his request for a defence assistant was not granted despite Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules. Given his difficulty with the language and the nature of the charges, the denial assumed significance. Together, these showed he was not given an effective and meaningful opportunity to defend himself.

A penalty that shocks

The Inquiry Officer’s findings could not be sustained, the bench concluded. Even if the conditional resignation were taken as established, it could not be divorced from the wife’s serious condition and the difficulty over leave.

Viewed as a whole, the conduct disclosed no grave or deliberate act of indiscipline that warranted removal. The court found the penalty manifestly excessive and disproportionate to whatever misconduct was established.

It recalled Ranjit Thakur, in which the court said a sentence has to suit the offence and the offender:

“It should not be vindictive or unduly harsh.” (para 24, quoting Ranjit Thakur)

Order

The appeals were allowed on 16 November. The Delhi High Court’s judgment of 14 February 2024 in Writ Petition (Civil) 8173 of 2020 was set aside, as was its order of 12 July 2024 in Review Petition 114 of 2024.

The removal order of 1 May 2018, affirmed by the appellate authority on 13 June 2018 and the revisional authority on 4 January 2019, was quashed. Given the passage of time, the court declined to send the matter back for a fresh inquiry.

The constable is to be reinstated forthwith with all consequential benefits and 50 per cent of the back wages from the date of his removal until reinstatement.