11,521 applied for 46 posts: Supreme Court backs written test added to Nagaland excise hiring
Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed the appeal of 16 Excise Constable aspirants, holding that a recruiting board may add an objective written test where the rules prescribe no detailed method.
Nagaland’s Department of Excise and Prohibition advertised 40 posts of Excise Constable, later raised to 46. It received 11,521 applications. Two months after the advertisement it added a written examination, and on 16 November the Supreme Court held that the department was entitled to do so.
Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra wrote the judgment for a bench with Justice Shree Chandrashekhar. The court dismissed an appeal by 16 unsuccessful aspirants against a Gauhati High Court ruling in the State’s favour.
An advertisement with two stages, then three
A meeting chaired by the Chief Minister on 16 September 2024 had resolved that departments would set up Departmental Recruitment Boards. Vacancies were to be advertised in at least two local newspapers and on department websites, and the boards were to keep the process transparent and fair.
Advertisement No EX.1/ESTT/1/2022/62-63 of 7 April 2025 invited applications from indigenous inhabitants of Nagaland for 40 posts. The qualification was Class VIII. An addendum of 14 May 2025 added six posts, taking the total to 46.
On 4 June 2025 the Board issued a corrigendum adding a written examination. Candidates were told to prepare accordingly. The Physical Test ran from 14 to 24 July 2025.
A notification of 25 July 2025 named the candidates who had qualified for the written paper. It carried 100 marks, was made of multiple-choice questions at the Class VIII standard, and had no negative marking. The date was 9 August 2025.
11,521 applicants, 2,297 through the physical test
Mr K N Balgopal, Advocate General for Nagaland, gave the court the numbers. Of 11,521 applicants, 5,985 appeared in the Physical Test and 2,297 cleared it. In his submission, an objective screening test was needed to cut that field down and keep the later stage fair.
He also said that all the appellants except one had taken the Physical Test. Ten of the sixteen had sat the written examination as well, which the appellants admitted before the High Court. Having taken part, he argued, they could not now challenge the process.
Ms Diksha Rai, counsel for the appellants, pointed to Clause 4 of the advertisement. It listed two stages, a Physical Test and a Suitability Test or Viva-Voce. A written examination, she said, was contrary to those terms.
She relied on the Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999 and a Memorandum of 19 July 2016 issued by the Commissioner of Excise and Prohibition. The selection criteria, she argued, could not change once the process had begun.
Single Judge quashed, Division Bench reversed
The Single Judge allowed Writ Petition (Civil) No 128 of 2025 on 16 October 2025. The Government could choose a selection method where the Rules were silent, he reasoned, but the method had to be stated in the original advertisement.
He found the Board validly constituted and no prejudice shown on that count. But he held that the Board could not itself change the selection procedure, and that the department was bound by the 2016 Memorandum on physical and medical standards. The corrigendum and the Physical Test were quashed.
The State appealed. On 3 December 2025 the Division Bench let the process continue, with results not to be declared without its leave. On 23 June 2026 it allowed Writ Appeal No 39 of 2025 and set aside the Single Judge’s judgment.
A selection list already notified
The State told the Supreme Court that the process had moved on. Of the candidates in the field, 211 were called for interview, roughly five for each post. Interviews were held from 19 to 21 February 2026.
The Board met on 24 June 2026 and administrative approval followed on 26 June. The list of 46 selected candidates was notified on 29 June. All 46 conveyed their acceptance between 1 and 8 July.
The State objected that the appellants had not disclosed this and had not impleaded the selected candidates. This court had issued notice and granted a stay on 7 July 2026.
The appellants replied that three acceptance letters arrived only on 8 July and that no one had yet been appointed. The bench decided the appeal on its merits.
Why the written test stood
The bench started with the 1999 Rules. Rule 5(i)(a) provides for direct recruitment through “competitive examination/selection”, and Rule 7(1) provides for a Selection Board. Schedule II makes direct recruitment the method for the Group C post of Excise Constable, and Schedule III sets Class VIII as the qualification.
A written examination at the Class VIII standard, the court held, falls within that expression. Nothing in the process contravened the Rules. Rule 5(ii), which requires the Government to consult the Commission before adopting a different method, was therefore not attracted.
On the 2016 Memorandum, the bench agreed with the Division Bench. It had not been confirmed by the Selection Board or notified by the State Government, and had not been strictly enforced in earlier recruitments. At its highest, it prescribed minimum physical and medical standards for athletic activities.
The Board had been constituted for this recruitment, consistent with the decision of 16 September 2024. The Single Judge had himself accepted that it was validly constituted under Rule 7. Under Clause 15 the advertisement let the Board correct any omission by notifications and addenda, and Clause 16 gave it the final word on disputes about the process.
Weightage, publicity and prejudice
The appellants called the written test arbitrary because it came after the advertisement and carried 100 marks against 12 for the viva-voce, a figure disclosed in reply to an RTI query. The court did not accept this. It saw the objective test as a better method:
“provides a means of assessing candidates on a common basis” (para 15)
It added that an objective paper avoids placing disproportionate reliance on the comparatively subjective assessment inherent in a viva-voce. The decision to add it, the court said, was taken against an exceptionally large number of applicants for 46 posts.
The corrigendum of 4 June 2025 was widely publicised, including in the local newspapers Nagaland Post and Eastern Mirror, as the Department had earlier resolved. The Division Bench had also rightly noted that every candidate who qualified in the Physical Test faced the same requirement and had an equal opportunity.
The appellants, the bench said, had not shown how the process was discriminatory or how they were prejudiced. They had taken part in it knowing the revised procedure. Where the Rules prescribe no detailed method, the competent recruiting authority has discretion to devise selection or shortlisting procedures.
Order
The court granted leave, found no ground to interfere with the Division Bench judgment of 23 June 2026, and dismissed the appeal. Civil Appeal No 14203 of 2026 arose out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No 22477 of 2026.
The judgment is marked reportable and dated 16 November 2026. The Single Judge’s order of 16 October 2025 stays set aside.