Debentures are not payment: Supreme Court keeps Rs 2,962 crore Videocon plan set aside
Justices Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Alok Aradhe held that dissenting lenders must be paid in money, upheld the remand to the creditors, and kept the foreign oil and gas assets out of the Videocon insolvency.
The resolution plan for the Videocon group offered Rs 2,962.02 crore against admitted claims of Rs 64,838.63 crore, and 95.09 per cent of the lenders voted for it. On 16 November the Supreme Court held that it still could not stand, because the lenders who voted against it were to be paid mostly in debentures redeemable over six years.
A bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe dismissed every appeal in a large batch under Section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Justice Aradhe wrote the judgment, which runs in two parts: one on the plan, one on the group’s foreign oil and gas assets.
Eleven plans, one winner, thirteen companies
Insolvency proceedings began against thirteen Videocon group companies on applications by State Bank of India and other creditors. The NCLT, Mumbai consolidated the processes on 8 August 2019. The resolution professional received eleven plans, and two were found compliant: one from Twinstar Technologies Limited and one from V Shape Investment Management Limited.
Twinstar’s amended plan of 7 November 2020 carried a total outlay of Rs 2,962.02 crore. It offered Rs 200 crore upfront to financial creditors, Rs 52 crore to workmen and employees, and Rs 10 crore to operational creditors.
The bulk came as non-convertible debentures of Rs 2,700 crore face value at a 6.65 per cent coupon. The first instalment of Rs 200 crore fell due 25 months after closing, and four of Rs 625 crore each followed in the third to sixth years. Financial creditors would also get 8 per cent equity in Videocon Industries Limited.
Four dissenters, 3.077 per cent of the vote
The creditors’ committee approved the plan on 11 December 2020 with 95.09 per cent of the voting share. Four financial creditors holding about 3.077 per cent dissented: Bank of Maharashtra (1.97 per cent), IFCI Limited (1.03 per cent), SIDBI (0.053 per cent) and ABG Shipyard Limited (0.024 per cent).
Clause 3.5.1 of the plan said dissenters would get no less than their liquidation entitlement under Section 53 and would be paid in priority. Clause 3.5.7 said payment would be made in all circumstances strictly under Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b).
The paperwork did not agree on the number. A distribution sheet from SBI Capital Markets put the dissenters’ share at Rs 114.21 crore. Form H, filed with the NCLT, estimated Rs 105.23 crore.
NCLT approved; NCLAT unwound it
By its order of 8 June 2021 the NCLT approved the plan under Section 31(1), deferring to the creditors’ commercial wisdom. It recorded a haircut of 95.85 per cent and noted that operational creditors would receive 0.72 per cent of their admitted claims.
The NCLT also directed that dissenting financial creditors be paid their liquidation value in cash, upfront, before any payment to assenting creditors. It asked the creditors and Twinstar to raise the payout to operational creditors, particularly MSMEs.
Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI and SIDBI appealed. On 19 July 2021 the NCLAT stayed the approval and ordered status quo ante, citing the exceptional facts of the matter. On 18 September 2021 the creditors, through SBI and holding about 94.98 per cent of the vote, told the NCLAT they wished to reconsider the plan.
The NCLAT’s judgment of 5 January 2022 made four findings. Payment through long-dated debentures was not payment under Section 30(2)(b). The NCLT’s cash direction modified the plan, which only the creditors could do.
The committee was not functus officio after approving a plan. And prior approval of the Competition Commission of India had not been shown. The NCLAT set aside both approvals and sent the matter back to the committee.
The committee met on 12 January 2022 and resolved, by 97 per cent, to invite fresh expressions of interest. A Form G followed on 18 January. On 14 February 2022 the Supreme Court issued notice and asked the committee not to proceed further.
What each side told the Court
Mr Guru Krishna Kumar, senior counsel for Twinstar, said the committee had no power to review an approval, and no new facts were recorded to justify one. The plan was binding on the committee once approved, he argued, relying on Ebix Singapore v. Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions.
He added that Rs 2,962 crore exceeded the liquidation value of Rs 2,568.13 crore, so the haircut was a commercial matter. The CCI had approved the plan on 8 December 2020, before voting closed on 11 December.
Mr N. Venkataraman, Additional Solicitor General for Bank of Maharashtra, said the plan gave dissenters neither priority nor cash. He pointed to the gap between Form H and the distribution sheet, and argued that the committee never becomes functus officio.
Mr Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General for the committee, said it acts as custodian of public trust, since most of its members are public sector banks. The power to approve a plan, he argued, carries the power to reconsider it, especially after the NCLAT’s interim order.
Remand is the only lawful course
The Court listed three questions at the outset. The third was:
“whether the CoC, having once approved a resolution plan under Section 30(4) of the Code, can revisit its decision while the approval is subject to challenge in a statutory appeal?” (para 3)
It began with jurisdiction. The Code, the bench said, is complete and self-contained. Neither the NCLT nor the NCLAT can interfere with the commercial decision of the committee or rewrite a plan, but the NCLAT can step in on the five grounds listed in Section 61(3).
The power to remit a plan to the committee follows by necessary implication, the Court held. It called remand the only lawful course where a plan is defective.
Neither tribunal may modify the plan. Outright rejection under Section 31(2) can lead to liquidation under Section 33(1)(b), which the Code treats as a last resort.
The bench drew on Jaypee Kensington and Essar Steel, both of which recognised that a defective plan goes back to the creditors. It also relied on Rule 11 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016, which preserves the tribunal’s inherent powers.
A parliamentary proviso arrives mid-case
Twinstar’s fallback was that its own plan alone be sent back, as in the Jaiprakash Associates order. The Court refused. Once approval is set aside the matter reverts to the committee, and it is not for any tribunal or this Court to tell it whether to reconsider one plan or invite fresh ones.
The Court also noted that Act 6 of 2026 has inserted a proviso to Section 31(2). It lets the adjudicating authority give the committee notice to rectify defects before rejecting a plan.
The bench said its conclusion rests on the law as it stood. The amendment, it added, confirms the legislative policy that a defective plan goes back to the committee, so the NCLAT’s order was in line with it.
Six years of paper is not money
Section 30(2)(b) requires a plan to pay dissenting financial creditors not less than their liquidation entitlement under Section 53(1). Regulation 38(1)(b) requires that they be paid in priority over those who voted for the plan.
The Court recalled that a three-judge bench in Jaypee Kensington held that this payment can only be payment in money. A creditor who chooses to quit, it said, cannot be forced to stay attached to the debtor through equities or securities.
Against a liquidation value of Rs 2,568.13 crore, financial creditors as a class were to get Rs 200 crore upfront and debentures of Rs 2,700 crore face value redeemable up to the sixth year. Dissenters were not carved out of that structure. Their entitlement was to be worked out within the same instruments.
Clause 3.5.7 did not rescue the plan. A general promise to comply with the law, the Court said, cannot replace a specific term on how, when and in what form dissenters are paid. Compliance, it held, lies:
“in the terms of the plan, and not in an undertaking to comply.” (para 27.4)
The plan therefore broke Section 30(2)(b) and Regulation 38(1)(b), which count as law in force for Section 61(3)(i). That ground for interference was made out.
The NCLT’s cash-first direction could not cure this. Because the Rs 200 crore upfront sum went to financial creditors as a class, ordering cash for dissenters altered the payment structure and the order of disbursement. That was a modification only the committee could make by the vote Section 30(4) requires.
One NCLAT finding falls, the result stands
The Court corrected the NCLAT on one point. Twinstar had placed on record, through an application filed in 2022, a CCI communication of 8 December 2020. That showed approval before voting ended on 11 December, so the proviso to Section 31(4) was met.
The finding did not change the result. The breach of Section 30(2)(b) was enough to sustain the NCLAT’s decision to send the plan back.
The creditors’ committee does not retire
On functus officio, the Court said the doctrine applies to an authority that has made a final decision and is divested of jurisdiction. The committee is a body of creditors with domain expertise, not an adjudicator. It held:
“The CoC does not cease to exist upon approving a plan.” (para 29.1)
It relied on the three-judge decision in Kalyani Transco v. Bhushan Power and Steel. That case held that an approved plan attains no finality until appeals under Sections 61 and 62 are decided, and that the committee exists until the plan is implemented or liquidation is ordered.
Here approval never became final. Statutory appeals were filed within about a month, and the NCLAT stayed the approval on 19 July 2021. The committee’s request, backed by about 95 per cent of the vote, came after that order.
The source of its power, the Court said, was not only the interim order but its continuing role under the Code. The interim order only ensured the process was not closed while the plan’s legality was under challenge.
Why the Ebix line did not help
Twinstar’s precedents did not fit, the bench said. Ebix and Amtek Auto dealt with a resolution applicant trying to walk away from an approved plan. Neither involved an approval that had been stayed and set aside on a Section 61(3) ground.
The binding character of an approved plan, the Court added, presupposes a plan that complies with the Code. It cannot shield one found to breach Section 30(2)(b).
K.N. Rajakumar arose under Section 12A. Kalpraj Dharamshi affirmed the committee’s commercial wisdom, which here favoured reconsideration.
Twinstar also cited the 26 October 2026 decision in Bank of India v SM Kamal Pasha. There the committee tried to withdraw approval of a compliant plan only because the debtor’s finances had improved.
The Court had condemned that as opportunism. Here the plan was non-compliant and set aside on appeal, so the decision did not help Twinstar, and the committee was within its rights to revisit its approval.
Where the Videocon oil and gas assets sit
Part B concerned appeals by the erstwhile promoter, Mr Venugopal Dhoot, and the VIL Vendors Association, an association of about 97 unpaid suppliers. They wanted the group’s overseas oil and gas assets, four concessions in Brazil and the Nunukan block in Indonesia, treated as assets of Videocon Industries.
The assets are held through subsidiaries. VOVL Limited owns 99 per cent of a Cayman Islands company, which owns the companies holding the Brazilian and Indonesian interests.
The Brazilian interests sit in a joint venture with a Bharat Petroleum subsidiary. The NCLT ordered their inclusion on 12 February 2020, the NCLAT stayed that order a week later, and it set the order aside on 14 May 2026.
Mr K.K. Venugopal and Mr Gopal Sankaranarayanan argued for the promoter that the subsidiaries held the assets as bare trustees under beneficial ownership agreements, and that the corporate veil should be lifted. They said claims of Rs 23,120.90 crore, about 40.2 per cent of the total, related to the assets but the assets were left out.
Subsidiary assets belong to the subsidiary
The Court held that a holding company and its subsidiary are distinct legal persons, and that the holding company does not own the subsidiary’s assets. Clause (b) of the Explanation to Section 18 excludes the assets of any Indian or foreign subsidiary, and Section 36(4)(d) does the same for the liquidation estate.
The Beneficial Ownership Agreements, it said, are intra-group arrangements that do not transfer a subsidiary’s assets to its parent. Lender correspondence and admissions cannot confer title either.
Alpha Corp Development and LIC v. Escorts could not override a statutory exclusion. That exclusion, the Court said, admits no qualification about how the subsidiary acquired the assets.
The Court also held the promoter estopped. It listed his own conduct: a 17 January 2017 letter asking SBI to shift facilities to the subsidiary alone, participation in valuation and monetisation, a Section 12A proposal that excluded the offshore assets, no objection to the plan, and a consolidation application that sought no inclusion of the foreign subsidiaries.
Haircut, fraud and the BPRL deal
The haircut and the adequacy of liquidation value, the Court said, are within the commercial wisdom of the creditors. The liquidation value was the average of two registered valuers and was never challenged. The promoter’s Section 12A proposal had been rejected by 98.14 per cent of the vote, also without challenge.
Allegations of fraud against SBI, the resolution professional and the creditors were general and lacked particulars. The March 2018 invocation of the pledge over VOVL shares was enforcement of security by VOVL’s lenders. A challenge to a pre-insolvency transaction, the Court said, lies only under the Code before the adjudicating authority.
On the VOVL process, the Court held that BPRL exercised a pre-existing right of first refusal under the Quotaholders’ Agreement. The VOVL creditors approved the deal by 99.96 per cent, and the NCLT approved it.
The transaction has concluded, and BPRL has acted on it. BPRL told the Court it invested about USD 1,092 million and paid about USD 151 million to cure defaults. The promoter had no locus, and no ground was made out to interfere.
Guardrails on remand
The Court then set limits on the NCLAT’s remand power, because remand costs time, certainty and asset value. It laid down five considerations.
Remand must serve the Code’s objectives of keeping the debtor a going concern, fair recovery for all classes of creditors and value maximisation. It must rest on a finding of legal non-compliance, under Section 30(2) or any other law within Section 61(3)(i).
It is to be used sparingly and without departing from any procedure the Code prescribes. It may also correct an adjudicating authority that modified a curable plan instead of sending it back. Every remand order must carry a strict direction to follow the Code’s timelines.
Order
In Part A, the three appeals filed by Twinstar, Civil Appeal Nos. 894, 512 and 509 of 2022, are dismissed with no order as to costs. GAIL (India) Limited’s claim is to be dealt with by the resolution professional under the Code.
The NCLAT is to decide GAIL’s pending Company Appeal No. 908 of 2025 in light of the judgment, and all its contentions are left open.
The Union of India’s applications were disposed of with liberty to state its contentions on the oil and gas blocks before the resolution professional and the adjudicating authority when a plan dealing with them is placed.
In Part B, the promoter’s appeals are dismissed: Civil Appeal 1307 of 2022, Civil Appeals 8659 to 8661 and 8718 to 8719 of 2026, and the appeal from Diary 41234 of 2026.
The VIL Vendors Association’s appeal from Diary No. 41286 of 2026 is dismissed, with liberty to pursue remedies available under law. There is no order as to costs.