Supreme Court rejects Rs 388 crore land bill: Housing Board kept the costlier land it took
Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe dismissed appeals by Uttar Pradesh and its Housing Board, holding that Gaursons India owes nothing more for a replacement plot in Ghaziabad.
The Uttar Pradesh Housing Board acquired 12.047 acres in Ghaziabad and built its Vasundhara Scheme on them. It then gave the owners replacement land that had already been set aside for a bird sanctuary. When a usable plot was finally allotted, the State and the Board asked for Rs 388 crore.
On 17 November the Supreme Court said no. Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe dismissed the appeals of the State and the Board and upheld an Allahabad High Court judgment of 7 February 2023 that had set the demand aside.
The bench said the appeals raised no question of law. It went through the facts only because the appellants argued the case in high-pitched terms, and it reached the same conclusion as the High Court.
A 1995 compromise over 12.047 acres
The Housing Board notified the Vasundhara Scheme in Ghaziabad on 26 June 1982 and 28 February 1987. It acquired 12.047 acres owned by M/s Mohan Meakins Limited and M/s National Cereals Products Limited, the predecessors of the first respondent, M/s Gaursons India Pvt Ltd. Possession passed to the Board on 8 August 1989.
The Allahabad High Court quashed the notifications on 18 March 1993. The Board came to the Supreme Court, which disposed of its appeal on 20 March 1995 on the basis of a compromise between the parties.
Under the compromise, the owners’ 12.047 acres would be adjusted in the scheme. That land would be used for construction related to water purification, and the rest kept open. No party would pay any value or compensation for the exchange.
Replacement land that was a lake
An exchange deed followed on 24 September 2004. The Board allotted 3.23 acres in Khasra number 948 and 8.809 acres in Khasra number 1454 at Arthala village, Ghaziabad. The deed repeated the use condition: water purification works, with the remaining land kept open.
On 1 August 2005 the original owners sold that land to Gaursons for Rs 12 crore. The same year it came to light that the District Magistrate of Ghaziabad had resumed both parcels on 21 March 1994 for a bird sanctuary. Revenue records showed number 948 as a lake and number 1454 as banjar, or waste, land.
Gaursons went to the High Court, which on 13 June 2006 told the Board to decide its representation. The Board rejected it on 27 July 2006, saying the sale deed described the land as residential, which conflicted with the 2004 deed.
Another round of litigation followed. In 2011 this Court asked the High Court to decide the writ petition within nine months. On 8 November 2012 the High Court set aside the Board’s rejection and told Gaursons to put its grievance to the State.
The Siddharth Vihar swap, and the houses
The State asked the Board for a report on a settlement. On 18 June 2014 the Board, at its 228th meeting, decided to allot a plot under its Siddharth Vihar Yojana on payment of land conversion charges and fees. Gaursons paid Rs 32,45,36,105, and a second Exchange Deed was executed on 25 January 2016.
Gaursons took possession and built 2,476 general houses and 450 EWS/LIG houses under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana. The houses were sold, and third-party rights were created.
Separately, a public interest litigation filed in 2010 had asked the High Court to protect the bird sanctuary. On 6 September 2010 the court ordered status quo between the parties.
On 3 July 2017 it told the Chief Secretary to inquire how Gram Sabha land had been resumed and then exchanged with private builders. A three-member committee reported, and a letter of 13 September 2017 said the 2005 sale deed breached the 2004 deed and the 1995 order.
The Chief Secretary’s order and the notice
The PIL was closed as infructuous on 9 January 2018, and the Board stopped Gaursons’ construction on 27 June 2018. On Gaursons’ petition, the High Court told the Chief Secretary to decide its representation.
His order of 21 June 2022 made two points that mattered. The land under the 2016 deed, now built over, should be allotted at the current bulk sale rate to protect homebuyers. And 12.047 acres in Khasra number 1454 could be handed to Gaursons only for a sewage treatment plant or water purification works, as open and green land.
The Housing Commissioner issued a demand notice on 15 September 2022 for Rs 388 crore. Gaursons challenged the order and the notice in two writ petitions.
What the High Court set aside
On 7 February 2023 the High Court allowed the petitions. It set aside the bulk-rate condition, the use restriction and the demand notice. It also told the authorities to decide afresh, preferably within two months, Gaursons’ application for allotment of the 450 EWS and LIG houses.
The State and the Board appealed. While the appeals were pending, the State formed a Special Investigation Team. Its report went before the Supreme Court under an order of 5 January 2024 and said officials of the Housing Board, besides Gaursons and its predecessors, were involved in fraudulent transactions.
The case for the State and the Board
Attorney General R Venkataramani and Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati appeared for the State, and Senior Advocate P N Misra for the Board. They argued that the 1995 order and clause 4 of the 2004 deed confined the land to water purification, yet the 2005 sale deed recited residential use.
The 2016 deed, they said, ignored those covenants and rested on Gaursons’ misrepresentations. They relied on the SIT’s finding that the Principal Secretary, Housing, pressed the Housing Commissioner to call the 2014 meeting, and that the use conditions were left out on purpose.
On that footing, they alleged collusion between Board officials and Gaursons in getting the 2016 deed executed.
Gaursons: the Board kept the better land
Veenu Singhal, appearing for Gaursons, said the owners gave up 12.047 acres in the older Vasundhara Scheme. The Board developed and monetised that land, with higher circle rates, and paid no compensation. It could not treat the 2016 deed as a fresh commercial allotment at bulk rates.
The original owners waited nine years after the 1995 order for usable land. Gaursons, which bought in 2005, then faced criminal proceedings, a withheld completion certificate and non-allotment of the 450 houses. It had also paid Rs 32.45 crore in conversion charges, despite the order that no party would pay for the exchange.
Why the use restriction fell away
The bench began with the compromise. Clause 3 spoke of the “said land” to be adjusted in the scheme, and the court read that as the acquired land of the predecessors, not any parcel the Board might allot later. The condition on use was tied to that land.
The 1995 order also obliged the Board to find alternative land free of any encumbrance. It allotted two parcels that the District Magistrate had already resumed for a sanctuary, and whose records showed a lake and banjar land. The court said that “no due diligence was exercised by the Housing Board” (para 25).
The 2004 deed therefore failed, through no fault of the owners, and its clause 4 could not bind Gaursons. The court upheld the High Court’s setting aside of the use restriction in the Chief Secretary’s order.
The sale deed and the 2016 deed stand
On the 2005 sale deed, the bench saw no bar. The land was given in lieu of the predecessors’ own land, and a person with title can transfer it.
The deed also said that if the Board gave land elsewhere in lieu, or paid compensation, the buyer company would be entitled to receive it. The bench read this as an assignment, so any later plot vested in Gaursons.
The 2016 deed was a fresh registered instrument, signed with the State’s no-objection, for a different plot in a different scheme. It described the plot as residential freehold and allowed residential construction in clauses 12 to 16.
The Board kept its regulatory hold. Under clause 15, Gaursons had to get its layout plan approved by the Board and pay development charges, layout plan charges and shelter fees before sanction.
Clause 13 carried over only one term of the compromise: no value or consideration payable. The parties chose which terms would govern the substituted land, the court said, so the 2004 stipulations could not be read into it.
Why the bulk-rate demand failed
The State argued that without the bulk rate the exchequer would lose more than Rs 388 crore. The bench pointed to the 2016 deed itself. Clause 13 recorded that no consideration was payable, and clause 5 recorded that the acquired land had been used in the Vasundhara Scheme with third-party rights created.
The Board’s own explanatory note for the 228th meeting called Vasundhara older and fully developed, with a considerably higher circle rate than Siddharth Vihar. The gap in rates and the Rs 32.45 crore already paid, in the court’s words, left:
“no ground for the Housing Board to demand anything more” (para 33.2)
The Board had kept and developed land of greater value without paying the predecessors anything. It could not ask for a further price for the substitute plot, the bench held.
The SIT report is left open
The State and the Board also relied on the SIT’s finding that Board officials and Gaursons colluded. Gaursons objected to the constitution of the SIT and to its report.
The bench expressed no opinion on the report or on what follows from it. It kept the matter open so that the authority concerned can act in accordance with law.
Order
Civil Appeal Nos 9025, 9026 and 9027-9028 of 2026, filed against the High Court’s judgment of 7 February 2023 in Writ-C Nos 19048 and 29931 of 2022, were dismissed.
The two months the High Court gave the State to allot the 450 EWS and LIG houses were extended by three months from the date of the Supreme Court’s judgment. The parties bear their own costs, and pending applications stand disposed of.