Order uploaded 12 days late, appeal on day 55: NCLAT says upload cannot restart limitation
The NCLT Mumbai dismissed an application on the day it first came up, in the presence of the appellant's counsel, and uploaded the order on 8 April 2026. The Principal Bench holds that limitation ran from 27 March, and that an appeal filed on 21 May is past even the 45-day outer limit.
The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at New Delhi has dismissed an insolvency appeal as time-barred. It held that a 12-day gap between an NCLT order and its upload to the website did not move the date from which limitation runs.
The appeal was filed on 21 May 2026 against an NCLT Mumbai order of 27 March 2026, which is 55 days later. The order of 6 November 2026 was written by Justice Mohd. Faiz Alam Khan, Member (Judicial), and signed with Naresh Salecha, Member (Technical).
A dismissal on the first hearing
Ajay Singh Narania had moved I.A. No. 1243 of 2026 before NCLT Mumbai Bench-V, in C.P.(IB) No. 203/MB/2021. On 27 March 2026 the Adjudicating Authority declined to issue notice and dismissed the application. The order reached the NCLT website on 8 April 2026.
Narania appealed under Section 61 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), together with an application under Rule 31 read with Rule 11 of the NCLAT Rules, 2016, to condone a delay of 13 days. He had applied for a certified copy of the order on 20 May, a day before filing.
The appellant: the order was never pronounced
Advocate J. Rajesh, first named for the appellant, argued that the case was not fixed for pronouncement on 27 March. The cause list placed it under the caption "Supplementary", and it was absent from the cause list of 8 April.
On that footing, he said, time ran from the upload. Thirty days from 8 April ended on 8 May, which made the delay 13 days. He relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Sanjay Pandurang Kalate v. Vistra ITCL (India) Limited, 2023 INSC 1063.
He added that Narania lives in Jammu and Kashmir, and that his attorney and his advocate are not Delhi residents. Briefing counsel and coordinating took time, he said. The delay was neither deliberate nor careless.
The respondents: open court, counsel present
Advocate Parthiv T. Mehta appeared for respondent no. 2. The respondents said the application was listed for the first time on 27 March, was dismissed that day, and the order was pronounced in open court with counsel for both sides present. No separate listing for pronouncement was needed.
They pointed out that the certified copy was sought only on 20 May, with the appeal filed the next day. Limitation, they said, runs from pronouncement. They relied on Supreme Court authority and on NCLAT's rulings in Directorate of Enforcement v. Anil Kumar Mittal and Mukesh Sumer Mal Sanghvi v. RD Engineer (India) Private Limited.
Kalate did not help the appellant, they said. The appeal had been filed beyond 45 days, a delay the tribunal has no jurisdiction to condone.
Why the upload date did not matter
The tribunal began with the record. The NCLT order showed that Narania was represented by Advocate Amir Arsiwala, and it carried the date 27 March 2026. Nothing placed before NCLAT showed that the order was not pronounced that day.
The appellant's only point, the bench noted, was that the case was not listed for pronouncement. It accepted that the order was uploaded on 8 April. But it held that an order passed in the presence of the appellant's counsel makes the later upload irrelevant:
"its uploading on any subsequent date is immaterial" (para 11)
Limitation therefore began on 27 March 2026. Section 61(2) IBC allows 30 days, and its proviso lets NCLAT condone a further delay of at most 15 days on sufficient cause. The tribunal also recalled Rule 3 of its Rules and Section 12(1) of the Limitation Act, 1963, which exclude the day from which the period is reckoned.
Kalate turned on a different fact
The bench distinguished Kalate. There the cause list showed the matter listed for admission, and it was undisputed that no substantive order was passed on 17 May 2023. The order surfaced on 30 May, so limitation ran from the upload.
Here, the bench said, the order was pronounced in court, so V. Nagarajan v. SKS Ispat and Power Limited governs. Time runs from the day of pronouncement. Only the time taken to supply a certified copy is excluded, and only if the application was made within the 30 days.
The tribunal added Sanket Kumar Agarwal v. APG Logistics Private Limited. It records that limitation stops on e-filing, that the pronouncement day is excluded, and that certified-copy time is excluded only if the application falls within the limitation period.
No power beyond 45 days
The bench then quoted Tata Steel Ltd. v. Raj Kumar Banerjee (2025). The Supreme Court held there that once the 30 and 15 days expire, NCLAT cannot entertain an appeal whatever the reason, and set aside an order condoning delay. The tribunal reproduced the Court's conclusion:
"no power to condone delay beyond the period stipulated under the statute" (para 18)
It also cited a coordinate bench in Supreme Construction Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. Puranik Builders Ltd. (2024). That bench had distinguished Kalate where the order dismissing an application was passed with both parties present, and held that limitation began on the date of the order.
Order
NCLAT held that the NCLT order was pronounced on 27 March 2026 in the presence of the appellant's counsel. The 30 days ended on 26 April 2026. The appeal, filed on 21 May 2026, lay beyond the 45 days that the tribunal can condone.
It dismissed the application for condonation of delay, and with it the appeal. There was no order as to costs.