NCLAT COMPANY APPEAL IBC NCLAT A stalled creditor-class swap cannotpush a housing project to liquidation
[ NCLAT ]

NCLAT pauses the CIRP clock on a near-complete housing project until NCLT rules on a new AR

A committee of creditors made up only of home buyers wanted to replace their authorised representative, who they said was blocking votes. The NCLT sat on the application and refused to stop the clock on Real Tech Constructions. The Principal Bench excludes the waiting time and asks the NCLT to decide at the earliest.

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at New Delhi has stopped the insolvency clock on a nearly finished housing project. The clock stays stopped until the NCLT decides whether the home buyers' authorised representative can be replaced.

The order of 6 November 2026 allows the appeal of Manindra Kumar Tiwari, resolution professional (RP) of Real Tech Constructions Pvt. Ltd. It was written by Justice Mohd. Faiz Alam Khan, Member (Judicial), and signed with Naresh Salecha, Member (Technical).

Three professionals, one stalled process

The corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) began on 28 April 2025 in C.P.(IB) No. 726/(PB)/2024. The first interim resolution professional, Pankaj Khetan, was unwilling to continue. The committee of creditors (CoC), with 100 per cent voting share, appointed Jugraj Singh Bedi in his place.

The appellant said Bedi took no concrete step beyond the public announcement and verification of claims. On 29 November 2025 the CoC replaced him. The NCLT allowed the substitution on 8 January 2026.

The appellant took charge that day, though the order was communicated to him only on 21 January. He reviewed the process, verified claims and visited the site. The project, he said, was substantially complete.

Extensions, then a creditor-class impasse

The 180 days under Section 12 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code expired on 25 October 2025. The CoC authorised the appellant to seek exclusion of 220 days, from 16 June 2025 to 21 January 2026. On 19 February 2026 the NCLT declined exclusion but allowed him to seek an extension.

The appellant filed I.A. No. 1345 of 2026 on 25 March, and the NCLT allowed a 90-day extension on 7 April. By his account, that carried the CIRP to 6 July 2026.

On 14 April 2026, financial creditors in the class holding more than 10 per cent of the vote asked him to replace the authorised representative (AR). Their grounds were non-cooperation and obstruction of voting. On 1 May the CoC approved the change and named Rajiv Khurana as the new AR.

The appellant filed I.A. No. 2115 of 2026 for the replacement. It was still pending. He also sought exclusion of the time from 1 May until that application was decided, in I.A. No. 2933 of 2026.

NCLT: the AR sits inside the process

NCLT New Delhi Bench (Court-II) dismissed the exclusion application on 7 July 2026 in C.P.(IB) No. 726/(PB)/2024. Its reason, as the appeal records, was that the AR is a part of the CIRP and cannot be treated as outside it.

The RP's case: a deadlock, not delay

Advocate Gaurav Gupta appeared for the appellant. No appearance was marked for the respondents. He argued that the delay was caused by the AR, and that the deadlock could end only when I.A. No. 2115 of 2026 was decided.

At the CoC meeting of 6 July 2026, he said, the chairperson reported that the replacement application had stalled critical stages needing the CoC's participation. Little construction was left. The CoC consists only of home buyers, who want resolution and not liquidation.

He cited NCLAT's decisions in Kiran Martin Gulla, RP of Varadharaja Foods Private Limited and Bhim Sain Goyal v. The American Swan Lifestyle Company Private Limited. He also cited the Supreme Court's rulings in Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Limited v. Satish Kumar Gupta and Swiss Ribbons Private Limited v. Union of India.

Regulation 16A and the stalled application

The bench began with what it saw as undisputed. The NCLT extended the CIRP by 90 days on 7 April 2026. Creditors holding more than 10 per cent of the class vote asked for a new AR on 14 April, under Regulation 16A(3A) of the CIRP Regulations, 2016.

It set out the mechanism. Under Regulation 16A(3A), creditors with at least 10 per cent of the class vote can seek replacement of the AR with an insolvency professional of their choice. The RP circulates the request and opens a voting window of at least 24 hours.

Under Regulation 16A(3C), the RP then applies to the Adjudicating Authority to appoint the professional who received the highest share of votes in that class. That application, I.A. No. 2115 of 2026, was the one pending.

The bench found it admitted that the CoC approved the change on 1 May 2026 because the AR was persistently not cooperating, and that the RP's application was pending. When an AR obstructs and the CoC decides to replace him, it said, the application should have been decided immediately.

"the exclusion, as prayed by the Appellant, should have been granted" (para 23)

Home buyers and a project almost done

The bench then looked at the stakes. The corporate debtor is in real estate, and hundreds of home buyers have a stake in it. It was told that construction was almost complete, with only minor work left.

"would not be in the interest of any stakeholder" (para 24)

That was the bench's view of pushing the company into liquidation. It concluded that the exclusion should have been allowed, and that the impugned order could not stand. The decisions cited by the appellant were not discussed in its reasoning.

Order

NCLAT allowed the appeal and set aside the NCLT order of 7 July 2026. It excluded from the CIRP of Real Tech Constructions the period from 1 May 2026 until the adjudication of I.A. No. 2115 of 2026.

The bench requested the NCLT to dispose of that application at the earliest. There was no order as to costs, and pending applications were disposed of.