Plan sat idle 11 months on its own clause: NCLAT quashes IBBI referral of RP, bidder and bank
NCLT Mumbai had referred the erstwhile RP, the successful resolution applicant and Saraswat Co-operative Bank to the IBBI for leaving an approved plan unimplemented from August 2024 to July 2025. The Principal Bench holds that clause 5.7(ii) let a pending appeal pause payment, that NCLT approved it unmodified, and that the applicant was never heard.
The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at New Delhi has set aside an NCLT Mumbai direction to refer the conduct of a resolution professional, a successful resolution applicant and a co-operative bank to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI).
The referral followed a resolution plan that stayed unimplemented for 11 months. NCLAT found the delay flowed from a clause the NCLT itself had approved.
The common judgment of 6 November 2026 was written by Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan, Member (Judicial). Naresh Salecha, Member (Technical), sat with him. It decides two appeals against one NCLT order of 4 September 2026 concerning Sristi Hospitality Private Limited.
Appeal 1978 of 2026 was filed by Rajan Deshraj Agarwal, the erstwhile resolution professional (RP) and chairman of the plan's monitoring committee. Appeal 1959 of 2026 came from the successful resolution applicant (SRA), the Consortium of Admas Industries Pvt Ltd and others. Both were allowed.
Approved July 2024, paid July 2025
Sristi Hospitality entered the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) on 27 February 2023, on a Section 7 petition filed by one of its directors, Santosh R. Shetty. Agarwal was appointed interim resolution professional that day and was later confirmed as RP.
The Committee of Creditors (CoC) approved the SRA's plan with 100 per cent of the vote on 5 August 2023. NCLT Mumbai approved it on 12 July 2024 in IA 3612 of 2023.
Clause 9.3 of the plan set a 46-day timeline for implementation. It ended on 27 August 2024. Meanwhile the suspended director appealed to NCLAT in appeals 1378 and 1383 of 2024.
On 23 July 2024 NCLAT passed an interim order saying implementation of the plan could go on, subject to the result of those appeals. It did not stay the plan. Both appeals were dismissed on 14 July 2026.
Nothing moved for about a year. On 7 July 2025, hearing a second status report in IA 1662 of 2025, NCLT asked the RP why the plan had not been implemented and, if it could not be, why liquidation had not been started. The plan was implemented, and the company handed to the SRA, on 30 July 2025.
The NCLT order that triggered the appeals
On 6 January 2026 NCLT held that clause 5.7(ii) of the plan could not override clause 10.15, under which the plan was unconditional except for NCLT approval. It held that the delay was contrary to Sections 30(2) and 30(4) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code and Regulation 38(3) of the CIRP Regulations, 2016.
The RP then sought to place a third status report on record in IA 456 of 2026. NCLT found no cogent explanation for the gap between 27 August 2024 and 30 July 2025. It noted that no material showed any extension had been sought from, or granted by, the monitoring committee.
That finding rested on the RP's statutory duty under Section 30(2) to examine the plan and the CoC's duty under Section 30(4) to weigh its feasibility and viability. NCLT said a plan must carry specific timelines, and that the commercial wisdom of the CoC cannot override the law.
It also noted that the RP had been bound either to get the plan implemented within the timelines or to move for liquidation. Its order of 4 September 2026 called the SRA's stand that it would pay only after favourable orders from NCLAT a violation of settled law.
On 4 September 2026 NCLT directed that the conduct of the erstwhile RP, the SRA and Saraswat Co-operative Bank Ltd, the other member of the monitoring committee, be referred to the IBBI. The Registry was told to forward the order.
Three parties, one plan clause
Vivek Sibal, Senior Advocate, for the SRA said NCLT made adverse remarks without hearing it, and when it was not even a party to the application. The SRA argued that it acted on a bona fide reading of clause 5.7(ii). It deposited the money, counsel said, once NCLT signalled it wanted the plan implemented.
The SRA added that once a plan is approved its terms cannot be changed or dissented from, and that clause 5.7(ii) had been approved by both the CoC and NCLT. It relied on Shashidhar v Indian Overseas Bank, Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments v NBCC and Noida Industrial Development Authority v Prabjit Singh Soni.
Sumant Batra, Senior Advocate, for the RP said the monitoring committee deferred implementation with the CoC's consent while the director's appeal was pending, as the clause allowed. He argued that NCLT could not re-examine a plan it had approved.
The RP also called the finding at paragraph 20(d) of the NCLT order factually wrong. The plan had been fully implemented on 30 July 2025, he said, about five months before the order of 6 January 2026, leaving nothing to comply with.
The RP also said his term ended on 12 July 2024 and that he drew no fees afterwards as RP. His term as chairman of the monitoring committee ended on 30 July 2025, again with no fees drawn.
His counsel pointed out that NCLT's 7 July 2025 order followed the view in Kalyani Transco v Bhushan Power and Steel of 2 May 2025. That judgment was recalled on 31 July 2025 and finally decided on 26 September 2025, allowing deferment with CoC consent for reasons not attributable to the SRA. NCLAT did not discuss it.
Janender Kumar Chumbak, for Saraswat Co-operative Bank, said the plan itself foresaw litigation and fixed payment within seven business days of finality. Delay alone was not misconduct, he said, and the bank, as a custodian of public money, was paid on implementation.
Clause 5.7(ii) read plainly
NCLAT set out four clauses. Clause 5.7(ii) tied payment to the clause 9.3 timeline, provided no appeal was pending before NCLAT or the Supreme Court and no stay had been granted. Clauses 10.3 and 10.15 made the plan binding and unconditional apart from NCLT approval.
Clause 8.1 was also important, NCLAT said. It made implementation subject to no stay by any appellate authority and no proceedings seeking more money or a material change to the plan.
The Tribunal read the clauses together. Payment was due on the 46-day timeline only if no appeal was pending. Even without a stay, a pending appeal gave the SRA no foundation to pay stakeholders.
NCLT had approved the plan on 12 July 2024 without any modification, and without waiving that precondition. NCLAT drew its conclusion on the clause:
"mere pendency of the appeal was sufficient for not implementing the plan" (para 34)
A defect NCLT should have caught
NCLAT found substance in the appellants' case. It said it was NCLT's duty, when approving the plan, to notice a discrepancy "conspicuous on the face of it". The ambiguity should not have been left to the discretion of the parties.
If it was not noticed or modified, the Tribunal held, the stakeholders could not be blamed:
"cannot be held liable for the delay" (para 36)
The appellants, it accepted, honestly believed they need not implement the plan while the appeal was pending. They acted once NCLT's query of 7 July 2025 signalled otherwise.
The interim order of 23 July 2024 only recorded that no stay had been granted, NCLAT said. It could not be read as a mandate to implement the plan.
The delay was also sufficiently explained, the Tribunal added, more so as the plan was fully implemented on 30 July 2025. And NCLT had made its adverse remarks against the SRA when the SRA was not a party before it, with no chance to explain its conduct.
The order
NCLAT allowed both appeals. It set aside the observation at paragraph 19 of the NCLT order that the SRA did not implement the plan within the stipulated timeline, in violation of its express terms.
It also set aside the direction at paragraph 20 referring the conduct of the erstwhile RP, the SRA and Saraswat Co-operative Bank Ltd to the IBBI, and the paragraph 22 direction to forward the order to the IBBI.
There is no order as to costs. Pending applications were disposed of.