Rs 631 crore offer, no deposit: NCLAT upholds insolvency of Distribution Logistics Infrastructure
The suspended director offered Rs 631 crore, ten crore more than the price at which the lenders sold the loan to JM Financial ARC, but never paid the instalments NCLAT itself had allowed. The Principal Bench holds that debt and default were undisputed, the earlier OTS lapsed for want of a Rs 59 crore deposit, and lenders cannot be compelled to settle.
The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at New Delhi has upheld the insolvency of Distribution Logistics Infrastructure Private Limited. The company's suspended director had offered to pay Rs 631 crore to clear its dues. The deposits meant to back that offer never came.
The judgment of 6 November 2026 was written by Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan, Member (Judicial), with Naresh Salecha, Member (Technical). It dismisses the appeal of Sudarshan Aithal K against the NCLT Mumbai Bench-VI order of 14 May 2026 admitting a Section 7 petition by Bank of India.
A 2013 loan for container trains
In 2013 Bank of India sanctioned a term loan of Rs 57.50 crore to the company, then called Vikram Logistics Limited, for its container trains project. The loan was restructured in 2014 and again in 2016, when the aggregate sanctioned limit stood at Rs 68.84 crore.
The facilities sat in a consortium banking arrangement. In 2021 the company sought a one-time restructuring, and the lenders signed a master restructuring agreement on 26 June 2021, followed by another in 2022.
The company defaulted on 29 December 2022. Bank of India classified the account as a non-performing asset on 28 March 2023 and issued a SARFAESI Act demand notice on 23 December 2024. NCLT Mumbai admitted the Section 7 petition on 14 May 2026.
The loan changed hands mid-appeal
On 30 June 2026, while the appeal was pending, Bank of India and the other lenders assigned the loan to JM Financial Asset Reconstruction Company Limited. The aggregate consideration was Rs 621 crore.
By NCLAT's order of 22 July 2026 JM Financial ARC was arrayed as Respondent No. 3. Its counsel told the Tribunal it now holds 100 per cent of the financial debt, and that the Committee of Creditors (CoC) has been reconstituted by the resolution professional.
The director: an OTS, then a higher bid
Kunal Tandon, Senior Advocate, for the director said the company worked with the consortium from 2021 to 2025. In March 2024 it proposed a one-time settlement (OTS), offering Rs 580 crore on 15 January 2025 and later Rs 590 crore, which the consortium led by Bank of Baroda accepted.
He said Bank of Baroda asked for 10 per cent upfront on 4 October 2025, yet still ran a Swiss challenge auction of the debt. The company was declared successful bidder on 30 October 2025, with its Rs 590 crore as the anchor bid, and needed time to pay the deposit.
While the Section 7 petition was reserved for orders on 10 March 2026, Bank of Baroda rejected the OTS on 16 April 2026 for non-deposit. A fresh Swiss challenge followed with JM Financial's Rs 621 crore as anchor, and JM Financial won at that price.
The company's holding company went to the Bombay High Court against that auction and offered Rs 625 crore. Before NCLAT the offer rose to Rs 631 crore, but the CoC rejected it on 18 June 2026 as conditional.
Counsel said the stipulations were only FEMA and RBI compliances for a foreign-owned company. Even if CIRP continued, he said, the banks could recover no more than Rs 621 crore, and 120 employees would suffer. He relied on Vidarbha Industries Power v Axis Bank.
The lenders: debt admitted, offers unfunded
Krishnendu Datta, Senior Advocate, for JM Financial ARC said debt and default were admitted. The company's own OTS letter of 15 January 2025 referred to its acknowledgement of debt. Once both are established, he argued, NCLT must admit a Section 7 application.
He said the OTS letter of 20 October 2025 made the offer subject to approval by all lenders and created no binding obligation. He also said the director concealed his pending Bombay High Court writ, although the petition and the appeal were verified at New Delhi on the same date, 21 May 2026.
On repeated defaults, he pointed to the unpaid 10 per cent upfront deposit of Rs 59 crore. On 15 June 2026 the director said he was ready to deposit half of Rs 631 crore.
On 29 June 2026 the offer was recast into two instalments, by 9 July and 20 July, and NCLAT ordered deposits on those dates. Nothing was paid.
He also relied on M. Suresh Kumar Reddy v Canara Bank, which he said confines Vidarbha to its facts, and on the amended Section 12A, in force from 26 May 2026. Withdrawal of an admitted application now needs a resolution professional's application and approval of 90 per cent of the CoC.
What the Tribunal checked first
NCLAT began with the NCLT's summary of the law, drawn from Power Trust v Bhuvan Madan and other rulings. At admission the adjudicating authority checks only that a financial debt exists and that default has occurred.
It noted that the director disputed neither debt nor default before NCLT or before it. What he pressed was that Bank of India held a minority share of about 9.4 per cent, that the OTS was illegally rejected, and that the assignment to JM Financial ARC was illegal.
The Tribunal reproduced the Supreme Court's passages in Innoventive Industries v ICICI Bank. Once default on a due debt is shown, the application must be admitted, whether or not the debt is disputed. It also reproduced Suresh Kumar Reddy, which holds that Vidarbha was decided in its own setting.
Rs 59 crore never reached the lenders
On the OTS, NCLAT noted that Bank of Baroda's letter of 4 October 2025 accepted the offer on condition of a 10 per cent upfront deposit of Rs 59 crore, due by 7 October 2025. By the director's own admission the money was never paid.
On 16 April 2026 the lenders, at a joint lenders' meeting, rejected and returned the OTS. They were not obliged to accept it without the deposit, NCLAT said.
It then recounted the offers at the appeal stage: Rs 631 crore with 50 per cent upfront, recorded on 15 June 2026, and the two-instalment schedule allowed on 29 June 2026. That order was expressly without prejudice to the lenders' right to accept or reject the offer.
NCLAT recorded that the Section 7 petitioner and the CoC had spoken of a loss of trust in the director. It found that even the amount NCLAT allowed him to pay was never deposited.
It found substance in JM Financial ARC's case:
"the Appellant is guilty of repeated defaults" (para 37)
The OTS price of Rs 590 crore was never funded, the offer rose to Rs 621 crore without being honoured, and the Rs 631 crore commitment lapsed in two tranches.
Settlement now runs through Section 12A
The Tribunal also accepted that, under the amended Section 12A, any settlement or withdrawal must follow the procedure the section lays down. It recalled Ayush Prashant Aggarwal v Uma Export, which it said made the withdrawal procedure more stringent.
As the Tribunal recorded that ruling, sub-section 2 starts with a non-obstante clause. An admitted application cannot be withdrawn before the CoC is constituted or after the first invitation for resolution plans.
A financial creditor, NCLAT added, could not be compelled to accept the director's OTS, particularly when he had earlier not honoured an OTS or deposited the 10 per cent in time.
The order
NCLAT held on the admission order:
"the Ld. Adjudicating Authority has not committed any mistake in admitting the application" (para 39)
The appeal was dismissed as lacking merit. There is no order as to costs, and the pending applications were disposed of.