Rs 56.8 lakh asset-sale loss denied: Bombay HC backs view Section 41(2) is for power producers
A Division Bench of Justice G.S. Kulkarni and Justice Dr. Neela Gokhale dismissed the tax appeal of Everest Kanto Cylinder, holding that Section 41(2) of the Income Tax Act has limited application to electricity generators, so the shortfall on the company assets sold could not be claimed as a business loss.
A maker of CNG cylinders sold some of its vehicles for less than their book value and set the shortfall, Rs 56,79,598, against its business income. On 5 November 2026 the Bombay High Court held that the provision it relied on, Section 41(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, has no application to a company like it.
A Division Bench of Justice G.S. Kulkarni and Justice Dr. Neela Gokhale dismissed the appeal of Everest Kanto Cylinder Ltd. Justice Kulkarni wrote the judgment, which was reserved on 14 August 2026.
How the claim reached the High Court
Everest Kanto is a listed company that makes and exports CNG cylinders. For assessment year 2021-22 it filed its return on 11 March 2022, declaring total income of Rs 1,34,59,23,877 under Section 115JB. Under the normal provisions it declared nil income after carrying forward past losses.
In computing income it claimed Rs 56,79,598 as a loss on the sale of a block of depreciable fixed assets, under Section 41(2). The Central Processing Centre at Bengaluru disallowed it in an intimation of 14 December 2022 under Section 143(1).
The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld the disallowance by an order of 5 February 2024. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Mumbai Bench, dismissed the company’s further appeal on 20 January 2025. That order was the subject of the appeal under Section 260A.
The Bench set one wrinkle aside. The company had said two separate Tribunal orders existed, and it had filed a miscellaneous application against the first. The Bench found only one order had been uploaded and certified, and that the other appeared to have been put up inadvertently.
What each side argued
Mr Pankaj Toprani, instructed by Krupa Jimit Shah, appeared for the company. He said the Tribunal wrongly held that Section 41(2) applies only to entities generating or distributing power. He added that the Department had not raised that ground before the Commissioner (Appeals) or argued it before the Tribunal.
On the merits he relied on the Madras High Court decision in Share Aids Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO. He also cited the Tribunal in Digital Electronics Ltd. v. Addl. CIT, which this Court approved in PCIT v. Alcon Developers.
Mr Arjun Gupta appeared for the Revenue. He said the claim ignored Section 43(6), which defines Written Down Value after reducing the money payable for assets sold. Once that reduction is made, he argued, there is no business loss to claim under Section 41(2).
He distinguished Alcon Developers, where the carried-forward loss was undisputed. Here, he said, the very issue was whether the amount counts as a business loss at all. Even if the Tribunal used different reasoning, he submitted, the issue rests on reading Section 41(2).
The question the Bench framed
The Bench set out the substantial question of law at the start. When it came to decide, it put the issue this way:
“whether the provisions of Section 41(2) were applicable in the assessee’s case” (para 14)
The Tribunal had held that Section 41(2) requires depreciation under Section 32(1)(i), which refers to assets of an undertaking in power generation or generation and distribution. A company claiming depreciation on the Written Down Value method, with assets grouped as a block, fell outside it. The Tribunal treated the shortfall as a short-term capital loss under Section 50.
The Tribunal had also noted that the assets sold fell within the definition of plant, which includes vehicles. The sale value was lower than their Written Down Value.
Tracing the life of Section 41(2)
Justice Kulkarni quoted the sub-section in full. It applies to a building, machinery, plant or furniture that the assessee owns, on which depreciation is claimed under Section 32(1)(i), and which has been used for the business.
If the money payable on its sale exceeds the Written Down Value, the excess, up to the gap between actual cost and Written Down Value, is chargeable as business income.
The Bench then traced its history through the commentary Sampath Iyengar’s Law of Income Tax. Sub-section (2) was omitted with effect from 1 April 1988, when the scheme of depreciation allowance changed.
The Finance (No. 2) Act, 1998 brought it back from 1 April 1998. The quoted circular explained that depreciation for power-generation assets was to be allowed on individual assets on the straight-line method, not on blocks, and section 41(2) was inserted to match.
Block assets and the sale price
The Bench quoted the commentary on the present position. After block depreciation, section 41(2) has a limited application for assessees engaged in generating electricity and choosing straight-line depreciation. For others, the sale value of an asset in the block is deducted in working out the block Written Down Value.
Justice Kulkarni drew the conclusion directly. The provision, he said, would have
“limited application in the case of the assessee engaged in generation of electricity” (para 17)
The company did not fall in that category. For an assessee outside Section 32(1)(i), he wrote, a sale from the block means the sale value is deducted from the block Written Down Value at year end.
The commentary the Bench quoted adds that where the block itself ceases to exist, the balance of Written Down Value becomes a loss under capital gains.
The Punjab and Haryana precedent
The Bench relied on CIT v. Rhodoen Silk Mills (P) Ltd., a Division Bench ruling of the Punjab and Haryana High Court. There the Commissioner (Appeals) had held Section 41(2) inapplicable to machinery outside power generation. The Tribunal agreed, and the High Court found no substantial question of law.
In that case the plant and machinery block was intact, with an addition of Rs 75,33,668 and a sale at Rs 29,80,000. The High Court said depreciation had rightly been computed on the Written Down Value after adjusting additions and sales within the block.
Justice Kulkarni quoted that ruling at length. The Bench then said it did not agree with Mr Toprani’s reliance on Digital Electronics.
Why Digital Electronics did not help
In Digital Electronics the assessee had set off brought-forward business losses against short-term capital gains on the sale of a factory building and plant. The Tribunal there read Section 72 as requiring only that the gains be assessable, not that they be taxed as business profits.
The Bench said that decision would, in no manner, assist the company.
The judgment does not address in terms the company’s objection that the Revenue never raised the power-sector ground below. Nor does it take up Share Aids or Alcon Developers separately in its analysis. It moves straight from the statute and the commentary to the answer.
Order
The question of law was answered against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue. The appeal was dismissed, with no order as to costs. The disallowance of Rs 56,79,598 for assessment year 2021-22 stands.