Tenant cannot plead for a co-owner who wants him out: Punjab and Haryana HC upholds eviction
Justice Deepak Gupta dismissed a corporation tenant revision against concurrent eviction orders for the first and second floors of SCO 813-814, Sector 22-A, held that the other co-owner had joined the landlord in seeking possession, and gave three months to vacate.
The tenant argued that the landlord could not evict him because the other co-owner of the building had not been joined. By the time the revision was decided, that co-owner had signed a compromise to get possession jointly and had asked the executing court for warrants of possession.
On 13 November the Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed the revision of the Haryana Backward Classes Economically Weaker Section Kalyan Nigam. Justice Deepak Gupta upheld concurrent orders directing it to vacate the first and second floors of SCO No. 813-814, Sector 22-A, Chandigarh.
A 1980 tenancy and a son’s shop
The landlord, Yashpal Malhotra, filed Rent Application No. 482 of 2015 on 13 July 2015 under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949, as extended to Chandigarh. He said he and the late Amar Nath had let the premises to the tenant in 1980 at Rs 2,000 a month, now Rs 23,844.
He needed them for his son, Vishal Malhotra, who married on 27 February 2015 and wanted to start an independent retail business. The plan covered uniforms, stationery, paper items, exercise books, book binding and wiro binding.
The petition disclosed that the son was working in M/s Shiva Industries, a proprietorship of the landlord’s wife, in which the landlord held a one-third share. It also disclosed that bay shop No. 814 on the ground floor was occupied by the other co-owner, Kewal Dhingra, and that a separate eviction petition was being filed against the ground-floor tenant.
What the tenant argued below
The tenant admitted the relationship but said a petition by one co-owner was not maintainable, for non-joinder. It said the ground floor had fallen vacant, that the son already worked in his mother’s concern, and that the landlord had hidden other properties, including a commercial property in the Industrial Area, Phase I.
Issue No. 5 on non-joinder put the onus on the tenant. The landlord and his son gave evidence. The tenant examined an Estate Office data entry operator as RW-1 and its own District Manager as RW-2.
RW-1 proved against his own side. He said the SCO was allotted in 1975 to Amar Nath and Yash Pal, that Amar Nath’s half share passed by a will of 26 September 1983 and a family settlement of 14 May 2013, and that ownership now stood in the names of Mr Dhingra and the landlord.
The landlord held no other property in his name, RW-1 added, and the industrial plot belonged to neither the landlord nor his wife.
Eviction in 2017, mesne profits fixed
On 10 October 2017 the Rent Controller held the need bona fide and rejected the non-joinder plea, relying on Kasthuri Radhakrishnan v. M. Chinniyan, (2016) 3 SCC 296. He found no concealment and gave three months to vacate.
The Appellate Authority dismissed Rent Appeal No. 237 of 2017 on 21 August 2023. During that appeal, on 6 August 2019, it fixed mesne profits at Rs 1,00,000 a month from 10 October 2017. This Court dismissed the tenant’s challenge to that order on 6 December 2022.
The landlord began Execution No. 29 of 2021. Mr Dhingra objected, and the executing court allowed his application under Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure on 16 July 2024. The landlord challenged that in CR-4723-2024.
The co-owners settle
In this revision Mr Dhingra applied to be impleaded. On 23 July 2025 the two co-owners signed a compromise. They agreed to share rent and mesne profits equally, to obtain possession of both floors jointly, to contest the execution together, and to withdraw their revisions.
Clause 10 recorded that the landlord had no objection to Mr Dhingra being impleaded as co-landlord. On 8 August 2025 the High Court took the deed on record without prejudice to the parties’ rights, and Mr Dhingra’s application was dismissed as withdrawn.
The Court also directed the tenant to deposit Rs 1,00,000 a month, inclusive of rent.
On 1 October 2025 the executing court noted that the tenant had deposited only Rs 65,78,043, covering arrears to 31 July 2025, against Rs 95,66,666 due to 30 September 2025. It ordered the deposit released to the co-owners in equal shares, and the tenant challenged that in CR-7378-2025.
Six grounds for the tenant
Mr Sudeep Mahajan, Senior Advocate, appeared for the tenant. He argued that not all co-owners were impleaded, that Mr Dhingra’s need was neither pleaded nor proved, and that no permission to start business in the premises had been obtained.
He added that the Rent Controller had not discussed Issue No. 5, that the compromise was reached during the revision and could not be considered, and that execution continues the main proceedings, so Mr Dhingra’s objections there counted. He relied on India Umbrella Manufacturing Co. v. Bhagabandei Agarwalla and Mangal Builders and Enterprises v. Williamson Magor.
Mr Divanshu Jain, Advocate, for the landlord, said the findings were concurrent and rested on evidence. He relied on, among others, Hindustan Petroleum Corporation v. Dilbahar Singh, Kasthuri Radhakrishnan and Mahendra Prasad Jain v. Manoharlal Jain.
Limits of the revisional power
Section 15(5) lets the High Court examine the record for the “legality or propriety” of an order. Citing the Constitution Bench in Dilbahar Singh, the judge said this is wider than Section 115 CPC but is not an appeal.
The Court cannot reappreciate evidence because another view is possible. It can interfere only if a finding is perverse, rests on no evidence, ignores or misreads material evidence, or is contrary to law. Bona fide requirement, he noted, is essentially a question of fact.
A co-owner who supports the eviction
The law on non-joinder, the court said, is settled. A co-owner owns every part of unpartitioned property, and under Kasthuri Radhakrishnan and Mahendra Prasad Jain one co-owner can sue for eviction without joining the rest.
The tenant’s own authority, India Umbrella, explains why. The suing co-owner acts in his own right and as agent of the others, whose consent is presumed unless they are shown to disagree.
So the tenant had to show that Mr Dhingra disagreed. It led no such evidence. Mr Dhingra was not examined and raised no objection before either authority, and the petition itself named him as the co-owner occupying bay shop No. 814.
His later conduct confirmed the presumption. He agreed in the compromise to contest the execution with the landlord, asked the executing court for warrants of possession, and withdrew his impleadment application.
“cannot be set up by a tenant on behalf of a co-owner” (para 23)
The plea that a co-owner does not consent, the judge held, can be raised only where he actually dissents.
The claim that the Rent Controller ignored Issue No. 5 was factually incorrect. He took Issues 1 and 3 to 5 together, dealt with non-joinder in paras 28 and 29, and in para 33 found nothing to show the petition bad for non-joinder.
Family need counts as landlord need
A co-owner landlord, the court held, need not plead or prove the requirement of every other co-owner. The need of a dependent son is the landlord’s own, as held in Joginder Pal v. Naval Kishore Behal. Both courts below found the son’s need genuine on testimony that stood unshaken in cross-examination.
The plea of other accommodation was disproved by the tenant’s own witness. How the co-owners share the premises is a matter between them. If the premises are not used as ordered, the tenant has the safeguard of Section 13(4) of the Act.
Permission can follow possession
The plea that the competent authority had not yet permitted business in the premises was not in the written statement, was not the subject of any issue, and was not argued before the Appellate Authority. The court said it cannot be raised for the first time in revision, since it needs a factual inquiry.
On merits, it noted that the premises form part of a shop-cum-office site at a commercial location, and that the landlord had pleaded he would seek conversion from the Estate Office. Regulatory permission ordinarily follows possession and is not a precondition to eviction on the ground of bona fide need.
A landlord need not set up the business before seeking eviction, citing Balwant Singh Chaudhary v. Hindustan Petroleum, and need not even specify its nature. The court added, citing Sarla Ahuja v. United India Insurance, that a tenant cannot dictate how the landlord should arrange his affairs.
Compromise and execution objections
The court held that its findings on need, maintainability and concealment rest on the trial evidence and stand independently of the compromise. A court can in any event notice a subsequent event that bears on relief, it said, citing Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu v. Motor and General Traders.
The compromise was used only against the tenant’s plea of non-consent. The tenant could not ask the court to look at Mr Dhingra’s earlier objections in execution while shutting out the later compromise.
A subsequent event must eclipse the landlord’s need altogether to defeat a decree. A landlord is not to be penalised for litigation delay, the court said, citing Gaya Prasad v. Pradeep Srivastava.
Execution is a continuation of the suit, the court accepted, but an executing court cannot go behind the decree. Mr Dhingra’s objections there concerned his status and share in rent, and he had given them up. India Umbrella supported the landlord, and Mangal Builders turned on its own facts.
Order
The revision is dismissed, and the Rent Controller’s order of 10 October 2017 and the Appellate Authority’s judgment of 21 August 2023 are upheld. The tenant must hand over vacant possession of the entire first and second floors within three months of the judgment, failing which the executing court will issue warrants of possession.
That time is subject to the tenant filing an undertaking before the executing court within two weeks to vacate by the fixed date, and clearing all arrears of mesne profits within four weeks.
The tenant continues to pay Rs 1,00,000 a month, inclusive of rent, until possession is delivered. Arrears, including the shortfall noticed on 1 October 2025, are recoverable in execution.
The co-owners’ rights between themselves are not affected. CR-7378-2025 is disposed of in the same terms, and pending applications stand disposed of.