Justice M. Batra Punjab & Haryana HC PARTLY QUASHED Rival FIRs, one Pathankot plot
[ Punjab and Haryana High Court ]

Two rival FIRs over one Pathankot plot: Punjab and Haryana HC quashes both cheating charges

Justice Manisha Batra held that neither side could claim to be cheated by a deed it was not party to, but kept the colony-law charges alive because who developed the colony is a question of fact for trial.

Two men, two FIRs, nine days apart, both accusing the other side of cheating over a single plot in Daulatpur village near Pathankot. On 13 November the Punjab and Haryana High Court quashed the cheating charge in both. It left alive the allegations under Punjab's apartment and property law, which turn on who carved out the colony.

Justice Manisha Batra, sitting alone, disposed of two connected petitions under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure by one oral order. The petitioners were Om Parkash and Rajinder Kaur, and the order partly allowed both.

One plot, two sale deeds, a boundary overlap

Om Parkash and his brothers had inherited 20 Kanals 3 Marlas in Khasra Nos. 926, 930 and 922/1 of Daulatpur. In May 2006 two of the brothers sold 4 Kanals 8 Marlas in equal shares to Rajinder Kaur and Gurmeet Kaur.

Rajinder Kaur gave her general power of attorney to Ajay Pal Singh in October 2020. Through him she sold her 44 Marlas as plots in five sale deeds across 2020 and 2021. The last, of 23 June 2021, went to her relative Rajesh Kumar for about 0-4¾ Marlas.

On 6 June 2023 Om Parkash transferred 6.25 Marlas, his 25/676 share in Khasra No. 926, to his son Abhishek Singh. The boundaries in that deed resembled those of Rajesh Kumar's plot.

Two civil suits, then two FIRs

Abhishek Singh sued Rajesh Kumar for a permanent injunction on 27 September 2023. Rajesh Kumar sued back on 3 October, seeking a declaration of ownership and a declaration that the 6 June transfer deed was null and void. Both suits are pending before the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Pathankot.

Rajesh Kumar also came to the High Court, which on 18 December 2023 told the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Border Range, Amritsar, to examine his representation. The Tehsildar reported on 7 February 2024 that the boundaries of the two deeds tallied.

The Deputy Superintendent of Police first called the dispute civil. After objections from higher officers a Special Investigation Team reported on 6 March 2024 that Om Parkash had written dimensions similar to Rajesh Kumar's plot, left no land for streets, and could not show approval to sell plots. FIR No. 26 followed on 7 March 2024.

The cross-FIR against Rajinder Kaur

Om Parkash had gone to the High Court too. On 19 February 2024 it told the Senior Superintendent of Police, Pathankot, to decide his representation by a speaking order.

The police reported on 14 March that Rajinder Kaur had sold 44.06 Marlas as plots without approval, 0.06 Marla more than her share. FIR No. 31 was registered on 16 March 2024. Both FIRs invoked Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 36(3) of the Punjab Apartment and Property Regulation Act, 1995.

Om Parkash was refused anticipatory bail by the Additional Sessions Judge on 13 March 2024 and granted it by the High Court on 10 April. His challan was presented on 20 June 2026, with charge fixed for 15 September 2026.

Rajinder Kaur got anticipatory bail from the Sessions Judge on 16 April 2024. The High Court stayed further investigation in her FIR on 2 July 2024.

What each side argued

Advocate Munish Puri, for Om Parkash, said his client never sold land to either Rajinder Kaur or Rajesh Kumar. He had only transferred his recorded share to his son, and the identity of the plot was a civil question the civil court was already handling.

Advocate Onkar Singh Batalvi, for Rajinder Kaur, said she sold nothing beyond her share and was neither a promoter nor an estate agent. The colony had been carved out by Om Parkash and his brothers, and the FIR was a means to pressure her relative Rajesh Kumar.

Senior Deputy Advocate General Ruchika Sabherwal, for Punjab, opposed both. She said FIR 26 came after a detailed enquiry ordered by the court, and that revenue records showed the land transferred to the son was a rasta. FIR 31 rested on 44.06 Marlas sold as plots without approval.

Rajesh Kumar said the Tehsildar's report raised triable questions. The challan was in, he said, so the defences could be raised at trial.

Two kinds of allegation, treated apart

Justice Batra began by splitting each FIR in two. One strand was cheating, a private grievance over the disputed plot. The other was selling land as plots without approval, a matter of statutory regulation.

The two FIRs, she observed, were cross-FIRs arising from one chain of transactions. Each side said the other's deed covered land it claimed for itself.

Cheating needs a deceived complainant

On Section 420, the judge said the law is no longer res integra. She relied on Mohd. Ibrahim v. State of Bihar: when a person sells property that is not his, the purchaser he misled may complain of cheating, but a third party claiming title may not.

She also relied on Jit Vinayak Arolkar v. State of Goa, where the Supreme Court quashed an FIR lodged under Section 420 during civil title suits. There it was impossible to see how the sale deeds deceived or harmed the complainant.

Applying this to FIR 26, Justice Batra noted that Rajesh Kumar was not a party to the 6 June 2023 deed. Om Parkash made no representation to him and received nothing from him. The only transferee was his son, who paid no consideration and had no grievance.

Whether the 25/676 share still existed on the ground, or was absorbed into the colony's passages, and which deed prevails, were questions of title and possession. Rajesh Kumar had himself raised them in his civil suit.

The Tehsildar's report showed only that the boundaries overlapped, not any dishonest intention. The State's stand that the transfer was made during the civil suit was not borne out, because the deed pre-dated both suits by months.

The 0.06 Marla that was only rounding

The same logic applied to FIR 31. None of Rajinder Kaur's five vendees had complained, and Rajesh Kumar supported her. The court also checked the arithmetic of the alleged excess.

The 23 June 2021 deed conveyed a 444/40000 share of 20 Kanals, which is 4.44 Marlas, and a 1/12 share of 3 Marlas, which is 0.25 Marla. The total is 4.69 Marlas, described as about 0-4¾ Marlas.

Add the five sales of 1.68, 13.50, 12.13, 12 and 4.69 Marlas and they total exactly 44. The 0.06 Marla excess arose only because the mutation rounded the last plot to 4.75 Marlas.

Civil dispute in criminal clothing

The FIRs came within nine days of each other, on parallel complaints while the civil suits were pending, the court noted. Neither side alleged that the petitioner deceived the complainant or induced delivery of property.

Justice Batra relied on G. Sagar Suri v. State of U.P. and held that the case fell in the first category of State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal. She said:

“criminal proceedings are not a short cut to other remedies available in law” (para 16)

Continuing the Section 420 proceedings against either petitioner would be an abuse of process. The court also held, following Anand Kumar Mohatta, that presenting the challan does not take away its power to quash.

The colony-law charge stays

The allegation under the Punjab Act stood on a different footing, the court held. It is not a private grievance but relates to developing land into a colony and selling plots without approval.

The Act defines a colony as land of not less than 1,000 square metres divided into plots, and a promoter includes an owner or the holder of a power of attorney from the owner. The land in these khasras, 20 Kanals 3 Marlas, is far larger, and even Rajinder Kaur's 44 Marlas exceeds the limit.

Each petitioner blames the other for carving out the colony, which is a disputed question of fact for evidence. The court cited State of Punjab v. Inder Mohan Chopra, where the Supreme Court set aside orders quashing an FIR under Section 36 and left such questions to trial.

Two things left for the trial court

The court left open which provision applies. Section 36(3) covers only cases where no other penalty is expressly provided, while a contravention of Section 5 is punishable under Section 36(1), with a minimum three years' imprisonment.

It also flagged Section 38(1), which bars prosecution under the Act without previous sanction of the competent authority. Sanction does not bar an FIR or its investigation, but a Section 173 report cannot be acted upon without it. The State's reply in Om Parkash's case was silent on whether sanction was obtained, and the court made no finding.

Order

Both petitions were partly allowed. FIR No. 26 dated 7 March 2024 and FIR No. 31 dated 16 March 2024, both of Police Station Division No. 2, Pathankot, were quashed so far as they relate to Section 420 IPC. In FIR 26, the Section 173 report and later proceedings were quashed to the same extent.

The trial court is to proceed in accordance with law, and Om Parkash may raise all pleas, including sanction, the applicable provision and limitation. The stay of 2 July 2024 on investigation in FIR 31 was vacated.

The court made clear that nothing in the order expresses a view on the civil suits or on the Punjab Act allegations. An application to stay the trial court proceedings, CRM-31192-2026, was disposed of as infructuous.