No membership for 22 garages, Bombay HC says, but an 896 sq ft flat is held for the claimant
Justice Sandeep V. Marne called Minoo Gowani membership case very weak but not hopeless, and ordered the developer of Saidale Co-operative Housing Society to keep one residential flat and two car parking spaces vacant until her suit is decided, while refusing any protection for the garages or the podium.
A woman who says a Mumbai housing society allotted her a shop and 22 garages in 1990 will get neither in the building now being planned. On 5 November 2026 the Bombay High Court held that a garage cannot ground society membership. It still ordered a flat of 896 sq ft held for her until her suit is decided.
Justice Sandeep V. Marne partly allowed Interim Application No. 5460 of 2026 by Minoo Tejraj Gowani in Commercial Suit No. 105 of 2026. He described her prima facie case as very weak, but found just enough material to justify a stopgap.
A building four decades in the making
Saidale Co-operative Housing Society, earlier called Pratibha Co-operative Housing Society, was formed to put up a residential building off Bhulabai Desai Road. Those who joined apparently contributed to the land and construction. The building went up only as a skeleton of 36 floors before the Municipal Corporation halted work over planning violations.
A long run of litigation followed. In a ruling of 19 and 20 March 2003, this Court told the society to provide suitable flats to its members in proportion to their contributions. The structure was finally demolished in 2019, and the society invited claims by a public notice of 20 July 2022.
On 6 October 2025 the society signed a Development Agreement with a developer. The same day, the High Court refused an interim injunction to another member, Mrs Devyani Gulabsi, who had challenged the redevelopment process. Her appeal is pending before a Division Bench.
The agreement makes no provision for Ms Gowani. She sued, and the two defendants lost their applications to reject the plaint for non-compliance with Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, by an order of 13 October 2026.
The documents behind her claim
Ms Gowani says her father, as her guardian, applied for membership when she was a minor. She relies on two registered Deeds of Confirmation of 4 February 1999 and on agreements-cum-applications for membership dated 28 March 1990. These bear signatures of the society Chairman and Secretary.
The shop on the lower-level podium was priced at Rs 3,00,000, of which Rs 90,000 is shown as paid. The entire podium with 22 garages was priced at Rs 3,30,000, with Rs 99,000 paid. She also holds 23 share certificates.
She leans on a Co-operative Appellate Court order of 26 May 1994, in which her father was joined to an appeal. That court recorded that no one objected to her father joining, and that on the documents produced the intervener appeared duly admitted as a member with the shop and podium.
What the three senior advocates said
Mr Pradeep Sancheti, Senior Advocate, appeared for Ms Gowani. He argued that the society never disputed her membership, even after notices in 2004 and 2022. He said she deserved parity with eight flat purchasers whose flats were never built, and that the agreement itself recognises her entitlement to the 22 garages.
He claimed a shop of 944.28 sq ft in the new building, being the old area plus the 22 percent additional area the agreement gives members. He relied on ALJ Residency Co-operative Housing Society v. Gehlot Development Services and on the Division Bench in Ambit Urbanspace v. Poddar Apartment CHSL.
Mr Ravi Kadam, Senior Advocate, appeared for the society, which has 35 members. He said her name is missing from the statutory Registers I and J, and that the resolutions she cites were passed when the society had no duly constituted managing committee. An administrator, by a resolution of 21 August 1993, had annulled meetings held from December 1988.
He added that she was 14 in 1990, and Section 22 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 bars a minor from membership. No proof of the balance payments existed, he said, and bye-law 80A vests shops and garages in the society. Of 80 car parking spaces in the old plans, 73 were already allotted.
Mr Zal Andhyarujina, Senior Advocate, appeared for the developer. He said her claim rests on a 1983 plan held forged in an earlier special case, and that the new plans have no commercial shops. Both defendants offered, without prejudice, to keep one 896 sq ft flat and two parking spaces vacant.
Membership is a question for trial
Justice Marne held that whether she was ever admitted as a member is a disputed question of fact that needs evidence. At this stage the Court could record only prima facie findings. He listed the points on each side, as the judgment sets them out.
For her were the share certificates, the signed membership applications, the 1994 appellate order and the 2003 ruling on members’ rights. The society also stayed silent when she wrote in 2004 and again on 26 July 2022. The Development Agreement also shows some recognition of 22 car parking spaces in which she claims an interest.
Against her, the Court noted, were Registers I and J, which do not carry her name. Without an entry there, the judge wrote, the share certificates become meaningless. She also produced no resolution admitting her, and the plaint did not say her name was ever entered.
The society had no valid managing committee at the time, and she was a minor. There was nothing to show she paid the balance Rs 2,10,000 for the shop or Rs 2,31,000 for the garages, or contributed anything over four decades. The society had also told the Divisional Joint Registrar that its records did not support her father’s claim.
Why a weak case still earned protection
The Court framed its limited task this way:
“The only issue that this Court needs to consider at this stage is whether any interim arrangement needs to be made at this juncture so that Plaintiff’s claim is not frustrated altogether.” (para 31)
Her case, the judge said, “is not very strong, and is in fact very weak” (para 31). Yet it could not be said there was no material at all. She had made out at least a suspicion of being a member, and deserved a chance to prove it.
He did not treat delay as a bar. She learned that the agreement left her out only after 6 October 2025, then wrote to the society and sued. The defendants did not deny they were about to submit plans to the Municipal Corporation.
Without protection, the judge reasoned, the society would hand flats to undisputed members and the developer would sell the rest on the open market. If she later won, nothing might be left to give her. Some premises had to be set aside so her claim would not become infructuous.
Garages are amenities, not flats
The Court refused any reservation for the 22 garages. The judge held that no membership can be granted in a cooperative housing society for a stand-alone garage. He found it hard to see why anyone would buy 22 garages to run one shop.
In his words:
“A garage or a car parking space does not have any independent existence.” (para 36)
Garages and parking spaces, he said, are free of floor space index and form part of a common amenity. A society or developer cannot sell them exclusively, even to a member, so as to create independent membership. The judge said he was not going deeper at this interim stage, and that his view on the garages was prima facie.
Under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, he held, membership attaches only to a flat sanctioned in the development permission. A garage or parking space falls outside the definition of a flat in both Section 2(a-1) of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963 and Section 154B-1(13) of the 1960 Act.
How the judge read the precedents
Mr Sancheti had cited Ambit Urbanspace for a garage holder’s right to monetise parking in redevelopment. The judge read it narrowly. It arose where garages were put to commercial use and the developer offered car parking spaces to persuade occupants to leave, and it lays down no general rule.
He also dealt with ALJ Residency, his own earlier ruling. That judgment recognised membership only for godown or storage space shown in the development permission, and rejected it for the basement area meant for parking.
The Court added that Uday Dalal and Punam Prashant Dighe reiterate that membership cannot rest on premises outside the sanctioned definition of a flat. It quoted Amanul Ekramul Ansari on parking areas, and read the Supreme Court’s Nahalchand Laloochand v. Panchali Co-operative Housing Society as pointing the same way.
No shop, and a limit on the podium
On the shop, the plan she relies on shows 735 sq ft of carpet area. Adding the 22 percent extra area given to members gave 896 sq ft. The defendants had agreed to reserve that much, as a residential flat, plus two parking spaces that are neither garages nor covered spaces.
The judge said this protected her claim to the shop to a large extent. He was not impressed by her complaint that the society had unilaterally chosen a purely residential building. There was no guarantee she would succeed on the shop, he added, and the Court could not direct the society to alter its plans and build one.
He did not accept that she could claim the whole lower-level podium either. The passages around the garages and the shop are a common amenity, he held, and she can claim no exclusive right in them. Nothing was to be reserved for that space.
The other prayers fail
She had also asked for an injunction against acting on the Development Agreement and the supplementary deed. She sought a bar on third-party rights in development potential tied to 8,296.37 sq ft, and disclosure of redevelopment records.
She asked for the Rs 10 crore deposited by the developer to be paid into court, and for the originals to be lodged with the Court.
Mr Sancheti had essentially pressed the plan-sanction relief, though he did not give up the others. The judge refused the rest. Members had waited for their homes for 40 years, he noted, and her claim, prima facie not very strong, did not justify halting redevelopment or a mandatory injunction to include garages in the plans.
Order
Pending the final decision of the suit, Defendant No. 2, the developer, must reserve one residential flat of 896 sq ft and two car parking spaces, not garages or enclosed spaces, in the proposed building. The developer decides the location and may not create third-party rights in them.
Immediately after the Municipal Corporation approves the plans, the developer must tell Ms Gowani the location and specifications and file an affidavit in the High Court.
If the suit is still undecided when the occupancy certificate is obtained, the developer is to hand over the flat and spaces to the society, which must keep them reserved until the suit is decided.
The remaining prayers are rejected. The interim application is partly allowed and disposed of, and costs of the application will be costs in the suit.