Justice M.S. Karnik Justice S.D. Patil Bombay HC PETITION ALLOWED Thirty-two years of service, no trainingcertificate, a pension at last
[ Bombay High Court ]

Teacher denied pension for lacking a B.Ed. wins it 21 years after retiring, Bombay HC rules

A Division Bench of Justice M.S. Karnik and Justice Sandesh Dadasaheb Patil quashed the refusal of pension to a commerce teacher with 32 years and 6 months of service in aided colleges, relying on earlier rulings for untrained teachers, and ordered pension and gratuity computed from 19 July 1973.

Mohammed Ali Ishak Patel taught for 32 years and six months and retired on 31 January 2005. The authorities then refused him pension because he never held a B.Ed. or D.Ed. On 5 November 2026 the Bombay High Court quashed that refusal and ordered his pension and gratuity computed from his first day of work in 1973.

Justice Sandesh Dadasaheb Patil wrote the judgment for a Division Bench with Justice M.S. Karnik. The writ petition, No. 915 of 2008, was filed that year, and the Court issued Rule on 17 July 2008.

A career across four aided institutions

Mr Patel graduated in commerce in July 1973 and began as an assistant teacher at Moinul-Uloom High School in Aurangabad. He worked there from 19 July 1973 to 31 March 1974 and again from 2 July 1974 to 4 July 1977, then took a Master of Commerce degree.

From July 1977 to June 1978 he taught at Burhani College of Arts and Commerce in Mazgaon, an aided junior college. He then spent two years at Anjuman-I-Islam’s Akbar Peerbhoy College, also aided, before joining Dr. Ambedkar College of Commerce and Economics, Wadala, on 1 July 1980 as a permanent junior lecturer.

He was moved to the senior scale on 3 July 1999, with effect from 1 July 1992, under a Government circular of 16 October 1992. He retired on 31 January 2005 as an assistant teacher in commerce.

Two letters of refusal

Mr Patel submitted his pension papers to the Education Inspector on 22 August 2006. By a letter of 27 October 2006 the Inspector told the college that the application could not be granted.

He took the matter to the Pension Adalat. There he pointed to a colleague, Mr Munnalal Premraj Pandit, who was also untrained and had been granted pension on retirement. The Division Commissioner of the Pension Adalat wrote to the Inspector seeking an explanation for the uneven treatment.

On 7 December 2007 the Pension Adalat wrote to him that he was not entitled to pensionary benefits under Rule 6 of the Pension Scheme in a Government circular of 4 November 1968. The petition challenged both letters.

What each side said

Ms Rishika Agarwal appeared for Mr Patel. She said he held a Master of Commerce but no D.Ed. or B.Ed., and that this could not be the only ground to refuse pension. The State had paid his salary throughout, and a similarly placed colleague had received pension.

Mr Vikrant Parashurami, Assistant Government Pleader, appeared for the State respondents. He said Mr Patel had not completed a post-training course such as the B.Ed. or an equivalent the Department recognises, so he was not treated as a trained teacher.

After the Government Resolution of 4 November 1968, he said, teachers with more than two years of post-training service are treated as holding a permanent post substantively for the pension scheme. Mr Patel, being untrained, was ineligible.

The precedents the Bench followed

The Bench first turned to K.V. Krishnan v. State of Maharashtra, a Division Bench ruling of 2000. There the teacher had served about 18 years at Ramnivas Ruia College as a confirmed full-time teacher on a sanctioned post, and the Deputy Director of Education had approved his services from time to time.

That Bench held that it did not lie in the mouth of the authorities, after his retirement, to say he had been untrained throughout. It directed pension and gratuity to be released within three months.

Next it cited Asaram Yesuji Ghogare v. State of Maharashtra, a Division Bench ruling of 2022 at the Aurangabad Bench. That judgment had relied on Smt. Umabai Deshmukh v. State of Maharashtra and Smt. Gokula Vilas Patil v. Education Officer (Primary), Sangli.

The State’s own communication

In Asaram Yesuji Ghogare the petitioner produced a communication of 9 February 2022 from the State School Education and Sports Department. It recorded that untrained teachers employed before 1 July 1992 were to be treated as deemed trained.

It also recorded a decision that similar employees appointed after 1 July 1972 as untrained teachers, who retired after long service, should be treated as a special case and given pensionary benefits. The communication was restricted to those who had gone to court.

That Bench had said the litigation could have been avoided, and had directed the State to circulate its order and the Gokula Vilas Patil judgment to all Zilla Parishads so that similar cases could be located and remedied.

No hesitation to hold

The Bench rejected the Assistant Government Pleader’s argument in short order. It said it was not impressed, and that the argument was

“in teeth of the Judgment” (para 8)

in Asaram Yesuji Ghogare. Weighing the four rulings together, the Bench held that Mr Patel, with 32 years and six months of service, was

“entitled to pensionary benefits and that the Petition deserves to be allowed” (para 9)

The judgment does not examine Rule 6 of the 1968 pension scheme in its own text or take up the colleague’s case separately. It rests on the earlier Division Bench rulings.

Order

The writ petition is allowed in terms of prayers (a) and (b). The letters of 27 October 2006 and 7 December 2007 are quashed and set aside.

The authorities are directed to sanction Mr Patel’s pension application and to compute his pension and gratuity with the starting date of his continuous employment as 19 July 1973. Rule is made absolute, the petition is disposed of, and there is no order as to costs. The order sets no deadline.