Justice N.J. Jamadar Bombay HC REVISION DISMISSED Possession decree for Mahim roomstands
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bombay HC upholds Mahim possession decree: tenant paid no rent for four years, then tendered it

Justice N. J. Jamadar refused to interfere in revision with a Section 6 decree, saying receipts issued by the landlord, four years of silence by the defendants and admissions of the plaintiff side supported the finding of possession.

A Mumbai tenant who stopped paying rent in July 2012 tried to hand over four and a half years of arrears in December 2016, after a woman said he had broken into the room. The Bombay High Court on 18 November refused to disturb the decree that gave her possession.

Justice N. J. Jamadar dismissed the civil revision of Mohammed Salim Hajisattar Dayatar and Farzana Salim Dayatar, and rejected an oral request to stay the decree.

A door broken open in March 2016

The room is Room 12B in Khimani Mansion, on MMC Road in Mahim West, and the landlord Rahim Khimani owns the building. Mrs Lilian Fernandes was the tenant until an agreement of 29 July 2008 moved the tenancy to Mr Dayatar.

Bela Avinash Mehta sued in the City Civil Court under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. She said Mr Dayatar surrendered the tenancy to the landlord by a declaration of 2 July 2012, after which she became the tenant at Rs 80 a month.

On 21 March 2016, she said, Mr Dayatar and two associates broke the door open and put the defendants’ belongings inside. FIR 110/2016 was registered at Mahim police station.

The defendants called the declaration forged and said they were always in possession. They had filed R.A.E. Suit 410/2016 in the Small Causes Court seeking declaratory and injunctive reliefs.

The City Civil Court decreed the suit on 23 December 2025. It directed the defendants to put her in possession and ordered an inquiry into mesne profits.

What each side argued in revision

Mr Vasim Siddiqui, for the applicants, said the trial judge misread the evidence and ignored admissions in the cross-examination of the plaintiff and of Sushma Mehta, a witness for her. He said those admissions showed the plaintiff was never in possession.

He argued that the judge strayed into lawful tenancy, a question the civil court cannot decide in a Section 6 suit, and acted on surmise. He added that the surrender declaration, Exhibit 28, was insufficiently stamped, forged and inadmissible.

Mr Pradeep Sancheti, Senior Advocate for the respondent, said revisional jurisdiction does not allow re-appreciation of evidence. He stressed two points: the plaintiff held the original rent receipts the defendants gave up at surrender, and the defendants had no receipts for July 2012 to March 2016.

Section 6 asks two questions

Justice Jamadar said a Section 6 suit is a swift remedy against dispossession without due process. Title does not matter. The court asks only whether the plaintiff was in possession and was unlawfully dispossessed within six months before the suit.

He noted that possession is, in his words, “considered to be nine points in law”, and that even a landlord may not forcibly evict a tenant. The judge cited Chockalingam v Manickavasagam (AIR 1974 SC 104) for that.

He also cited Ejaz v Handloom Weavers’ Cooperative Society ((2002) 3 SCC 137) on the law’s abhorrence of dispossession without due process.

On what possession means, he cited a three-judge decision in Anil Kumar Bhunja ((1979) 4 SCC 274). The test is whether the person is in general control of the thing.

The landlord’s receipts decided possession

The court began with undisputed facts. Mr Khimani is the landlord, Mrs Fernandes was the tenant, Mr Dayatar came in on 29 July 2008, and the landlord issued the rent receipts. The dispute was whether the plaintiff took possession in July 2012 and was dispossessed on 21 March 2016.

The plaintiff relied on rent receipts the landlord issued for July 2012 to March 2016, and on the landlord’s own evidence. Mr Khimani said Mr Dayatar handed over possession in July 2012.

He also refused a cheque dated 14 December 2016 that Mr Dayatar tendered for arrears from 1 July 2012 to 31 December 2016. He returned it with a note that the defendants were not the tenants.

For the period the plaintiff said she held the room, the landlord had issued receipts in her name. The defendants, indisputably in occupation from 2008 to 2012, had none after July 2012 because they had not paid rent.

Four years without a letter

The judge then looked at conduct. If the landlord would not take rent, some step from the defendants was to be expected, he said.

“Complete inaction till the month of December, 2016 cannot be said to be immaterial” (para 20)

In cross-examination Mr Dayatar offered what the judge called a lame excuse: that he might have forgotten to write to the landlord. A state of affairs had run from 2008 to 2012, the judge noted, and when it ended the defendants did nothing.

Admissions that helped the plaintiff

The plaintiff admitted she lived in a flat in another building and that her family and Devendra Mehta used the room. The judge held this did not detract from her claim. She did not have to use the room as a household to be in possession.

Mr Siddiqui argued that Devendra Mehta, not the plaintiff, took the room. The judge said that strengthened her case: Sushma Mehta conceded that Devendra acquired it, which fitted the plaint. A suggestion put to her that she was given an extra key also implied that the plaintiff side had possession.

The judge also saw no plausible reason for the plaintiff to hold the original receipts for the period the defendants were in occupation.

Forgery plea left to the Small Causes Court

The judge said a Section 6 court is not expected to give a definitive finding on whether the declaration is genuine. The Small Causes Court, where the defendants seek a declaration about the tenancy, can decide that.

In this suit the declaration mattered only because the landlord-defendant relationship that lasted until 2012 did not continue afterwards, and the plaintiff appeared to be in possession. On possession, he held, the trial court made no error.

On dispossession, the plaintiff reported the matter to the police at once. Minor discrepancies in Sushma Mehta’s account of breaking the lock did not matter. Nothing material came out in the cross-examination of her son Shreyansh, who said he saw it.

Order

The judge held that the findings of fact were justified and not perverse, and that there was no jurisdictional error or material irregularity. No interference was warranted in revisional jurisdiction.

The application is dismissed. The applicants then sought a stay of the execution and operation of the decree, and the court rejected that prayer. The judgment was reserved on 30 September 2026 and pronounced on 18 November 2026.