Justice S. Mohan Madras HC ACCUSED ACQUITTED Child witnesses improved ontheir police versions
[ Madras High Court ]

Madras HC acquits teacher in POCSO case: child witnesses turned a touch into a pinch in court

Justice Sunder Mohan held that three child witnesses and the mother improved their story in court and had been tutored, and set aside the Cuddalore Special Court conviction.

Three child witnesses told the police that a teacher touched a pupil. In the witness box, all three said he pinched her. On 17 November the Madras High Court set aside the teacher’s seven-year POCSO sentence, holding that the change was a material improvement and that the witnesses had been tutored.

Justice Sunder Mohan allowed Criminal Appeal 1273 of 2022 and acquitted the appellant, Ashok Kumar. The appeal was heard with the help of an amicus curiae appointed by the court.

What the trial court decided

The Special Court for POCSO cases at Cuddalore had tried the teacher in Spl.S.C.No.18 of 2022. The charge was aggravated sexual assault under Section 9(m) read with Section 10 of the POCSO Act, with two linked charges under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.

The prosecution examined 15 witnesses and marked 18 documents. On 6 October 2022 the Special Court acquitted him under the SC/ST Act but convicted him under POCSO. It sentenced him to seven years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 2,000.

The prosecution case

The accused was a teacher at a village panchayat school, and the complainant was a young pupil. The prosecution said that one afternoon in November 2021 he sent most students out of the class and kept the girl and two classmates back.

It alleged that he touched her inappropriately under her clothing. She told her mother within about half an hour, the family confronted him at the school, and the mother lodged a complaint at 8.30 pm.

Defence and amicus

The defence said the three child witnesses were tutored and spoke in a parrot-like manner. It alleged that a local politician with a grudge against the appellant and his wife, the headmistress, had instigated the complaint.

It also pointed to delay in lodging the complaint, a suppressed earlier complaint and a medical opinion that did not support the story. The amicus, Mr Shruthan Balaji, relied on State of MP v Balveer Singh ((2025) 8 SCC 545) to argue that tutored child evidence must be discarded.

The Additional Public Prosecutor, Ms Sharada Vivek, said minor contradictions could not sink a consistent victim backed by two eye-witnesses, and that the statutory presumption under POCSO had not been rebutted. Mr P G Thiyagu, for the complainant, argued that the absence of medical corroboration did not matter.

Touch became pinch

The court began with the paperwork. The complaint, the statement before the Magistrate under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the statement to the doctor and the police statements of the girl, her mother and the two classmates all said the same thing: the accused touched her private part.

The medical opinion recorded no physical or genital injuries. It added that sexual violence could not be ruled out.

In court, the girl said the accused pinched her private part. The two classmates repeated that version. So did her mother, who had said only that he touched her in her complaint, while her father and grandmother said the girl told them he had pinched her.

The investigating officer confirmed in cross-examination that none of them had said so during the investigation. The doctor said a pinch would show on examination and he had found nothing.

The court called this a material change, not a small slip:

“Touch and pinching are two different acts” (para 13)

Tutoring, motive and the missing signature

The court held that the two classmates had been tutored to suit the prosecution. They also told the court that the girl’s parents had questioned the accused and then lodged a complaint, which they had never said to the police.

The father said both parents signed the complaint, which his brother wrote. The signature of the father is not on the complaint, a gap the court said made the defence claim of an earlier, suppressed complaint probable.

Witnesses also said a politician went with them when the complaint was lodged and came to court during the examination. The court recorded the defence case that the accused and his wife were harassed because they did not yield to the politician’s demands.

The Supreme Court test

The court set out the Balveer Singh guidelines on child witnesses. Where a witness adds details, the improvement must first be put to the witness, then proved through the investigating officer, before it can be discarded.

Where a child’s whole account is said to be tutored, two factors must be shown: an opportunity to tutor, and a reasonable likelihood that tutoring happened. Bald assertion is not enough.

The court found both met on these facts. All the witnesses had given one version earlier and a different, enlarged one in the deposition, and the improvement was not explained. It said:

“Tutoring can be inferred from that fact alone” (para 18)

It added that the cross-examination and the defence suggestions made the tutoring case probable. The court also found the delay in sending the complaint to the Magistrate, and the explanation for it, unsatisfactory.

Order

The Criminal Appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentence in Spl.S.C.No.18 of 2022 dated 6 October 2022 are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of the charge.

Any fine paid is to be refunded and the bail bond discharged. The court recorded its appreciation of the amicus curiae, Mr Shruthan Balaji. Mr N U Pressanna appeared for the appellant.