Adopted in Amritsar, NOC held in Delhi: HC rejects objection to Australia relocation plea
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held that the refusal of CARA, sitting in New Delhi, is the integral cause of action, and that the passport office in Amritsar cannot take the case away. Merits will be argued on 2 December.
A girl adopted in Amritsar in 2021 has waited, her adoptive parents say, nearly five years to join them in Australia. They need a No Objection Certificate from the Central Adoption Resource Authority, and the authority says it cannot issue one.
The Union of India and the passport authorities argued that the Delhi High Court should not hear the case at all, because everything happened in Punjab. On 19 November, Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma rejected that objection and kept the petition in Delhi.
The ruling decides only where the case can be heard. The merits are listed for 2 December 2026.
Adopted in Amritsar, stalled in Delhi
The petitioners, Harpreet Kaur and her husband, are persons of Indian origin who are now citizens of Australia and hold Overseas Citizen of India cards. The child was born in Amritsar on 23 December 2019.
The adoption ceremony took place under Sikh rites on 18 October 2021. A deed of adoption under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 was registered at the Sub-Registrar’s office in Amritsar on 18 November 2021.
The child’s Aadhaar was updated and a fresh birth certificate issued naming the adoptive parents. A civil court in Amritsar declared her their adopted daughter by decree of 2 January 2024.
On 25 January 2022, the couple applied online for her passport. They say the Amritsar Passport Seva Kendra would not proceed without an NOC from CARA.
CARA wrote from New Delhi on 10 August 2022. It told the adoptive father to follow Regulation 22C of the Adoption (Amendment) Regulations, 2021, which needs the case to be sponsored by the competent authority of the receiving country.
The petitioners say the Australian authorities declined to start that process and advised an immigration route, which itself needs the CARA NOC. On 13 March 2026 they asked CARA to put the case before its Relaxation Committee. They say they have had no reply.
The objection from the Centre
The petition asks for a writ to CARA to issue the NOC and for a direction to the passport authorities to issue the passport. CARA contested it on merits, saying it is legally barred from issuing the NOC without the receiving country’s approvals.
The Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Regional Passport Officer at Amritsar objected to jurisdiction. They said the adoption deed, the birth records and the passport application were all at Amritsar, and that impleading Delhi-based ministries does not confer jurisdiction.
They relied on ONGC v. Utpal Kumar Basu, Kusum Ingots, Alchemist and two Delhi decisions, Chintan Agrawal and Dr Neha Chandra, to argue that only a material part of the cause of action counts and that another High Court may be a more appropriate forum.
What the petitioners said
For the petitioners, Sheenam Chhabra said the main relief is a writ to CARA, a statutory body at R.K. Puram in New Delhi. The refusal of the NOC is the integral cause of action, and the passport relief depends on it.
She applied a but-for test: had CARA issued the NOC, there would have been no reason to withhold the passport or come to court. The deed and birth records at Amritsar, she said, are background.
She cited the Full Bench in Sterling Agro Industries, a Division Bench ruling in Charnjit Singh Aulakh, and the Supreme Court’s 2026 ruling in Baksish Ahmad. She argued that forum conveniens cannot be used where the authority sits within the court’s jurisdiction.
She added that CARA, the principal respondent, took no objection, that the Centre’s objection was belated, and that other benches had heard similar petitions against CARA.
Two clauses of Article 226
“Whether this Court has the territorial jurisdiction to entertain the present petition, and if so, whether it ought to decline to exercise the same by invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens” (para 16)
Justice Sharma set out Article 226. A High Court can issue writs where the authority is located within its territory under clause (1), or where the cause of action arises there wholly or in part under clause (2).
Clause (2), she said, was meant to widen the reach of High Courts and does not shrink the first. Jurisdiction is decided on the facts pleaded, taken as true, and those facts must form a material, essential or integral part of the cause of action, not an incidental one.
She cited Alchemist and the Supreme Court’s 2023 test in State of Goa v. Summit Online Trade Solutions. The pleaded facts must have a nexus with the subject matter and prayer, and unrelated facts do not count.
Existence of jurisdiction and its exercise are separate, she added, citing Kusum Ingots. Even if part of the cause arises in the territory, a court may decline under forum conveniens.
Why Delhi was the right court
The judge held that the grievance is the non-issuance of the NOC by CARA. CARA is a statutory body in New Delhi, empowered under Chapter VIII of the Adoption Regulations, 2022 to issue the NOC for relocation of a child adopted under the Hindu law.
Its letter of 10 August 2022 was sent from New Delhi. The representation of 13 March 2026 was addressed to it there and remains undecided. And CARA’s stand that it is barred from issuing the NOC is taken and maintained in Delhi.
“A material and integral part of the cause of action” (para 26)
She held that this part of the cause of action arose in Delhi, so clause (2) of Article 226 applied. The facts about CARA have a direct nexus with the prayer, which asks CARA itself to issue the NOC.
Amritsar events and the passport office
The deed, birth records and civil decree at Amritsar, the judge held, are not under challenge. They are background, and no relief is sought against the authorities that made them.
The relief against the Amritsar passport office is consequential. The Regional Passport Office told the court that no passport application for the child is pending and that a fresh one would be processed in accordance with law. The passport question therefore depends on the NOC.
She distinguished Chintan Agrawal, where a passport date-of-birth correction was refused by an office in Ghaziabad and the only Delhi link was the Ministry of External Affairs. No Delhi authority had a role in that decision. Dr Neha Chandra was distinguished in the same way.
Forum conveniens and the child
On forum conveniens, the judge declined to send the case elsewhere. CARA’s records are in New Delhi, and CARA has appeared and argued the case on merits.
She noted that Delhi benches have heard similar petitions against CARA where the adoption deeds were executed in Punjab or Rajasthan. These included Jasleeniqbal Sidhu in May 2025 and Karnika Khandelwal in July 2026. Her own bench decided Rupinder Kaur Sandhu on 4 August 2026.
The petition had been pending since April 2026 with pleadings complete, and the child’s relocation had been unresolved for nearly five years. Sending the family to another forum would not serve the best interests of the child, she held.
Order
The High Court rejected the preliminary objection raised by the Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Regional Passport Officer, Amritsar. It clarified that nothing in the ruling expresses a view on the merits.
In the same judgment it allowed the petitioners’ application to correct the prayer clause, which named the wrong respondents by number. The petition is listed for arguments on merits on 2 December 2026 before the Roster Bench, subject to the Acting Chief Justice’s orders.