Bombay HC quashes abetment case: father blamed four men for a missing daughter already dead
Justice Milind Jadhav said later investigation displaced the kidnapping premise, six months separated the complaint from the suicide, and the custody of the suicide note raised serious doubt. The case against the fifth accused continues.
A Mumbai man died by suicide in October 2019 and left five chits blaming others for the loss of his minor daughter. Investigators later found that she had died by suicide on 30 March 2019, before he complained of her disappearance. The Bombay High Court has now quashed the abetment case against four men named in his note.
Justice Milind N. Jadhav ruled on 18 November that no proximate and live link tied the applicants to the death. He left the case against the remaining accused untouched.
Five chits and a complaint from the widow
On 25 April 2019 the father lodged a complaint at Nehru Nagar Police Station under Section 363 of the Indian Penal Code, saying his minor daughter had been enticed away. It named one of the applicants.
On 13 October 2019 he died by suicide at Tilak Nagar railway station. Five chits recovered from his pocket, the prosecution says, blamed his decision on the persons who enticed his daughter and kept her from contacting him.
His wife complained at Wadala Railway Police Station on 14 October 2019 that the applicants had abetted the suicide. The case was registered as CR No 226 of 2019 and investigated by the Crime Branch, DCB CID Unit VI.
The chargesheet named the four applicants and a fifth accused, who was not before the court. His name and his gang, along with the name of a Senior Inspector of Police, appear in the chits, the judgment records.
The charges were under Sections 306 and 34 of the IPC. The case is Sessions Case No 149 of 2024 before the Additional Sessions Judge, Mumbai.
The kidnapping case that collapsed
The kidnapping case did not last. After the chargesheet, the investigating officer filed a C-summary report. It showed that the daughter had died by suicide on 30 March 2019 and had not eloped with anyone.
On 23 June 2025 the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, 37th Court, Esplanade, Mumbai, took note of that report in CC No 875/PW/2019. The father had died, and his widow appeared before the Magistrate and said she had no objection to closing the case.
The Magistrate found no sufficient evidence to frame a charge. He discharged all the accused of offences under Sections 363 and 368 read with Section 34 of the IPC and cancelled their bail bonds.
What the applicants said
Mr R V Gupta, advocate for the applicants, said they were falsely implicated and had no link to the girl's disappearance or the later death. One applicant had worked for another for four years, living in his workshop, and left for his native place on 31 March 2019.
When the police visited that workshop on 2 April 2019 with the father and relatives, the employer gave the man's address and telephone number. He arranged a video call in front of the officers and attended the police station the next day. The man himself attended on 7 April 2019 on the police's directions.
Mr Gupta said the kidnapping complaint named one applicant alone and attributed no role to the others. He argued that the five chits were suspect.
The widow had said she was shown them at Wadala Railway Police Station, but the note was already circulating in the Nehru Nagar area at about 9:40 pm on 13 October 2019. The inquest panchanama of 14 October at Sion Hospital did not record the chits, and the note carried no bloodstains.
He added that the father's mobile phone was produced only on 13 November 2019, with a dead display, though the father was said to have spoken to his son at about 8:22 pm. Nobody had investigated who made the note go viral on social media. The applicants also said they were implicated because of business rivalry and political pressure.
The State and the widow's lawyer
Ms Shilpa Talhar, the Additional Public Prosecutor, said the investigation was complete and the chargesheet filed. She argued that the chits, together with witness statements, disclosed a prima facie case that had to be tested at trial.
She said the Magistrate's order concerned different offences and could not absolve the applicants of abetment. The discrepancies over the note, the phone and the Senior Inspector were matters of evidence, not for quashing.
Ms Payoshi Roy, the advocate appointed for the widow, adopted that position. She added that the widow had lost her husband and daughter in quick succession, and that each applicant's precise role could be proved only at trial.
The premise of the prosecution shifts
Justice Jadhav began with the foundation of the case. The prosecution rested on the alleged kidnapping in March 2019 and the mental agony it caused the father. Later investigation, he said, showed that the girl was not abducted and that the father had been under a mistaken impression.
He held that this fundamentally altered the premise on which the father was said to have suffered agony. The court treated the Magistrate's order of 23 June 2025 as a relevant development that could not be ignored, though it concerned distinct offences and could not by itself decide liability under Section 306.
Six months, no fresh act of instigation
The court next took the gap in time. The girl went missing on 30 March 2019 and the father died on 13 October 2019, more than six months later.
In that period, the judge noted, the applicants cooperated with the police. The first complaint targeted only one applicant, and the record showed no overt act by any of them that could count as instigation or intentional aid.
He held that an earlier kidnapping complaint, without further material showing intentional instigation or aid, cannot by itself amount to abetment of suicide.
Doubts over the chits and the phone
On the five chits, the court listed the three points the applicants had raised: the note's circulation before the widow said she saw it, the inquest panchanama's failure to record their recovery, and their handling by a police constable when all the deceased's articles went to his son.
The judge said these might not individually justify discarding the note at this stage. Taken together, he said, they created serious doubt over how the chits were recovered, preserved and circulated.
The mobile phone was unexplained too, he found. It was produced almost a month after the incident in a damaged state, and the agency had not said why it was not recovered earlier.
The suicide note also carries allegations against the then Senior Police Inspector, which the investigation did not meaningfully examine. Together with the discrepancies over the chits, the judge said, these circumstances:
“cast a shadow on the manner in which the investigation has proceeded” (para 13)
What Section 306 demands
Justice Jadhav said Section 306 needs abetment within the meaning of Section 107 of the IPC: instigation, intentional aid or conspiracy to bring about the suicide. That a person died by suicide and named others in a note is not enough in every case.
Even taking the note into account, he said the prosecution would have to:
“establish a proximate and live link between the alleged acts of Applicants and suicide” (para 14)
He found no material of any fresh act of instigation or aid after the long gap. A mere mention of the applicants in the note, set against the later findings of the agency, would not satisfy Section 306 read with Section 34.
Quashing against some accused only
The judge relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Lovely Salhotra v State of NCT of Delhi. He recorded it as settling that nothing in Section 482 of the CrPC or Section 528 of the BNSS prevents quashing against some accused only.
He said there was no impediment to quashing as against these four applicants, and that continuing the trial would not serve a meaningful purpose. Taken together, the later investigation, the Magistrate's order, the time gap, the lack of any specific act and the doubts over the note did not show a prima facie case.
Order
The criminal application is allowed. The investigation and proceedings in Sessions Case No 149 of 2024 are quashed against the four applicants. The case arose from CR No 226 of 2019, also registered as CR No 355 of 2019 at Nehru Nagar Police Station.
All consequential proceedings against the four are quashed too.
The court clarified that its observations are confined to these four applicants and do not affect the proceedings against the remaining accused.
It appreciated Ms Roy's assistance and directed that her fees be paid by the High Court Legal Aid Services Authority on production of a server copy of the order. It applied the court's decision in Sanjyot Nitin Telharkar v State of Maharashtra and the Schedule under Regulation 18(1) of the Maharashtra State Legal Services Authority Rules, 1998.