Rs 2.79 lakh of scrap sales is not fraud: Bombay HC clears four Morya Grain ex-directors
Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan refused to declare four former directors of a wound-up distillery personally liable under Section 542 of the Companies Act, 1956, finding next to no business activity behind an annual report that did carry an untruthful statement.
A wound-up distillery filed an annual report, an income tax return and held five board meetings after the court ordered its liquidation. The Official Liquidator said that was fraud and asked for four former directors to be made personally liable. On 4 November 2026 the Bombay High Court found the business too small to carry that charge.
Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan disposed of Official Liquidator Report No. 26 of 2022 without any directions. He held that revenue below Rs 3 lakh and tax deducted of about Rs 2,100 showed next to no activity, and no loss to the company or any creditor.
A report against four former directors
Morya Grain Distilleries Private Limited was wound up in Company Petition No. 322 of 2015. The report invoked Section 542 of the Companies Act, 1956, which lets the Company Court declare people who knowingly carried on the business with intent to defraud creditors personally responsible, without limit, for the company's debts.
The cause title names Praj Industries Limited as respondent. The report itself is aimed at the company's four erstwhile directors: Jatin Bhupendra Shah, Tulsidas Khimji Patel, Narendra Ramjiyani and Narendra Patel.
Union Bank of India took symbolic possession of the premises under the SARFAESI Act on 5 March 2016 and lodged a claim of about Rs 51.13 crore on 27 July 2018. It sold the Paithan property by e-auction on 20 January 2022.
A statement of affairs filed in 2022
The Liquidator asked the directors for a Statement of Affairs on 13 March 2018, 25 November 2019 and 2 February 2022. It came on 8 March 2022. Claims were invited on 31 May 2019, and Union Bank's was the only one received.
On 2 January 2025, the court recorded that the directors had been served but had not appeared, and that a prima facie case under Section 542 had been made out. The Liquidator filed an affidavit of evidence on 23 January 2025. The directors then filed a reply.
What the Liquidator relied on
Mr Ranjeev Carvalho, for the Official Liquidator, pointed to the annual report for the year ended 31 March 2019, filed on 16 September 2019, and the income tax return filed on 15 October 2019. Five board meetings were held between 19 June 2018 and 26 March 2019, and the profit and loss account showed revenue from operations.
The directors knew of the winding-up order, he said, since the company was the appellant in Appeal (L) Nos. 170 and 172 of 2018. The annual report recorded a loss of Rs 1,41,23,405 for the year and a total loss of Rs 50,70,12,698, so an intent to defraud could be inferred.
He also called the report contradictory. The directors said no significant order had affected the company, while the auditors said it carried on no business and meant to seek striking off. Fixed assets of about Rs 51.93 crore were missing from the Statement of Affairs, he added.
The directors approached the Liquidator only after Union Bank sold the Paithan property, and their advocate wrote on 31 January and 16 February 2022. The Liquidator argued that the aim was to keep creditors from being paid.
Scrap, not business, said the directors
Mr Rohaan Cama, for the directors, said a Section 542 charge is a charge of fraud and must be pleaded with particulars. The report did not say who was defrauded, how, or by what dishonest act, and it attributed no separate role to any of the four.
The revenue, he said, came from selling scrap. The return was filed in a bona fide belief, to avoid penalty under the tax law while the appeal against winding up was pending.
No debt was created after the winding-up order, he added. Union Bank was the only creditor to prove a claim, and no other creditor came forward after the public notice.
Two ingredients, and thin numbers
The judge read Section 542(1) as needing two things: business actually carried on, and an intent to defraud behind it. The Liquidator asked for the declaration on the strength of the revenue in the financial statements and tax return, the board meetings and the statement that no order had affected the company.
The annual report showed revenue from operations of Rs 2,79,048, which the court called a minuscule level of activity. The income tax return showed tax deducted at source of about Rs 2,100.
The court reasoned that a company doing real business would have seen tax deducted at source on some scale. The directors' account of scrap sales therefore appeared believable and reasonable.
On the standard of proof, the court said proceedings of this kind are decided on a preponderance of probabilities. But the serious nature of the allegation, it said, calls for closer scrutiny and cogent material showing a higher degree of probability of fraudulent conduct.
"I am not satisfied that a case has been made out" (para 13)
No loss to any creditor
The court said Section 542 postulates some nexus between the activity carried out and the fraudulent intent, so that liability can be fastened on directors for the impact of the fraud. With revenue under Rs 3 lakh and tax deducted of Rs 2,100, it could not discern any loss inflicted on the company, a creditor or anyone else.
The annual report did contain an inaccurate statement. It said no order affecting the company had been passed, though the company was in appeal and knew of the winding-up order. The court said that statement could be held untruthful.
But the same report showed serious financial distress, and the statement was not made to aid any business run with intent to defraud. The court added that its order was not a clean chit on the misstatement.
Counsel had referred to a decision of a Single Judge at the Nagpur Bench in Official Liquidator of John Galt Laboratories Ltd. v. R.B. Sangare. The court recorded its holding that fraudulent business must be pleaded and proved, and that allegations must identify the role of each person proceeded against.
Order
The Official Liquidator Report is finally disposed of without any directions. The court said submissions were made primarily on Section 542, and actions under the order are to be taken on receipt of a downloaded copy from the court website.