Three family members lose bid for road-facing SRA shops: Bombay HC says rehab spot is no choice
Justice N.J. Jamadar held that a slum dweller has a right to a tenement of a prescribed size, not to a location, and that a deal with a replaced developer cannot override uniform allotment norms.
In 2016, the first developer of a slum rehabilitation scheme in Malad promised three shop owners units facing Khotkuwa Road. The developer was later removed and the owners were declared eligible only in 2019. By the time the matter reached the High Court, the scheme counted 42 eligible commercial occupants against 18 front-facing shops, the society said.
On 18 November, the Bombay High Court refused to enforce the promise. Justice N.J. Jamadar dismissed three connected writ petitions and held that the road-facing shops had to be shared out under the scheme’s uniform norms.
A scheme that grew from four to 42
The petitioners are Pravinkumar, Rajkumar and Arvind Mehta, who occupied separate commercial structures in Dagdu Chawl facing Khotkuwa Road in Malad. The land is being redeveloped under the Jai Hanuman slum rehabilitation scheme.
The original developer was Shah Housecon. Its appointment was terminated, and Sigma Happy Homes LLP took over.
The petitioners were declared eligible in 2019. They said that on 17 June 2016 the earlier developer, with the consent of the slum dwellers’ society, had agreed to give each of them a road-facing commercial unit.
The new developer, they said, honoured that promise. A plan approved on 4 May 2023 gave them shops 3, 2 and 5 on the road.
The Slum Rehabilitation Authority’s revised plan of 26 November 2024 changed this.
Arvind and Pravinkumar were moved to shops 27 and 28 at the rear of the rehab building, and Rajkumar was given shop 3 instead of shop 2.
Eviction, a dismissed petition and the appeals
The petitioners did not vacate their old structures, and eviction proceedings were started under Sections 33 and 38 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas Act, 1971. An eviction order passed on 1 January 2025 was upheld by the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee on 6 May 2025.
Pravinkumar’s writ petition against that was dismissed on 19 January 2026, but he was given liberty to challenge the allocation of his permanent accommodation. The three then appealed against the revised plan.
The Committee dismissed their appeals on 10 August 2026. It noted that when the first letter of intent was issued on 21 April 2015, only four slum dwellers were eligible for commercial premises.
By the date of its order, 42 commercial occupants had been declared eligible, and the eligibility of 18 more was pending. It also said the 2016 agreements were of no help because the petitioners had no right of rehabilitation when they were signed.
Arguments for and against the shops
Aseem Naphade, for Arvind, argued that the Committee’s order was bereft of reasons, as it merely recorded submissions and the pleadings. The revised plan, he said, was arbitrary and meant to turn rehab units into free-sale assets for the developer.
He did not claim an unfettered right to choose a location. His point was that a solemn promise by the earlier developer with the society’s consent, followed by the 2023 plan, could be enforced.
Amogh Singh, for Pravinkumar, added that reasons must be in the order itself and cannot be supplemented later by an affidavit. He cited the Constitution Bench ruling in Mohinder Singh Gill.
The Slum Rehabilitation Authority said slum dwellers have no vested right to particular units and that the front shops could not all go to one family. Mayur Khandeparkar, for the new developer, said the 2016 agreements were signed before the petitioners were eligible and were a private arrangement.
Vikram Garewal, for the society, said there are only 18 front structures against about 42 eligible occupants. He added that 39 other members would be affected and had not been impleaded.
What a slum dweller is entitled to
The judge framed the issue as whether the petitioners could claim road-facing units because of the earlier developer’s agreements and the 2023 plan. He began with the nature of the entitlement.
A slum dweller generally has no title to the land, he said. Rehabilitation gives units on ownership to make the right to livelihood meaningful, in situ as far as practicable, but not in a chosen building, floor or place.
The Slum Act speaks of tenements allotted “in-situ or otherwise” and gives the benefit to an eligible slum dweller. Regulation 33(10) of the Development Control and Promotion Regulations, 2034 has statutory footing and binds the authority, the developer and the slum dwellers alike.
“The right to rehabilitation thus does not precede the declaration of eligibility” (para 26)
Under the regulation, the only preference is for differently abled persons and female-headed households. All other eligible occupants are on the same footing and get units by lots.
An eligible commercial occupant is entitled to up to 20.90 square metres of carpet area free of cost. The regulation expressly allows back-to-back shopping on the ground floor, so a road-facing unit is not guaranteed.
Private deals do not beat uniform norms
The judge relied on two Division Bench rulings, Sirfaraz Sheikh and Mohanish Mohan Chikhalkar, which refused preferential allotment based on a developer’s promises or individual hardship. He also relied on the Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling in Sayunkta Sangarsh Samiti.
That ruling held that private agreements cannot be enforced against the Authority’s statutory mandate. The petitioners’ case failed on facts too, he said, since the agreements were signed in 2016 and they were declared eligible only in 2019.
Private arrangements, whether by contract or otherwise, cannot command preference over allotment by lottery or another uniform method under the Authority’s circulars.
Was the revised plan arbitrary?
The judge accepted that a revision may be challenged if it was made to benefit one person unjustly or without reason. Here the number of eligible commercial occupants had risen from four to 42, and Regulation 33(10) contemplates accommodating those declared eligible later.
There were only so many road-facing shops. The petitioners belong to one family and could not claim three of them.
Shops 2 and 5, first earmarked for the petitioners, went to two other eligible occupants, declared eligible in 2024 and 2025. They had not been taken over by the developer as free-sale units, and the petitioners got rear shops in the rehab building. The change was not discriminatory.
He distinguished Dhanraj Tejmal Lukad, where a similarly placed claimant was given an irregular rear shop 3.33 feet wide while others got road-side units. Nothing of that sort was shown here.
Reasons in the Committee’s order
The judge said the Committee’s reasoning was not refined, structured or sequential. But he could not accept that the order had no reasons.
The Committee had noted the rise from four to 42 eligible occupants, 18 eligibility claims pending, and that rehabilitation rights accrue only on eligibility. It dealt with both main planks of the petitioners’ case.
Order
The three writ petitions were dismissed, the rule was discharged and no costs were awarded. The revised plan of 26 November 2024 stands.