Chief Justice M.C. Tripathi Justice A.M. Sethna Bombay HC MATTER REMANDED A medical board must say if hecan do the job
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bombay HC orders a fresh medical test for a UPSC-selected geophysicist with both legs affected

Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait M. Sethna set aside a cryptic Tribunal order and sent a candidate with 55 per cent locomotor disability back to the Central Standing Medical Board to say whether he can do the work of a Geophysicist, Group A.

He cleared the preliminary, the main examination and the interview, and the Union Public Service Commission recommended him as a Geophysicist, Group A. Then a medical board declared him fit and the Ministry of Mines turned him down. On 3 November 2026 the Bombay High Court sent him back to a medical board with one question to answer.

Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi, with Justice Advait M. Sethna, partly allowed Writ Petition No. 2665 of 2025 by Teklal Kumar Das. The Bench set aside the Central Administrative Tribunal order of 1 October 2024 and remanded the case to the Central Standing Medical Board.

Selected by the UPSC, rejected by the Ministry

Mr Das holds an M.Sc. in Applied Geophysics, completed on 20 August 2022, and belongs to the Scheduled Caste category. His latest certificate, dated 9 April 2024, puts his disability at 55 per cent.

Examination Notice No. 02/2022-GEOL of 22 September 2021 reserved three Geophysicist posts for candidates with locomotor disability or cerebral palsy. He took the Combined Geo-Scientist Examination, 2022, passed the preliminary on 20 February 2022 and the main on 25 and 26 June 2022, and sat the personality test on 17 January 2023.

The UPSC declared the final result on 31 January 2023 and recommended him. His dossier went to the Ministry of Mines on 21 March 2023.

Fit, but classified as both legs affected

The Central Standing Medical Board, Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi examined him on 29 April 2023. It certified him fit under the physical handicap category, with a noting of both legs, 55 per cent.

The Ministry published medical results on 5 July 2023 and listed him at serial number 158 as pending. On 30 August 2023 it told him his candidature would not be considered, because he did not meet the functional requirement for the post.

The CGSE rules list two functional classifications for a Geophysicist: hard of hearing, and one arm or one leg affected. The Ministry said his classification, both legs affected, was outside both.

Three rounds before the Tribunal

Mr Das first filed Writ Petition No. 12744 of 2023. A coordinate Bench disposed of it on 4 December 2023 and sent him to the Tribunal. His Original Application No. 15 of 2024 ended on 19 January 2024 with a direction to the Ministry to decide his representation within two months.

The Ministry rejected the representation by a speaking order of 3 April 2024, again citing the functional classification. His Original Application No. 1094 of 2024 was dismissed on 1 October 2024.

The Tribunal said the post required one leg or one arm affected, or hard of hearing, and that Mr Das did not meet it. It found no force in his argument that the Medical Board had declared him fit and capable of all kinds of work.

A coordinate Bench issued notice in this petition on 27 February 2025. On 24 September 2025 it directed the Ministry not to fill the post for which he was selected until the next hearing.

What the petitioner argued

Mr Anjani Kumar Singh, for Mr Das, said the Tribunal never discussed that his client had passed the physical requirement at the medical examination, and had been declared fit by the Board. Having cleared three stages, he argued, he could not be rejected after the Board found him medically fit.

He described the post as having three main duties: field data acquisition and subsurface mapping, data processing, and modelling and map preparation. He said about 70 per cent of the work is desk work. He also said his client did geological field work in Uttar Pradesh in 2018 and 2019 as a B.Sc. student at Banaras Hindu University.

He relied on the principle of reasonable accommodation and on three Supreme Court rulings, Sujata Bora v. Coal India Ltd., Omkar Ramchandra Gond v. Union of India and Om Rathod v. Director General of Health Services.

The respondents' answer

Dr Vinod Joshi appeared for the UPSC and Mr Pranil Sonawane for the other respondents. They said the notice allowed only candidates with hard hearing, one leg or one arm affected, while Mr Das is classified as both legs affected.

They also said the Board report showed fitness under the physically handicapped category under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, but did not show that he met the functional requirements of the post.

A report that needed clarifying

The Chief Justice, writing the judgment, said the Bench is bound to follow expert opinion such as that of the Medical Board. But the Board had declared Mr Das fit while classifying him as both legs affected, which the court said required clarification against the functional requirements of the post.

The Board's findings, it said, are expert opinion that a court cannot substitute with its own.

The Tribunal order was cryptic, in the Bench's view. It recorded no finding on that apparent contradiction, nor on the key question whether Mr Das is fit for the Geophysicist post given its functional needs, although he had cleared three stages and been recommended.

The judges noted that in their brief interaction with Mr Das, his gait and walk, they too found him otherwise fit. That was not enough, they said.

"There has to be a proper medical/scientific report" (para 44)

Reasonable accommodation, applied to the post

The Bench noted the Supreme Court's repeated holding that reasonable accommodation, which flows from Article 41 read with Articles 14 and 21, is to be interpreted broadly. It quoted Omkar Ramchandra Gond on Section 2(y) of the RPwD Act, which it said is not confined to assistive devices.

It also noted that the Supreme Court in Anmol v. Union of India treated reasonable accommodation as rooted in Part III. The Tribunal should have considered these decisions, it said, along with their application to the facts.

The Bench therefore found it necessary to ascertain whether Mr Das can actually perform the job of a Geophysicist, given the Board's classification of 55 per cent disability in both legs. A thorough and overall medical evaluation of his fitness for the post would be of prime importance.

A colleague's case did not help

Mr Das had also relied on another candidate, Ms Heena Parveen, who had joined service in a similar situation. The Ministry's speaking order of 3 April 2024 said a departmental inquiry was pending against her. The court held that no equity could be claimed on that account.

Order

The petition is partly allowed. The Tribunal order of 1 October 2024 is set aside and the matter goes to the Chairperson of the Central Standing Medical Board, Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi. A reconstituted Board is to re-examine Mr Das de novo and assess him functionally, to see whether he can discharge the duties of a Geophysicist.

Mr Das is to present himself within one week of communicating a certified copy of the order to the Board. The Board must issue a detailed report, saying clearly whether he satisfies the functional requirements, within four weeks of the physical examination.

If the findings favour him, the UPSC, the Ministry of Mines and the Geological Survey of India must consider them favourably and act on them in accordance with law, expeditiously. If they go against him, he may challenge the decision in accordance with law.

The interim order of 24 September 2025 reserving one post continues until the Board's report or decision and for three weeks after. The Bench said its observations are confined to the facts of the case, and the writ petition stands disposed of.