Rs 1.74 crore shop deed has no existence in law: Bombay HC keeps a Worli firm a nominal member
Justice Sandeep V. Marne set aside Deputy Registrar orders that had given a company full membership of a Worli housing society for 10 shops, holding that the 2019 amendment ending nominal membership does not upgrade anyone and that members cannot go to the Registrar without first applying to the society.
A company paid Rs 1.74 crore under a registered deed to take over a Worli shop from its previous occupant, then used the deed to ask the State for full membership of the housing society.
On 4 November 2026 the Bombay High Court held that the deed transferred nothing. The previous occupant had already handed the shop back to the society.
Justice Sandeep V. Marne allowed ten connected writ petitions by Vaitarna Bheema Worli Sagar Co-operative Housing Society Limited. He set aside the Deputy Registrar’s orders of 30 June 2026 and the Divisional Joint Registrar’s order of 9 October 2026, which had directed the society to issue share certificates for 10 shops.
Ten petitions, ten shops, one company
Respondent No. 4 is a private limited company, called Prowess Financial Services Pvt. Ltd. in the Shop 16 agreement. Its director, Mr Satish Chaturvedi, lives in a flat in the society’s building and has served as its Chairman.
The company occupies shops numbered 7 to 16. In each case it took over a shop that an earlier allottee had surrendered, and the society admitted it as a nominal member.
In May 2026 it went straight to the Deputy Registrar under Section 22(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960, asking for ordinary membership for all ten shops. The Deputy Registrar treated the appeals as filed under Section 23(2) and allowed them.
The society’s revision applications were dismissed on 9 October 2026, after an interim stay on 11 August. All ten petitions went to the High Court. Counsel treated the petition on Shop 16 as the lead case.
Land for homes, 15 per cent for shops
The original Worli Sagar society was formed to get government land under a Government Resolution of 12 May 1983. A Resolution of 11 February 1987 allotted a plot at Pochkanawala Road on a 99-year lease, on condition that only members eligible under the 1983 policy be admitted.
The 1983 policy was meant for income groups, with the top group reserved for government and public sector employees and legislators. On 22 June 1987, the State let the society use up to 15 per cent of the built-up area for shops. About 53 shops were built.
The State asked for the names of sub-lessees and the purpose of each letting. It set no eligibility test for them. The court read that as the reason the society admitted shop occupants only as nominal members.
How Shop 16 changed hands
Shop 16 was first allotted to Ms Neeta Rupani, who surrendered it in 2007. The society then allotted it to Mr Vasudev Hemrajani, who surrendered his nominal membership and occupancy rights by a deed of 17 January 2017.
The society allotted the shop to Respondent No. 4 in 2017 and moved the share certificate into its name as a nominal member. The agreement barred it from selling, transferring or letting anyone else into the shop without written consent.
It also let the society cancel the arrangement and recover possession after a two-week notice of breach. The allotment letter, in Marathi, said a nominal member had no rights of membership and no share in profits or assets.
A deed signed seven years later
On 22 August 2024, Respondent No. 4 and Mr Hemrajani signed a Deed of Confirmation/Transfer, registered with the Sub-Registrar. It showed Rs 1,74,00,000 paid to Mr Hemrajani. The society, the court noted, was not told.
On the strength of that deed, the company began claiming title to the shops. The Deputy Registrar relied heavily on it, and on a clause in the 2017 agreement mentioning ownership or occupancy rights, to find the company was entitled to ordinary membership.
What the society said
Mr Pradeep Thorat said the company never applied to the society for membership, so Sections 22 and 23 never came into play and the Deputy Registrar had no jurisdiction. He said the company was a mere licensee who could only be a nominal member under Bye-law 20.
Dr Abhinav Chandrachud added that the 1983 Resolution barred admitting commercial occupants as members. He argued that the 2019 amendment was substantive and prospective, so existing nominal members stay as they are. He relied on Section 11 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, for restrictions on enjoyment.
Mr Mayur Khandeparkar said there is no concept of automatic elevation of a nominal member and that the Deputy Registrar cannot change a class of membership. He distinguished this Court’s ruling in Viviana CHSL v. State of Maharashtra.
Mr Khandeparkar added that the shop had been surrendered in 2017, yet the company signed with the previous occupant in 2024 to convert its nominal membership into ordinary membership. He said the allotments carried specific conditions not to sell any rights and to surrender the shops to the society.
He pointed to Section 24, Section 27(8) and Rule 8(1)(f) of the Rules to show how little a nominal member holds, and to Rule 19, under which nominal membership can be granted by an authorised officer without a general body meeting.
What the company said
Mr Drupad Patil, for the company, said shop allottees are allotted shops like flat allottees, with no rent beyond maintenance, and the society cannot draw an artificial distinction. The company had paid the previous allottee and about Rs 25 lakh per shop to the society.
He said a society agency had paid Rs 3 crore for the right to find members for the shops. The society, he said, treated the company as a member until it decided on redevelopment, with tenders due by 25 October 2026. He said Viviana applied and the Supreme Court had dismissed the special leave petition against it.
Nominal membership under the statute
The judge began with the framework. Under Section 24 of the Act a nominal member has no share in profits or assets and, under Section 27(8), no vote and no seat on a committee. Bye-law 3(xxiv) says a nominal member holds no right, title or interest in the property.
Bye-law 20 allows a sublettee, licensee, caretaker or occupant to be admitted, and the form for it requires an applicant to declare that status. The judge held that a flat or unit owner can never be a nominal member, and a nominal member can never claim ownership.
Cancellable at will, unlike a regular member
The judge said a nominal member can lose the shop in ways a regular member cannot. If one encroaches outside the shop or changes its use, the society can cancel the membership. For a regular member, the society must follow the other steps the Act lays down.
The allotment letter also said a nominal member who wants to leave must surrender the shop to the society. The court held that a shop allottee cannot enter a transfer with a third party. Only the society can make a fresh allotment, and that is what happened in 2017.
The 2019 amendment cuts one way
Chapter XIII-B, inserted from 9 March 2019, removed nominal membership for housing societies and capped membership at the number of flats. The court agreed with Dr Chandrachud that the change is substantive and operates prospectively, citing two Supreme Court rulings.
Nominal members admitted earlier therefore stay nominal members. Section 154B-31 saves existing bye-laws and orders. The court found nothing in the amendment suggesting that a nominal member is converted into an ordinary one.
On the idea that the amendment lifts nominal members into ordinary membership, the judge was blunt:
"under no circumstances can it be countenanced" (para 45)
Section 154B-7 allows transfer of occupancy rights only by an owner. The explanation to it says occupancy right does not include the right of a tenant or licensee on leave and licence.
A deed with nothing to confirm
The judge held that Mr Hemrajani had surrendered everything in 2017, so no privity of contract linked him to the company. The privity ran from him to the society and from the society to the company. There was nothing for the 2024 deed to confirm.
The deed falsely branded Mr Hemrajani as transferor and the company as transferee, the judge said. He called the Deputy Registrar’s findings perverse, and held that registration does not turn an occupier into an owner. The deed, he wrote:
"not even worth the paper on which it is written" (para 50)
He observed that the company took a volte-face in 2024, after being content for years with nominal membership. It had taken the shops with its eyes open to the conditions, through a director who was a member and a former Chairman.
No application, no jurisdiction
Sections 22 and 23 start with an application to the society. A refusal or a three-month silence gives the Registrar jurisdiction, by Section 23(2) appeal or deemed membership under Section 22(2). The court called the making of an application sine qua non and a jurisdictional fact.
Without it, the Deputy Registrar, a creature of statute with no inherent jurisdiction, could not act. The court held the Deputy Registrar’s orders without jurisdiction and non-est, and that Respondent No. 4 could not go to the Registrar directly.
Why Viviana CHSL did not help
In Viviana, the shop owners had bought their shops by registered agreements and the society had treated them worse than flat owners. The court there upheld regular membership on its unusual facts.
The Viviana society had signed a development agreement in 1984, and Consent Terms later let the developer build 16 shops whose buyers were to be nominal members. Twelve of the buyers went to the Deputy Registrar, who ordered their names entered as regular members.
That ruling held that the 2019 amendment had wiped out the very idea of nominal membership in housing societies. Here the shops were not bought at all. The society still owns them, and the company holds only a licence to occupy.
Justice Marne said a judgment is authority for what it decides. Viviana did not say a person can skip the society and go straight to the Deputy Registrar, or that nominal members became regular members in 2019. The occupancy right it discussed is not the licence the explanation to Section 154B-7 excludes.
The money argument
The Rs 3 crore, the court said, was a fee to an estate agency for finding allottees to 53 shops. A 1991 letter from that agency itself asked for nominal membership for the Shop 16 allottees.
The Rs 25 lakh paid to the society bought no ownership, since the occupant still pays additional lease rent to the State. The Rs 1.74 crore never reached the society, and the court found it incomprehensible why the company paid it.
On Section 11 of the Transfer of Property Act, the judge agreed with the Calcutta High Court in Subal Chandra Malty that the section applies only where an absolute interest is created. Here the agreement imposed restrictions on use, so no title passed.
Order
The Divisional Joint Registrar’s order of 9 October 2026 and the Deputy Registrar’s order of 30 June 2026 are set aside. Rule is made absolute in each petition and there is no order as to costs. Respondent No. 4 stays a nominal member until the occupancy rights end, and the membership then ends.
After the judgment was pronounced, counsel for the company asked for a six-week stay. The court refused, noting that the company is already a nominal member and the orders would have raised its status.