Justice P.S. Sen Calcutta HC PETITION DISMISSED Appeal route not skipped lightly
[ Calcutta High Court ]

Calcutta HC rejects writ on Rs 6.2 crore stamp revaluation, allows 30 working days to appeal

Justice Partha Sarathi Sen held that a buyer who appeared at the hearing and paid the extra duty had no case for skipping the Section 47B appeal, but gave 30 working days to file it.

A property was registered on a market value of Rs 2,40,00,003. The West Bengal registration authority later raised it to Rs 6,23,75,007, and the buyer paid the extra stamp duty and registration charges. On 16 November the Calcutta High Court dismissed his writ petition against that order as not maintainable.

Justice Partha Sarathi Sen held that Bidyut Naha had a statutory appeal and had not explained why he skipped it. He also gave Mr Naha 30 working days to file that appeal, to be treated as within limitation.

From Rs 2.4 crore to Rs 6.2 crore

The petition challenged a memo of 18 September 2025 from the Collector and Deputy Inspector General of Registration, West Bengal. Acting under Section 47A(5) and (8) of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, he had re-determined the property’s value at Rs 6,23,75,007.

The memo directed Mr Naha to pay deficit stamp duty of Rs 26,86,250 and registration charges of Rs 3,83,750 within a specified time. Together that came to Rs 30.7 lakh.

At registration the authority had valued the property at Rs 2,40,00,003, and Mr Naha paid duty on that value. The registered document was then delivered to him.

No reasons, no Form VIII, said the buyer

Ms Indralina Sen, with Mr Indra Nath Mukherjee, appeared for the petitioner. She said a notice of 11 September 2025 under Section 47A(5) had called Mr Naha to appear on 18 September at 3 pm. He did, and on that day the authority raised the value without giving any reason.

She argued that Rule 5(1) of the West Bengal Stamp (Prevention of Undervaluation of Instrument) Rules, 2001 required a notice in Form VIII. She also said the authority had not complied with Rule 5(3)(d). The revaluation, she submitted, was invalid for want of formalities and reasons.

Mr Naha had paid the revised amount, she said, but under duress. The notice warned that late payment would carry penal interest, so the writ petition remained maintainable.

The State’s answer: pay, then appeal

Mr Nilanjan Pal, with Ms Indrani Chakraborty, Additional Government Pleader, appeared for the State. He said the notice was issued in accordance with law. The authority had re-assessed the value on the basis of the proposed use of the land as a pond (‘pukur’) and as commercial, given the potential of the adjacent area.

Mr Naha, he said, had accepted that valuation by paying the deficit. He also pointed to Section 47B, which gives an appeal against an order under Section 47A(5) or (8), and said the petitioner had offered no cogent reason for not using it.

The statutory scheme the court read

Justice Sen took maintainability first. He set out Sections 47A and 47B. Under Section 47A(8), the authority may on its own motion, within five years of registration, examine an instrument and, after hearing the parties, determine the market value afresh.

Under Section 47B, a person aggrieved by such an order may appeal to the prescribed appellate authority within 60 days of receiving it, or a longer period the authority allows for cause shown. The court framed the question this way:

“whether despite availability of alternative efficacious statutory remedy, the present writ petition is at all maintainable in the eye of law or not” (para 11)

Two exceptions, neither made out

The court turned to two Supreme Court decisions. In UP State Spinning Company Limited v RS Pandey ((2005) 8 SCC 264), the Supreme Court had said the High Court should not normally interfere where an efficacious alternative remedy exists.

It recognised two exceptions. One is where the proceeding is taken under a provision that is ultra vires, and the other is where the order was made in breach of natural justice.

The court also quoted Radha Krishan Industries v State of Himachal Pradesh ((2021) 6 SCC 771). It lists the exceptions as enforcement of a fundamental right, breach of natural justice, an order wholly without jurisdiction, or a challenge to the vires of a law.

The same decision says that where a statute creates a right and prescribes the remedy, that remedy must be used before invoking Article 226. It calls this a rule of policy, convenience and discretion.

Appeared, participated, did not appeal

Applying those principles, Justice Sen found that Mr Naha had failed to make out a case for entertaining the writ petition. The impugned notice recorded that he had appeared and taken part in the hearing after the notice of 11 September 2025, and his counsel did not dispute it.

No case had been made that the authority’s action was otherwise ultra vires, the court said. The State had placed enough material to show the authority acted within Section 47A(5) and (8).

Mr Naha had made no effort to explain why the alternative remedy was not used. The court recorded that it was:

“constrained to hold that the writ petition is not maintainable” (para 16)

The judgment does not decide whether Rule 5 of the 2001 Rules was followed, or whether the new value was right. Those questions were left to the appeal.

Order

WPA 13816 of 2026 is dismissed, with no order as to costs.

Observing that Mr Naha was perhaps pursuing his remedy in the wrong forum on wrong legal advice, the court gave him liberty to appeal to the appropriate appellate authority under Section 47B of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899.

If the appeal is filed within 30 working days of the date of the judgment, the appellate authority must treat it as filed within the period of limitation. An urgent certified copy is to be given to the parties on the usual undertaking.