Calcutta HC says forensic lab certificate on a CD-ROM only partly satisfies Section 65-B(4)
Justice Sandip Kumar De dismissed a civil revision against a Kandi court order that refused to take a CD-ROM on record, but left the petitioner free to produce the electronic evidence again in strict compliance with law.
A forensic laboratory certificate that came with a CD-ROM was not enough to put the disc before a trial court, the Calcutta High Court held on 17 November. Justice Sandip Kumar De found that the certificate met the requirements of Section 65-B(4) of the Evidence Act, 1872 only in part.
He also held that a line in the application, saying the video was recorded on a mobile phone, did not make up for what was missing.
The court dismissed a civil revision filed by Mst. Bilkish Fatema against an order of a civil court at Kandi in Murshidabad. She remains free to produce the electronic evidence again, provided she follows the law strictly.
A second application for the same CD-ROM
The challenge was to order number 118 of 20 July 2022, passed by the Civil Judge (Junior Division), 1st Court, Kandi, in Miscellaneous Case 6 of 2015. The revision was registered as C.O. 1109 of 2023, with an interim application, CAN/1/2026, filed in it this year.
By that order the trial judge refused an application to bring electronic evidence on record along with a certificate from a forensic laboratory. He noted that the petitioner had already been given a similar opportunity.
An earlier application to the same effect had been rejected on 18 January 2021, with liberty to take appropriate steps. On 24 November 2021 she filed another, this time to bring a CD-ROM on record with a forensic laboratory certificate.
The trial judge held that the matter was settled by the order of 18 January 2021. He saw no need to pass any further order and rejected the application.
Mr Mousomee Shome and Mr Subhajit Das appeared for the petitioner. Despite service, no one appeared for the opposite party, Husneara Begum, and an affidavit of service was kept on record.
What Section 65-B asks of electronic evidence
Justice De reproduced Section 65-B in full. Under sub-section (1), information in an electronic record that is printed on paper, or stored or copied in optical or magnetic media produced by a computer, is treated as a document. It is then admissible without further proof of the original, if the section’s conditions are met.
Sub-section (2) sets four conditions for the computer output. The computer must have been used regularly to store or process information for regular activities, under the lawful control of the person using it. Information of that kind must have been fed into it in the ordinary course.
The computer must also have been working properly through the material period, or any lapse must not have affected the record or its accuracy. And the output must reproduce, or derive from, the information fed into the computer in the ordinary course.
Sub-section (4) is the certificate. It must identify the electronic record and describe how it was produced, and give particulars of any device involved. It must also deal with the conditions in sub-section (2).
The certificate must purport to be signed by a person in a responsible official position in relation to the device or the activities concerned. It is enough for a matter to be stated to the best of that person’s knowledge and belief.
Why the certificate fell short
On a careful reading of the section, the court said, a certificate is required to bring electronic evidence on record. It then looked at what the petitioner had offered with the CD-ROM.
The court held that the forensic laboratory certificate:
“partially complied with the requirements of Section 65-B(4) of the 1872 Act” (para 8)
but, it added, the certificate was not the complete one. The order does not list which particulars under sub-section (4) were missing.
The application of 24 November 2021 also carried a statement, in its first paragraph, that the videography was done through a mobile phone. The court held that this statement did not fulfil the requirements of the certificate contemplated by Section 65-B(4) either.
Justice De therefore found no illegality or infirmity in the trial judge’s order. The judgment does not say what dispute Miscellaneous Case 6 of 2015 concerns, or what the video is meant to prove.
Order
The revisional application, C.O. 1109 of 2023, is dismissed. The interim application, CAN/1/2026, is disposed of.
The petitioner is at liberty to produce the electronic evidence before the trial court in strict compliance with the relevant laws. There is no order as to costs.
An urgent photostat certified copy of the judgment, if applied for, is to be supplied to the parties on compliance with the usual formalities. The judgment was heard and delivered on 17 November 2026.