Calcutta HC upholds pond-conversion notice on medicine shop: a larger pond now is no defence
A Division Bench held that even on the mouza map the 2012 construction covers part of the pond and embankment, and that failure to revise the records of rights does not excuse it.
A man accused of converting part of a pond into a medicine shop and doctor’s chamber argued that the pond is now much larger than the land records show. The Calcutta High Court was not persuaded. On 16 November it dismissed his petition and left a notice under the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955 standing.
Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya wrote the judgment for a Division Bench with Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi, who agreed. The Bench said the Tribunal had reached a plausible conclusion on a technical report and that no patent error justified interference.
A notice under Section 4C(5)
The petitioner, Dibakar Chakrabarty, challenged an order of a Tribunal. The Tribunal had upheld a notice issued by the appropriate authority under Section 4C(5) of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955.
The notice alleged that he had built a medicine shop and a doctor’s chamber by unlawfully converting a pond (pukur) and its embankment (pukur par).
The Tribunal had constituted a technical team to verify the position in the field. The team’s report was before the court.
The petitioner: the pond has swollen
Mr Arindam Chattopadhyay, for the petitioner, relied on that field verification report. It showed, he said, that the present area of both the pond and the embankment is much larger than the measurements in the land records.
The construction was made in 2012. If the pond and embankment were smaller then, he argued, there would be no case of conversion.
He added that the Tribunal should specifically have directed the extent of the pond to be measured and the records of rights corrected.
State: the shop sits on the pond
Mr Nilanjan Bhattacharjee, Senior Standing Counsel for the State, pointed to the mouza map annexed to the petition, which was also part of the technical team’s report. Even on that map, he said, the construction stands on the original location of the pond.
The photograph annexed to the report, he submitted, corroborated the same fact. On that footing, he argued, the Section 4C notice could not be called bad in law under any circumstances.
Counsel also appeared for three other respondents. The order does not record their submissions.
What the Bench saw on the map
The Bench looked at the mouza map on which the alleged encroachment had been superimposed in the report. Even on that map, it found, the construction was made by encroaching on a portion of the pond or embankment.
It treated the petitioner’s other point as a separate question. Whether the records of rights must be modified to show the current position, the Bench said, is distinct from the issue before it.
It added that the State would do well to consider revising the records to reflect the present size of the pond and embankment. But, it held, non-revision does not justify building over part of the pond or its embankment and thereby changing its character.
No patent error in the Tribunal’s order
The Bench then turned to the Tribunal’s own reasoning. The Tribunal had constituted a technical team and examined its report before reaching its conclusion.
That, the Bench held, left no basis for interference:
“no patent error in the order of the Tribunal” (para 9)
It described the Tribunal’s conclusion as a plausible one, reached after adverting to the team’s report.
Order
WPLRT 213 of 2026 is dismissed on contest, without any order as to costs.
The Bench made it clear that nothing in its judgment, or in the Tribunal’s, prevents the petitioner from taking recourse to appropriate provisions of law to seek permission to convert, if he is otherwise entitled to it in law.
Urgent photostat certified copies may be supplied to the parties on compliance with the requisite formalities. The matter was heard and decided on 16 November 2026.