Justice U. Kumar Calcutta HC ACCUSED ACQUITTED A box packed a month after theraid it was meant to prove
[ Calcutta High Court ]

Seizure box made a month after the raid: Calcutta HC acquits two men of ATM card-swap fraud

Justice Uday Kumar set aside concurrent convictions for cheating by personation, holding that a missing malkhana register, unsealed seizures, uncertified bank and invoice records, a spoiled identification parade and the acquittal of a co-accused on the same recoveries left nothing to support the verdict.

Police said they recovered 26 ATM cards from two men accused of swapping a woman’s debit card. Only nine reached the trial court, and the box that held the seized articles carried a packing date a month after the seizure.

On 12 November 2026 the Calcutta High Court acquitted both men. Justice Uday Kumar, in revision, held that the concurrent convictions for cheating by personation rested on recoveries, documents and identification that the law does not allow a court to rely on.

A card swapped at an SBI ATM

The prosecution case began on 1 October 2019. Karuna Bala Adhikary (PW-1) went to an Axis ATM at Bulbulchandi, could not withdraw cash, and was told by people in the booth to try a nearby SBI ATM. At the second machine, a person asked to use it first for an urgent transaction.

In that interval, the prosecution said, the accused swapped her SBI debit card, ending 1042, for a card in another person’s name. On 2 October she received alerts of unauthorised withdrawals and a gold purchase totalling Rs 65,300. She blocked the card.

She lodged a written complaint only on 16 October 2019, sixteen days after the incident. Cyber Crime P.S. Case No. 05 of 2019 was registered under Sections 419, 420 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code against Dilwar Hossain, Mehebub Alam and one Nabi Sk.

The investigating officer, ASI Jhumpa Mandal (PW-12), apprehended Mr Hossain on 16 October 2019 at a jewellery shop owned by PW-4. The complainant’s original card was said to have been recovered from his person. On 19 October the officer seized tax invoices and jewellery boxes from the shop.

Four years in prison, then revision

On 16 November 2021 the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Malda, convicted Mr Hossain and Mr Alam under Sections 419/120B and 420/120B of the IPC. Each was sentenced to up to four years in prison and fined Rs 20,000. Mr Nabi Sk. was acquitted.

The 5th Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Malda, dismissed Criminal Appeal No. 04 of 2021 on 15 March 2022. It affirmed the conviction, treating the defects in seizure and electronic records as mere defective investigation. The men then came to the High Court under Sections 397 and 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

The defence: a chain with no links

Mr Satadru Lahiri appeared for the petitioners. He called the delay in the complaint unexplained, and said no Malkhana register was produced and the investigating officer kept all seized articles in her own unsupervised custody. The independent seizure witnesses, PW-3 and PW-7, said the items had no proper seals.

He pointed to the drop from 26 recovered cards to nine produced in court. For the rule that unsealed seizures lose value he cited Mohd. Aman v. State of Rajasthan, State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram and State of Rajasthan v. Gurmail Singh, with more recent decisions in Mool Chandra and Ramkrushna Prahllad Dongardive.

The invoices (Ext. 4 and 4/1) were unverified photocopies and the bank passbook (Ext. 2) was a computer printout. Relying on Tharammel Peethambaran, Pooranmal, Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer and LIC v. Ram Pal Singh Bisen, he said they were inadmissible without Section 65 foundation and Section 65B certification.

On identification he cited Shaikh Umar Ahmed Shaikh, Habal Shaikh and Sujit Biswas. On parity, he said the magistrate discarded identical house-search recoveries to acquit Mr Nabi Sk. and then used them to convict his clients, contrary to Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi and a Division Bench ruling in Manjur Sk.

The State: caught with the card

Mr Subir Ganguly appeared for the State. He said the complainant’s own card, ending 1042, was taken from Mr Hossain’s person when he was caught at the jewellery shop, and PW-4, PW-7 and the investigating officer proved it. Mr Nabi Sk. was acquitted only because nothing tied him to this victim’s card.

He argued that minor lapses by an investigating officer do not erase truthful ocular testimony and direct recovery, citing State of Uttar Pradesh v. Naresh and Bhagwan Jagannath Markad. Missing Malkhana entries or seal defects, he said, are ministerial flaws that cause no prejudice, relying on Jagmohan Singh Kuldip Singh Anand and Narayan Chetanram Chaudhary.

He said the chain was backed by an original tax invoice (Ext. 5), merchant slips and branded packaging found at the accused’s homes, tying the money to gold bought under aliases.

PW-1 identified both men at parades on 1 November and 27 November 2019, and the shop salesman identified Mr Alam as the buyer who used the name Mosaraf Hossain.

Six questions the judge set himself

After the rival arguments Justice Kumar framed six questions. They covered the chain of custody, the documents, the identification parade, parity with the acquitted co-accused, the use of past criminal cases, and whether the findings were perverse enough for revision. The third asked:

“Whether the evidentiary value of the T.I.P. was completely vitiated and destroyed by pre-trial police station exposure and contradictory judicial testimony.” (para 20)

No register, no seals, a future-dated box

The investigating officer admitted on oath that no Malkhana register was maintained or produced and that the articles stayed in her personal custody. PW-3 and PW-7 said the cards and containers had no seals, gala impressions or witness signatures. The court called the register the essential link proving safe custody.

Then came the box. The prosecution produced an Amul Dairy Creamer box said to hold exhibits seized on 19 October 2019, but it bore a manufacturing and packaging date of 17 November 2019. The record had no explanation for the date.

PW-4 had deposed that the police recovered about 26 ATM cards from the accused’s body, yet only nine were exhibited. Seventeen were unaccounted for.

The judge accepted the defence cases on custody. The State’s decisions, he said, cover only minor lapses such as a delay in sending samples or a typing error, where the seal and the register stay intact. Here the register was missing, the container carried a future date and seventeen cards had gone.

The holding on the first question was short:

“alleged recoveries are completely vitiated, non est in the eye of law” (para 27)

He held that both courts below were perverse to dismiss these failures as defective investigation.

Photocopies and printouts with no certificate

The passbook was marked as an exhibit through oral testimony alone. PW-12 admitted she had no seizure list, requisition or other record showing how it was seized. PW-2 admitted that the invoice and merchant slip were photocopies and that the originals were never found or produced.

Under Sections 61 and 64 of the Evidence Act, the judge said, contents must be proved by primary evidence unless Section 65 is satisfied. The prosecution laid no foundation and did not account for the originals. He relied on Tharammel Peethambaran and Pooranmal.

The passbook ledger and transaction slips are electronic records, so Sections 65A and 65B apply. Following the Constitution Bench in Anvar P.V., he held that a Section 65B(4) certificate is a precondition to admissibility, and that marking an exhibit does not cure its absence. No such certificate was produced at any stage.

The Bankers’ Books Evidence Act, 1891 was also ignored, he said, since bank entries need originals or certified copies with the Section 2A certificate. He cited paragraphs 25 to 27 of Ram Pal Singh Bisen and held Exhibits 2, 4 and 4/1 inadmissible.

Shown at the police station before the parade

PW-1 admitted in cross-examination that the police officer showed her the accused at the police station before the parade. The judge held that once a suspect is exposed to the witness before a parade, later identification in the parade or in court reflects police-induced familiarity, not independent recollection.

The Magistrate who held the parade (CW-2) testified that PW-3 identified the petitioners. The parade record, Ext. 14, shows that PW-3 completely failed to identify them. PW-3 also said the police never questioned him during investigation.

Several witnesses spoke only of two or three unknown persons without saying who did what. With Mr Nabi Sk. acquitted and no specific attribution recorded in the dock, the judge held that a generic pointing at a group cannot fix guilt on either petitioner. He relied on Shaikh Umar Ahmed Shaikh, Habal Shaikh and Sujit Biswas.

The State’s cases, Naresh and Bhagwan Jagannath Markad, apply where identification rests on independent, untainted circumstances. The judge held the parade identification vitiated and unusable to connect the petitioners with the crime.

One recovery, two verdicts

The judge called the doctrine of parity a facet of Article 14. Where co-accused face the same allegations and the same quality of evidence, a court cannot acquit one and convict another.

The prosecution alleged identical house-search recoveries of third-party ATM cards against Mr Nabi Sk. and the petitioners. The magistrate disbelieved the recoveries for him and honourably acquitted him, then convicted the petitioners on the same flawed, unsealed recoveries. The appellate court glossed over the anomaly.

He drew support from Javed Shaukat Ali Qureshi and the Division Bench decision in Manjur Sk. @ Manjur Shaikh. The convictions, he held, cannot stand on any known principle of judicial consistency.

Past cases and a shifted burden

The trial court, he found, leaned on unverified criminal histories and pending cases of the petitioners as proof of criminal propensity. Such antecedents are not substantive proof of the offence on trial. At best they may count at sentencing, if a conviction is first secured on admissible evidence.

In examining the accused under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the magistrate also drew adverse inferences for failing to prove innocence. That shifted the burden onto the defence, the judge held, though the prosecution must prove its case from beginning to end.

When a revision court may step in

Justice Kumar acknowledged the limits of revisional jurisdiction under Sections 397 and 401, where re-appreciation of evidence is generally discouraged. Where concurrent findings rest on no evidence, on inadmissible material and on disregard of settled principles, he held, they become perverse and justify interference. He cited Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan and Manjir Chatterjee.

He found monumental perversity, total non-appreciation of evidence and gross errors of law in both judgments below.

Order

CRR 1781 of 2022 was allowed. The appellate judgment of 15 March 2022 and the conviction and sentence of 16 November 2021 in Cyber Crime P.S. Case No. 05 of 2019 were set aside.

Dilwar Hossain and Mehebub Alam were acquitted of the charges under Sections 419/120B and 420/120B of the IPC on the benefit of doubt. They were to be set at liberty forthwith if not wanted in another case, and any fine paid is to be refunded.

Interim orders were vacated and there was no order as to costs. The lower court records go back to the trial court, the case diary returns to the State’s counsel, and urgent certified copies are allowed on compliance with formalities.