Justice S. Sarkar Justice P.S. Chatterjee Calcutta HC APPEAL DISPOSED A narrow gap between two Kolkatabuildings
[ Calcutta High Court ]

Calcutta HC leaves halt on G+4 rebuild in place after report finds 69 cm gap above second floor

A Division Bench refused to disturb the status quo order of a Single Judge on a regularised building, citing the inspection report of an engineer, and asked for the writ petition to be decided within two months.

A G+4 building had already come up at Phears Lane in Kolkata when a neighbour went to court. An inspection report said that above the second floor the reconstruction kept a gap of only about 69 cm. On 17 November the Calcutta High Court declined to lift the freeze on further construction.

Justice Shampa Sarkar and Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee disposed of the owner’s appeal in FMA 839 of 2026. They did not decide the dispute. They left the Single Judge’s interim order standing and asked that the writ petition be decided quickly.

A neighbour’s objections to the rebuild

The appeal challenged an interim order dated 19 May 2026 in WPA 26880 of 2025. The Single Judge had directed status quo on the construction, which the Bench described as admittedly contrary to the sanctioned plan but regularised by the Corporation.

The writ petitioner, who claims to be an adjacent neighbour, alleged that the appellant had illegally obtained a plan to reconstruct a dilapidated structure. He said a G+4 building had already been built, and that work was continuing.

The allegation was that the required side open spaces had not been maintained. That, he said, hurt the free use of light and air.

The Bench confines itself to one order

The Bench noted that the Single Judge had passed several orders. It was told that an earlier order is also under challenge in another appeal.

It said it would make no observation on the merits of the order of 5 August 2026, and would restrict itself to the merits of the order actually impugned before it.

What the engineer’s report found

The Kolkata Municipal Corporation had filed reports during the proceeding, the last dated 18 August 2026. The Bench declined to interfere because the Single Judge had acted on the inspection report of the Executive Engineer.

That report said reconstruction was going on. Up to the second floor level there was no gap between 29 Phears Lane and 29/5A Phears Lane.

Above the second floor, one adjacent wall of 29/5A had collapsed. At reconstruction from the third floor level, a gap or open space of about 2 feet 3 inches (69 cm) had been kept up to the top of the fourth floor, and photographs were annexed.

Why the Single Judge froze the work

On reading that report, the Single Judge was prima facie satisfied that status quo should be kept. The construction and reconstruction, he thought, should not proceed.

He also formed a prima facie opinion on the regularisation. The Special Officer, Building, he thought, had regularised a major deviation, since an additional floor built without any sanction had been regularised.

The Division Bench did not accept the argument of the appellant’s counsel, Mr Kallol Basu, that the status quo order was passed without reasons. The respondent was represented by Ms Purbasha Nandy Brahma.

Two months for the writ petition

The Bench requested the Single Judge to dispose of the writ petition expeditiously, preferably within two months of communication of its order. It said it expressed no opinion on the merits of either side’s submissions.

The question of the alternative remedy that was available to the writ petitioner, it added, will also be decided by the Single Judge.

Order

The appeal and the connected application, CAN 1 of 2026, are disposed of. The Corporation’s reports are to be handed to the appellant’s Advocate-on-Record once the Corporation’s advocate issues due notice. That advocate was not present before the Bench.

Exceptions to the reports are to be filed within a week of receipt. Urgent photostat certified copies of the order are to be given to the parties on the usual undertakings.