Calcutta HC sees regime revenge in Mizoram scrapping a fully paid Rs 38 crore Kolkata land sale
A Division Bench of Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray upheld the order forcing Mizoram to convey its Ballygunge land to the highest bidder, which had paid in full, and extended the time for the State to comply by eight weeks.
The Government of Mizoram took about Rs 38.3 crore for a plot in Ballygunge, signed an agreement to sell it, and then cancelled the whole tender within four weeks of a new government taking office. On 13 November the Calcutta High Court told it to complete the sale.
Justice Arijit Banerjee, writing for a Division Bench that included Justice Apurba Sinha Ray, found no public interest that could justify the cancellation. The Bench called the decision “a clear case of regime revenge” (para 63) and dismissed the State’s appeal, with no order as to costs.
A guest house, a demolition and a sale
The land is at 24 Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, formerly Old Ballygunge Road, in Kolkata. The Government of Mizoram bought it in 1973 and built a guest house there. The State told the court it was the only Mizoram House in Kolkata until 1998.
The old building was demolished in 2020, with a new Mizoram House planned. A plan for new construction was sanctioned in 2022. The court noted that, on the records before it, the property is not in use.
On the State’s own account, the General Administration Department floated an e-tender-cum-e-auction in 2023 to sell the plot. Excel Vincom Private Limited emerged as the highest bidder. The draft sale deed, quoted in the judgment, recorded that the State was no longer interested in building and wished to sell for financial gain.
The paper trail the court read
The Bench built its account from the correspondence. On 20 July 2023 the department emailed Excel Vincom that its bid had been accepted. A letter of intent followed on 4 August 2023, and a nomination email on 7 August named the buyers.
On 6 October 2023 the Government of Mizoram and the company signed an unregistered agreement for sale. By 31 October the company reported Rs 18,98,82,000 paid by RTGS. The department accepted its suggested changes to the draft conveyance the same day and asked it to proceed.
A letter of award came on 1 December 2023. On 7 December the company accepted it and paid the balance 50%, Rs 19,18,00,000, with Rs 35,86,660 in penal interest for 57 days of extended time. On 14 December it told the department that the whole consideration, Rs 38,29,91,994 after tax deducted at source of Rs 41,94,666, had been paid.
Elections, a delay and a cancellation
General elections were announced in Mizoram in October 2023, and the new government took charge on 8 December 2023. That day the department told the company it would hear soon on execution of the deed. The company wrote on 12 December asking for speed.
On 21 December a Deputy Secretary wrote that the election had put other issues on the back burner. The newly formed government had to be briefed, and the Christmas season would slow offices. The department hoped to resume in January 2024.
Between those letters, two community bodies wrote to the Chief Minister. Kolkata Mizo Students wrote on 22 December and Calcutta Mizo Welfare Association on 27 December, both asking that the sale be stopped.
On 4 January 2024 the department issued a notification cancelling the process. It said that, although Excel Vincom had paid 100% with penal interest, disposing of the land at that juncture was against the general interest of the public.
It relied on Clause 3.1.11 of the bid document, read with Clauses 5.5 and 6.2, and said every rupee paid, including earnest money, would be refunded without compensation or interest. The company protested on 11 January.
What the Single Judge had ordered
Excel Vincom went to the High Court in WPA 1344 of 2024. On 2 April 2024 a Single Judge allowed the petition, set aside the cancellation and directed the State to execute and help register the sale deed within six weeks.
The Single Judge held that full payment, the sale agreement and a draft conveyance had created an actionable claim and a vested interest. The Single Judge saw a commercial transaction, not a policy decision, and held that Clause 3.1.11 could not be used arbitrarily.
The Single Judge also called the Rule 309 argument baseless, noting that the tender and later letters came from the same department. The State, he said, is an entity in perpetuity and cannot be swayed by the populist measures of a new regime.
The State: no title passed, no deal
Advocate General Biswajit Deb appeared for Mizoram, with four other advocates. He said the previous government had not followed Rule 309 of the General Financial Rules, 2017, and had not obtained in-principle approval from the Council of Ministers. He relied on MRF Ltd v. Manohar Parrikar.
He argued that Clause 6.2 transfers ownership and possession only on execution of a sale deed, and that Clause 3.1.11 lets the authority cancel at any stage before the deed is signed. Reading the tender otherwise, he said, would make that clause otiose.
On alternative remedy, he pointed to the arbitration clause in the agreement and said that, in effect, a writ court had decreed specific performance. He cited Municipal Council Gondia v. Divi Works and Supplies.
He added that promissory estoppel needs an executed deed and yields to public interest, that an agreement to agree does not bind, and that a party cannot approbate and reprobate. He also cited the Registration Act and the Transfer of Property Act.
The company: a bargain struck and paid for
Senior Advocate S.N. Mookherjee appeared for Excel Vincom. He took the court through the tender clauses and the correspondence and said the only step left was the conveyance. The cancellation, he argued, was plainly prompted by the change of government.
He pointed out that the plan sanctioned in August 2022 had never been acted on, and that the land lay vacant. Official documents had been disclosed only up to 30 January 2023. For February to May 2023 nothing showed any irregularity, so the court should presume official acts were regularly performed under the Evidence Act.
Relying on Shishir Realty, ABL International and Gujarat State Financial Corporation v. Lotus Hotels, he argued that the State cannot act arbitrarily even in contract. A writ court, he said, can strike down such a cancellation and order consequential relief, and promissory estoppel applies to government tenders.
Why the writ court could hear it
The Bench framed the central issue this way:
“whether or not, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the appellant State of Mizoram was justified in cancelling the entire tender process at the stage when only formal execution of the conveyance remained to be done.” (para 32)
It took the preliminary point first. The State had cited Phoenix ARC, Satyawati Tondon and Naveen Mathew Philip. The Bench noted that statutory remedies existed in all three, which is not the position here.
An arbitration clause, it held, neither did nor could take away the High Court’s writ jurisdiction. A civil suit for specific performance is a long process and, particularly where no factual dispute is involved, cannot be treated as an efficacious alternative.
Alternative remedy is not a complete bar, the Bench said, and entertaining a petition is a matter of judicial discretion. Because the Single Judge found the cancellation arbitrary, the Bench saw nothing wrong in how that discretion was used.
A mandamus is not a suit
On the complaint that the writ court had granted specific performance, the Bench distinguished Gondia. That case, it said, turned on disputed facts and an absence of material, and laid down no rule against a mandamus to honour a solemn undertaking.
It quoted Lotus Hotels, where the Supreme Court said it was too late in the day to argue that a State instrumentality could break a solemn undertaking and leave the other side to sue for damages.
The Bench also cited ABL International and Godavari Sugar Mills for three propositions. Contractual disputes with the State can be heard in writ jurisdiction, disputed facts alone are no bar, and a consequential monetary claim does not defeat the petition.
Once the State is party to a contract, it said, it must act fairly, justly and reasonably, as Article 14 requires. If it does not, a writ court can issue directions to correct the arbitrary action.
Rule 309 and the presumption of regularity
The Bench rejected the argument based on Rule 309 of the General Financial Rules. Whether the Government followed its financial rules, it said, is an internal matter of the Government of Mizoram.
A third party dealing with the Government may assume official acts were regularly performed, and the court may presume the same under Section 114, illustration (e), of the Evidence Act. It added that the State had not shown any breach of the Business Rules.
Any irregularity in the Government’s internal affairs, it said, should not defeat the accrued rights of a citizen under a binding contract. It found that the decision to sell had been conscious and well considered.
Title had not passed, but the promise had
The State had argued that until a registered conveyance is executed, it may cancel. The Bench agreed that title does not pass until then. That, it held, does not let a vendor go back on a promise to sell recorded in a duly executed agreement of sale.
Doing so, it said, would be a breach of contract that entitles the buyer to seek specific performance in a court of law. Otherwise, the Bench observed, commercial deals would become completely uncertain.
On Clause 3.1.11, the Bench said the State was putting its case too high. The clauses do reserve a right to cancel before conveyance, it accepted, but that right cannot be exercised arbitrarily, unfairly or unreasonably against a citizen.
Deferred for the polls, cancelled after them
The Bench found that the parties had taken great pains to finalise the deal. The entire consideration and penalty were deposited and accepted without demur, protest or reservation. The clauses were settled after detailed deliberation, and only the conveyance remained.
From the correspondence, it concluded that execution of the sale deed was deferred only because of the upcoming State elections. Once the elections changed the ruling party, it said, the Government performed a complete volte face and cancelled the tender.
It drew on Shishir Realty, where the Supreme Court used the phrase regime revenge and said one cannot change the rules of the game once it has started. The Government, the Bench said, cannot renege on a promise acted on by a citizen only because the regime has changed.
In its closing summary the Bench added that the new dispensation had cancelled the tender, along with the agreement of sale, without entering into any dialogue with the company.
Two letters against Rs 38 crore
The State’s case of extreme public interest rested on two letters, the 22 and 27 December 2023 representations from the Mizo community bodies. The Bench reproduced both in full.
The first described the Ballygunge Mizoram House as a refuge for Mizo students, families and professionals, of sentimental, historical and heritage value. The second asked the Chief Minister to cancel the sale at all cost and said the process had not reached its final stage.
The Bench said private interest must give way to public interest, but the public interest must be “overwhelming and demonstrable” (para 48). It found that these two representations showed nothing of the kind for a process on the verge of its logical conclusion.
It also noted that the State did not claim the deal had been struck below market value or that the exchequer would suffer. No prejudice, it said, would come to the State from sticking to its bargain.
Promissory estoppel against the Government
Rejecting the argument that estoppel does not bind the Government, the Bench held that execution of the agreement and payment of the full price created in the company, at least in equity, a right to have the property conveyed. The State came under a matching obligation.
Citing Shishir Realty, it said the Government must place material before the court to show how public interest outweighs the need to enforce a promise. A bare statement that public interest requires it is not enough. The only way out for the State was to establish overwhelming public interest, and it failed to do so.
The State’s other authorities set aside
The Bench went through the remaining cases one by one. Dressar Rand and Nikhil Adhesives concerned letters of intent, while here there was a binding contract. Dharma Naika, on Karnataka land laws for Scheduled Castes and Tribes, had no relevance.
In HUDA v. Orchid Infrastructure, no concluded contract existed. Shrijee Sales, Union of India v. VVF, Sidhbali Steels, Yamuna Expressway and Shree Durga Oil Mills all turn on public interest or equity, and the State had shown none here.
Renaissance Distilleries bars a tender participant from attacking the process afterwards, but the company never challenged it and wanted it completed. R. Hemalatha and its Registration Act provisions did not help the State, the Bench said.
Indore Vikas Praadhikaran was cited for the point that no vested right arises before acceptance. Here, the Bench said, the decision-making was completely arbitrary and a discernible vested right had arisen. It was not even the State’s case that public revenue demanded cancellation.
Order
The appeal, FMA 772 of 2024, was dismissed with no order as to costs. The Division Bench saw no reason to interfere with the Single Judge’s judgment of 2 April 2024 in WPA 1344 of 2024.
That judgment had set aside the cancellation of the tender process and directed the State to execute a sale deed for the land at 24 Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, Ballygunge, in favour of Excel Vincom and to co-operate in registration.
The time for the State to carry out the Single Judge’s order was extended by eight weeks from 13 November 2026. Urgent certified copies were allowed on compliance with the usual formalities.